This article is more than 1 year old

Mandrake Linux 8.1 easier than Win-XP

Practically installs itself

Windows addicts curious to see how the other half lives but wary of the installation challenges Linux is supposed to present will find Mandrake 8.1 considerably easier to install and configure than Win-XP. It's quite nearly Harry Homeowner-proof.

Ready for some cultural tourism? No need to hesitate; the Pro package sells for a mere $70.00, compared with XP's $300, so it's hardly a major investment even if you should run home to Redmond in the end.


The Mandrake installation beats even SuSE's, which is relatively trouble-free. The first issue for me was whether I'd get the same fatal read errors I got from Red Hat and SuSE with my CD-ROMs set to cable select, as the Dell factory likes them. This is important because Compaq, Gateway and HP also like this arrangement, and Harry is most likely using an OEM box.

With Red Hat the installation failed, and the documentation was inadequate to sort out the issue. With SuSE it failed as well, but the YaST installer prominently offers a safe-mode install, and the documentation prominently urges this whenever there's a problem. The user may never know why his first attempt failed, but his second will go all right so long as he follows directions.

Again I set up my two CD-ROMs and two HDDs with cable select, and ran Mandrake's DrakX installer. And it handled it flawlessly. I was so surprised that later I switched everything back to master/slave configs and re-installed, but that worked fine as well.

So I give an F to Red Hat for having no knowledge of the issue and no useful recommendations; a C+ to SuSE for making it easy to get it right the second time around; and an A to Mandrake for having no issue at all.

The second issue for me is my networking scheme, which, while not quite an out-of-the-box setup is by no means over the top. Perhaps a bit eccentric, by Harry standards.

I'm using a DSL modem, ethernet cards and a router to connect my machines to Verizon's DSL service. I need a PPPoE client running. Red Hat took me hours to configure; SuSE never did work due to some lame-assed PPPoE client I was told to fetch from their Web site (hello!); and Win-XP never worked right either, because it was convinced beyond a shadow of a doubt that it had already installed all the software needed to run my hardware and arrogantly refused to be corrected.

And Mandrake? It detected my ethernet card, and when I installed ADSL it popped in a handy PPPoE client and connected the first time. I mean, immediately after configuring it, without any subsequent tweaking.

As for other hardware detection, Mandrake was infallible. The drives; the wheel mouse, the keyboard, the monitor, the video card (nVidia Ge-Force AGP 64 MB), the sound card (SoundBlaster Live), all of it. All I had to do was confirm its choices every now and then.

Disk partitioning and formatting is an absolute breeze in expert mode, with a graphical menu showing all your hard drives and partitions. You just click to select a partition and it's selected in the configuration menu. It's mousey, with little sliders to set the partition sizes. (Mousey is OK with me, as is texty; what irritates me is a combination where I'm going back and forth between mouse and keyboard.)

Video gremlin

Ah, but there was one hitch. The driver for my video card with hardware acceleration which I was offered froze my machine during the boot and nothing could make it start.

There was an "experimental" driver which I didn't try. The one I did try wasn't flagged for danger, but should have been. So I had to use the driver without hardware acceleration which worked fine, and then download the right RPM from nVidia's Web site. Not a lot of trouble, but this is precisely the sort of little oversight which will drive poor Harry to distraction; and it's the only thing I encountered during several different Mandrake installations which mars an otherwise outstanding Linux eXPerience.

What to expect

There will of course be some trade-offs if you migrate from Windows. Regardless of whether you choose KDE or Gnome, the Linux desktop simply isn't as pretty. It's more configurable, certainly; the OS is more stable; you get lots of free applications; and your machine will be a lot more secure, if for no reason other than your immediate escape from that premier virus propagator Outlook.

If you're into graphics work, Linux is not your environment. But then you're already using a Mac. If you're heavily into games, then you're definitely stuck with Windows. Linux's multimedia support is crude out of the box, but there are heaps of applications and codecs for download, so this limitation can be overcome.

So what's it good for? Everyday chores, really, especially those related to the Internet. It's a fine choice if you want to surf the Web and take control of the information you're leaving behind and Web sites are leaving on your machine; good for sending and receive e-mail with fewer malware dangers (start by displaying all received messages as text only); and of course chatting and trading files with your friends on line.

In other words, it's better at most of what the majority of Windows addicts use their computers for -- wasting time on line.

Office applications are adequate, but not great. Personally I never use anything but a text editor, though many people seem to relish the distractions of word-processors and spreadsheets. Here you have several choices, none of which is as slick as its MS Office counterpart. Sun's StarOffice 5.2 is particularly loathsome, but reports indicate that version 6.0, due out in early 2002, marks a giant step forward.

Of course Linux is a great development platform if you like to roll your own, and perfect if you want to run a little Web or FTP server off your home machine. It's far cheaper, simpler and safer than using IIS over NT or 2K. (Also excellent in the enterprise space, but that's another story.)

Other virtues include 'getting clean' after years of addiction to the Microsoft upgrade scam. The sweet sensation of rehabilitation alone is worth the purchase price.

And if you'd like to eXPerience that sensation, Mandrake 8.1 is, hands down, the best way to get started. ®

Related Stories

SuSE 7.3 rocks Red Hat and flips XP the bird
Win-XP vs Red Hat 7.2
Red Hat Hell continued
Red Hat redemption

More about


Send us news

Other stories you might like