Hoaxed US Chamber thumps pranksters with blunt instrument

Can you DMCA a parody that looks like the real thing?


With this week's lesson in the vagaries of copyright law, we seek to answer the following question: If someone uses your copyrighted material to build a website that fools a Reuters reporter into thinking you've suddenly changed your mind, are you legally empowered to destroy their clever online hoax with a DMCA takedown notice?

Last week, a group of swashbuckling pranksters calling themselves The Yes Men put out an online press release purporting to come from the US Chamber of Commerce. The faux release announced that the Chamber had reversed its controversial opposition to greenhouse gas legislation, and the Yes Men even went to far as to hold a faux press conference, posing as Chamber men.

The faux press conference was interrupted when a (real) Chamber man showed and started saying things like "This is a fraudulent press conference!" You can see the entire episode here:

But such protests from the (real) Chamber came too late to prevent a Reuters news service reporter from penning a story based on the faux press release. The story soon turned up at The Washington Post and The New York Times.

After the hoax was revealed, the faux release remained online, and the (real) Chamber couldn't leave well enough alone. It soon tossed a DMCA takedown notice the Yes Men's ISP, Hurricane Electric, insisting the press release infringed on their copyrights "by directly copying the images, logos, design and layout of the Chamber of Commerce’s copyright-protected official website."

Hurricane did indeed take the release down. According to Wired, the ISP obeys alltakedown notices - whether they're legally sound or not. But another outfit, Hosting.com, quickly put the release back up. And it's still up.

The Net watchdogs at EFF have come out against the Chamber's DMCA tactics, demanding the takedown notice be rescinded. "We are very disappointed the Chamber of Commerce decided to respond to political criticism with legal threats," EFF staff attorney Corynne McSherry said from inside a press release.

"The site is obviously intended to highlight and parody the Chamber's controversial views, which have sparked political debate and led high-profile members to withdraw their support from the Chamber." Parody is protected under copyright law and the First Amendment, which means it can stand up to a DMCA takedown.

But we can't help but wonder if the faux release crosses that line between parody and stark imitation. To be sure, the release uses some, shall we say, heightened language.

"Climatologists tell us that if we don't enact dramatic reductions in carbon emissions today, within 5 years we could begin facing the propagating feedback loops of runaway climate change. That would mean a disruption of food and water supplies worldwide, with the result of mass migrations, famines, and death on a scale never witnessed before," read the faux prepared remarks from Chamber president and CEO Thomas J. Donohue. "Needless to say, that would be bad for business."

But some were fooled - at least initially. That includes not only Reuters but Mother Jones, a site that has closely followed - and criticized - the Chamber's views on climate change.

Speaking with The Reg, EFF senior staff attorney Matt Zimmerman is adamant that the faux release is a parody because it was intended as a parody. "I would argue that a parody is more effective if it gives the reader/viewer, even for a moment, the impression that the work came from the target of the criticism. A work hardly carries the same artistic impact if it's immediately clear that the work is a spoof," he says.

"'The purpose and character of the use' prong doesn't include an 'obviousness' requirement. The Chamber loses on that prong if it can't show that the 'purpose and character of the use' was not for criticism and commentary. Even someone who was initially confused can't honestly argue that the purpose of the spoof was for purposes other than criticism and commentary."

But others disagree. Regardless of what the intention was, says Mike Rodenbaugh, principal in the San Francisco intellectual property firm Rodenbaugh Law, the Yes Men hoax doesn't pass the parody test. "Taking [the Chamber's] entire web site design and completely fooling people crosses the line," he tells The Reg. "I don’t believe they have an argument for fair use."

Jonathan Handel, an IP lawyer with the California firm Troy & Gould, doesn't go quite so far. But he says that at the very least, the hoax lies in a gray area between parody and imitation. "It’s tough when you start to do street theatre on a computer," he says. "There’s no way of signaling that it’s a parody."

Referring to the EFF's argument that the intention of parody makes it a parody, Handel says: "That cuts a very fine line." He can see the faux Chamber's argument - but he can see the (real) Chamber's argument as well.

What we can say for certain is that this rather amusing episode clearly that the DMCA takedown is "a blunt instrument," as Handel calls it. The law is ridiculously flawed - especially when ISPs like Hurricane respond to takedowns without even reading them.

