Internet security suites fail to block exploits

Tests expose 'chocolate teapot' shortcomings


Internet security suites do little to protect users against exploits, according to security notification firm Secunia.

The Danish security notification firm is urging a root and branch rethink on how security suites are designed, moving away from "ineffective signature-based detection" to a smarter form of defence.

However, an anti-virus expert whose firm's products were not involved in the tests said Secunia's approach only tested against one aspect of how security suites protect consumers, and were therefore potentially misleading.

Secunia tested 12 suites (which typically bundle firewall, anti-malware and anti-spam functions) against a range of 300 exploits targeting vulnerabilities in various high-profile programs.

Even though it blocked only 64 out of 300 exploits, Symantec's Norton Internet Security 2009 came out best from the test, detecting almost ten times more exploits than its nearest competitor. Security suites from the likes of Kaspersky, Check Point, Microsoft, AVG and McAfee all flopped.

Security product bundles are marketed as comprehensive Internet Security Suites, leaving the impression that the user is fully protected against internet threats. Secunia's tests suggest the products fail to do what they say on the tin. Symantec has recently begun introducing behaviour-based detection, which helps to explain why its software did the best of a bad bunch.

Thomas Kristensen, chief technology officer at Secunia, said that the shortcomings of security suites combined with the fact users rarely keep systems fully patched made a recipe for trouble.

"While we did suspect that the popular security vendors would score quite poorly in detecting exploits, the extremely low detection rate took us by surprise and this really begs the question: Does the customer get their money's worth?"

Computer users therefore need to keep up to date with patches in order to have any hope of withstand hacking attacks. Secunia's free Personal Software Inspector (PSI)* and the similar functionality within Kaspersky Internet Security 2009 make it easier to keep up to date with patching.

Graham Cluley, senior technology consultant at Sophos, which focuses on the corporate market and did not take part in the tests, agreed that applying patches was important. "There's no such thing as a perfect security suite, but security software reduces threats and people shouldn't come away from these tests with the conclusion that they these products are ineffective."

Cluley added that the tested problems might do better in real world conditions rather than in the lab because of run time protection. Security products commonly scan files before they are run as well as monitoring what they are doing once they begin running. That means that although Word files harbouring 0day exploits, for example, may make it past scanners they might be prevented from running.

"They [Secunia] haven't actually "run" these exploits on the computer - so it's not really a "real-life" test of how well these security suites would perform," Cluley explained. "It sounds like only one aspect of the suites was tested, rather than all of the ways in which they might have been able to protect the users."

Secunia said its tests illustrated the shortcomings of signature-based security suites. Generic detection of exploits would be a better approach because what triggers a vulnerability (unlike the payload of an attack) doesn't alter, Kristensen pointed out.

"Even with a very rapid creation of payload-based signatures, all their customers are still left exposed for a considerable amount of time from the point when the criminals start distributing their new payload until it has been 'caught', analysed, a signature has been created, the signature has undergone quality assurance testing, the signature is published, and finally downloaded and activated by the security software," Kristensen said.

"Determining the characteristics of a vulnerability is somewhat more complicated and takes longer than than creating a payload based signature, however, it need only be created once," he continued. "Often the security vendors can finish their analysis and create a signature in the same time as the criminals can develop an exploit and start their criminal attacks."

Cluley argued that this criticism was misplaced, as security firms all moved away from signature-based detection years ago. He said modern security suites made far greater use of generic and behaviour-based detection as a way of dealing with the growing volume of malware-sample production.

A full round-up of the exploits and vulnerabilities used in the tests and a rundown of results can be found here (pdf). ®</p

Similar topics

Broader topics


Other stories you might like

  • How refactoring code in Safari's WebKit resurrected 'zombie' security bug
    Fixed in 2013, reinstated in 2016, exploited in the wild this year

    A security flaw in Apple's Safari web browser that was patched nine years ago was exploited in the wild again some months ago – a perfect example of a "zombie" vulnerability.

    That's a bug that's been patched, but for whatever reason can be abused all over again on up-to-date systems and devices – or a bug closely related to a patched one.

    In a write-up this month, Maddie Stone, a top researcher on Google's Project Zero team, shared details of a Safari vulnerability that folks realized in January this year was being exploited in the wild. This remote-code-execution flaw could be abused by a specially crafted website, for example, to run spyware on someone's device when viewed in their browser.

    Continue reading
  • Cisco warns of security holes in its security appliances
    Bugs potentially useful for rogue insiders, admin account hijackers

    Cisco has alerted customers to another four vulnerabilities in its products, including a high-severity flaw in its email and web security appliances. 

    The networking giant has issued a patch for that bug, tracked as CVE-2022-20664. The flaw is present in the web management interface of Cisco's Secure Email and Web Manager and Email Security Appliance in both the virtual and hardware appliances. Some earlier versions of both products, we note, have reached end of life, and so the manufacturer won't release fixes; it instead told customers to migrate to a newer version and dump the old.

    This bug received a 7.7 out of 10 CVSS severity score, and Cisco noted that its security team is not aware of any in-the-wild exploitation, so far. That said, given the speed of reverse engineering, that day is likely to come. 

    Continue reading
  • If you're using older, vulnerable Cisco small biz routers, throw them out
    Severe security flaw won't be fixed – as patches released this week for other bugs

    If you thought you were over the hump with Patch Tuesday then perhaps think again: Cisco has just released fixes for a bunch of flaws, two of which are not great.

    First on the priority list should be a critical vulnerability in its enterprise security appliances, and the second concerns another critical bug in some of its outdated small business routers that it's not going to fix. In other words, junk your kit or somehow mitigate the risk.

