Nvidia v Qualcomm, Samsung: Thumbs up from judge in patent row

Beak says patent language means what Nv says it means


Nvidia has won an important early victory in its ongoing patent litigation against Qualcomm and Samsung, with a judge in the US International Trade Commission ruling in Nvidia's favor as to the language of the disputed patents.

"We're very pleased with the outcome of the ruling," Nvidia said in a Monday blog post, "in which claim constructions favorable to Nvidia will be applied to six out of seven disputed claims when the judge considers the question of Samsung's and Qualcomm's infringement."

The ruling was the result of a pretrial hearing, known as a "Markman hearing," in which a judge hears evidence from both sides of a patent dispute as to the specific meanings of key words in the asserted patents.

Because a Markman ruling sets the legal standard by which patents will be interpreted in an eventual jury trial, it can be an important indicator of the expected outcome of the trial as a whole.

This was the first such dance for Nvidia. As it noted in its blog post, the patent lawsuit it filed against Qualcomm and Samsung in September 2014 is the first in its 22-year history, despite holding some 7,000 issued and pending patents.

Nvidia alleges that the graphics coprocessors found in Samsung mobile phones infringe on seven of its patents – no matter whether the GPUs in question are based on ARM's Mali, Imagination Technologies' PowerVR, or Qualcomm's Adreno technology.

Neither ARM nor Imagination is named as a defendant in Nvidia's suit.

Qualcomm and Samsung both dispute Nvidia's assertions and Samsung, for one, has already struck back. The Korean firm fired off a counter-suit against Nvidia and one of its customers in November, claiming Nvidia's tech violates six of its own patents.

Samsung's suit was filed in the Eastern District of Virginia, where Nvidia's co-defendant, Velocity Micro, is headquartered. Nvidia had sought to have the case moved to its own home base of Northern California, having claimed that the only reason Samsung named Velocity at all is because Virginia "has a faster time to trial than most jurisdictions in the United States." But Nvidia said on Monday that District Judge Robert Payne denied its motion and any eventual trial will proceed in Virginia.

"We continue to believe Samsung's claims have no merit, and that Samsung's effort to sue a small company selling NVIDIA-based products in Virginia is entirely unwarranted," Nvidia said. ®

Similar topics


Other stories you might like

  • Yet again, Cream Finance skimmed by crooks: $130m in crypto assets stolen

    Third time's the unlucky charm for loan outfit

    Decentralized finance biz Cream Finance became further decentralized on Wednesday with the theft of $130m worth of crypto assets from its Ethereum lending protocol.

    Cream (cream.finance and not creamfinance.com) reported the loss via Twitter, the third such incident for the loan platform this year.

    "Our Ethereum C.R.E.A.M. v1 lending markets were exploited and liquidity was removed on October 27, 1354 UTC," the Taiwan-based biz said. "The attacker removed a total of ~$130m USD worth of tokens from these markets, using this address. No other markets were impacted."

    Continue reading
  • OpenID-based security features added to GitHub Actions as usage doubles

    Single-use tokens and reusable workflows explained at Universe event

    GitHub Universe GitHub Actions have new security based on OpenID, along with the ability to create reusable workflows, while usage has nearly doubled year on year, according to presentations at the Universe event.

    The Actions service was previewed three years ago at Universe 2018, and made generally available a year later. It was a huge feature, building automation into the GitHub platform for the first time (though rival GitLab already offered DevOps automation).

    It require compute resources, called runners, which can be GitHub-hosted or self-hosted. Actions are commands that execute on runners. Jobs are a sequence of steps that can be Actions or shell commands. Workflows are a set of jobs which can run in parallel or sequentially, with dependencies. For example, that deployment cannot take place unless build and test is successful. Actions make it relatively easy to set up continuous integration or continuous delivery, particularly since they are cloud-hosted and even a free plan offers 2,000 automation minutes per month, and more than that for public repositories.

    Continue reading
  • REvil gang member identified living luxury lifestyle in Russia, says German media

    Die Zeit: He's got a Beemer, a Bitcoin watch and a swimming pool

    German news outlets claim to have identified a member of the infamous REvil ransomware gang – who reportedly lives the life of Riley off his ill-gotten gains.

    The gang member, nicknamed Nikolay K by Die Zeit newspaper and the Bayerische Rundfunk radio station, reportedly owns a €70,000 watch with a Bitcoin address engraved on its face and rents yachts for €1,300 a day whenever he goes on holiday.

    "He seems to prefer T-shirts from Gucci, luxurious BMW sportscars and large sunglasses," reported Die Zeit, which partly identified him through social media videos posted by his wife.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021