    Both of these received a CVSS score of 9.8 out of 10 in severity. The IT giant urged customers to patch affected security appliances ASAP if possible, and upgrade to newer hardware if you're still using an end-of-life, buggy router. We note that miscreants aren't actively exploiting either of these vulnerabilities — yet.

    Continue reading
  • Symantec: More malware operators moving in to exploit Follina
    Meanwhile Microsoft still hasn't patched the fatal flaw

    While enterprises are still waiting for Microsoft to issue a fix for the critical "Follina" vulnerability in Windows, yet more malware operators are moving in to exploit it.

    Microsoft late last month acknowledged the remote code execution (RCE) vulnerability – tracked as CVE-2022-30190 – but has yet to deliver a patch for it. The company has outlined workarounds that can be used until a fix becomes available.

    In the meantime, reports of active exploits of the flaw continue to surface. Analysts with Proofpoint's Threat Insight team earlier this month tweeted about a phishing campaign, possibly aligned with a nation-state targeting US and European Union agencies, which uses Follina. The Proofpoint researchers said the malicious spam messages were sent to fewer than 10 Proofpoint product users.

    Continue reading
  • Azure issues not adequately fixed for months, complain bug hunters
    Redmond kicks off Patch Tuesday with a months-old flaw fix

    Updated Two security vendors – Orca Security and Tenable – have accused Microsoft of unnecessarily putting customers' data and cloud environments at risk by taking far too long to fix critical vulnerabilities in Azure.

    In a blog published today, Orca Security researcher Tzah Pahima claimed it took Microsoft several months to fully resolve a security flaw in Azure's Synapse Analytics that he discovered in January. 

    And in a separate blog published on Monday, Tenable CEO Amit Yoran called out Redmond for its lack of response to – and transparency around – two other vulnerabilities that could be exploited by anyone using Azure Synapse. 

    Continue reading
  • Halfords suffers a puncture in the customer details department
    I like driving in my car, hope my data's not gone far

    UK automobile service and parts seller Halfords has shared the details of its customers a little too freely, according to the findings of a security researcher.

    Like many, cyber security consultant Chris Hatton used Halfords to keep his car in tip-top condition, from tires through to the annual safety checks required for many UK cars.

    In January, Hatton replaced a tire on his car using a service from Halfords. It's a simple enough process – pick a tire online, select a date, then wait. A helpful confirmation email arrived with a link for order tracking. A curious soul, Hatton looked at what was happening behind the scenes when clicking the link and "noticed some API calls that seemed ripe for an IDOR" [Insecure Direct Object Reference].

    Continue reading
  • For a few days earlier this year, rogue GitHub apps could have hijacked countless repos
    A bit of a near-hit for the software engineering world

    A GitHub bug could have been exploited earlier this year by connected third-party apps to hijack victims' source-code repositories.

    For almost a week in late February and early March, rogue applications could have generated scoped installation tokens with elevated permissions, allowing them to gain otherwise unauthorized write or administrative access to developers' repos. For example, if an app was granted read-only access to an organization or individual's code repo, the app could effortlessly escalate that to read-write access.

    This security blunder has since been addressed and before any miscreants abused the flaw to, for instance, alter code and steal secrets and credentials, according to Microsoft's GitHub, which assured The Register it's "committed to investigating reported security issues."

    Continue reading
  • CISA and friends raise alarm on critical flaws in industrial equipment, infrastructure
    Nearly 60 holes found affecting 'more than 30,000' machines worldwide

    Updated Fifty-six vulnerabilities – some deemed critical – have been found in industrial operational technology (OT) systems from ten global manufacturers including Honeywell, Ericsson, Motorola, and Siemens, putting more than 30,000 devices worldwide at risk, according to private security researchers. 

    Some of these vulnerabilities received CVSS severity scores as high as 9.8 out of 10. That is particularly bad, considering these devices are used in critical infrastructure across the oil and gas, chemical, nuclear, power generation and distribution, manufacturing, water treatment and distribution, mining and building and automation industries. 

    The most serious security flaws include remote code execution (RCE) and firmware vulnerabilities. If exploited, these holes could potentially allow miscreants to shut down electrical and water systems, disrupt the food supply, change the ratio of ingredients to result in toxic mixtures, and … OK, you get the idea.

    Continue reading
  • DeadBolt ransomware takes another shot at QNAP storage
    Keep boxes updated and protected to avoid a NAS-ty shock

    QNAP is warning users about another wave of DeadBolt ransomware attacks against its network-attached storage (NAS) devices – and urged customers to update their devices' QTS or QuTS hero operating systems to the latest versions.

    The latest outbreak – detailed in a Friday advisory – is at least the fourth campaign by the DeadBolt gang against the vendor's users this year. According to QNAP officials, this particular run is encrypting files on NAS devices running outdated versions of Linux-based QTS 4.x, which presumably have some sort of exploitable weakness.

    The previous attacks occurred in January, March, and May.

    Continue reading
  • Now Windows Follina zero-day exploited to infect PCs with Qbot
    Data-stealing malware also paired with Black Basta ransomware gang

    Miscreants are reportedly exploiting the recently disclosed critical Windows Follina zero-day flaw to infect PCs with Qbot, thus aggressively expanding their reach.

    The bot's operators are also working with the Black Basta gang to spread ransomware in yet another partnership in the underground world of cyber-crime, it is claimed.

    This combination of Follina exploitation and its use to extort organizations makes the malware an even larger threat for enterprises. Qbot started off as a software nasty that raided people's online bank accounts, and evolved to snoop on user keystrokes and steal sensitive information from machines. It can also deliver other malware payloads, such as backdoors and ransomware, onto infected Windows systems, and forms a remote-controllable botnet.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022