And then there's the familiar irony of such DMCA madness. In the end, the (real) Chamber men played right into the hands of the faux Chamber men. There's no parody like self-parody. ®


Other stories you might like

  • IBM settles age discrimination case that sought top execs' emails
    Just days after being ordered to provide messages, Big Blue opts out of public trial

    Less than a week after IBM was ordered in an age discrimination lawsuit to produce internal emails in which its former CEO and former SVP of human resources discuss reducing the number of older workers, the IT giant chose to settle the case for an undisclosed sum rather than proceed to trial next month.

    The order, issued on June 9, in Schenfeld v. IBM, describes Exhibit 10, which "contains emails that discuss the effort taken by IBM to increase the number of 'millennial' employees."

    Plaintiff Eugene Schenfeld, who worked as an IBM research scientist when current CEO Arvind Krishna ran IBM's research group, sued IBM for age discrimination in November, 2018. His claim is one of many that followed a March 2018 report by ProPublica and Mother Jones about a concerted effort to de-age IBM and a 2020 finding by the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) that IBM executives had directed managers to get rid of older workers to make room for younger ones.

    Continue reading
  • FTC urged to probe Apple, Google for enabling ‘intense system of surveillance’
    Ad tracking poses a privacy and security risk in post-Roe America, lawmakers warn

    Democrat lawmakers want the FTC to investigate Apple and Google's online ad trackers, which they say amount to unfair and deceptive business practices and pose a privacy and security risk to people using the tech giants' mobile devices.

    US Senators Ron Wyden (D-OR), Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), and Cory Booker (D-NJ) and House Representative Sara Jacobs (D-CA) requested on Friday that the watchdog launch a probe into Apple and Google, hours before the US Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, clearing the way for individual states to ban access to abortions. 

    In the days leading up to the court's action, some of these same lawmakers had also introduced data privacy bills, including a proposal that would make it illegal for data brokers to sell sensitive location and health information of individuals' medical treatment.

    Continue reading
  • Behold this drone-dropping rifle with two-mile range
    Confuses rather than destroys unmanned aerials to better bring back intel, says Ukrainian designer

    What's said to be a Ukrainian-made long-range anti-drone rifle is one of the latest weapons to emerge from Russia's ongoing invasion of its neighbor.

    The Antidron KVS G-6 is manufactured by Kvertus Technology, in the western Ukraine region of Ivano-Frankivsk, whose capital of the same name has twice been subjected to Russian bombings during the war. Like other drone-dropping equipment, we're told it uses radio signals to interrupt control, remotely disabling them, and it reportedly has an impressive 3.5 km (2.17 miles) range.

    "We are not damaging the drone. With communication lost, it just loses coordination and doesn't know where to go. The drone lands where it is jammed, or can be carried away by the wind because it's uncontrollable,"  Kvertus' director of technology Yaroslav Filimonov said. Because the downed drones are unharmed, they give Ukrainian soldiers recovering them a wealth of potential intelligence, he added.  

    Continue reading
  • Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise adds Wi-Fi 6E to 'premium' access points
    Company claims standard will improve performance in dense environments

    Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise is the latest networking outfit to add Wi-Fi 6E capability to its hardware, opening up access to the less congested 6GHz spectrum for business users.

    The France-based company just revealed the OmniAccess Stellar 14xx series of wireless access points, which are set for availability from this September. Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise said its first Wi-Fi 6E device will be a high-end "premium" Access Point and will be followed by a mid-range product by the end of the year.

    Wi-Fi 6E is compatible with the Wi-Fi 6 standard, but adds the ability to use channels in the 6GHz portion of the spectrum, a feature that will be built into the upcoming Wi-Fi 7 standard from the start. This enables users to reduce network contention, or so the argument goes, as the 6GHz portion of the spectrum is less congested with other traffic than the existing 2.4GHz and 5GHz frequencies used for Wi-Fi access.

    Continue reading
  • Will Lenovo ever think beyond hardware?
    Then again, why develop your own software à la HPE GreenLake when you can use someone else's?

    Analysis Lenovo fancies its TruScale anything-as-a-service (XaaS) platform as a more flexible competitor to HPE GreenLake or Dell Apex. Unlike its rivals, Lenovo doesn't believe it needs to mimic all aspects of the cloud to be successful.

    While subscription services are nothing new for Lenovo, the company only recently consolidated its offerings into a unified XaaS service called TruScale.

    On the surface TruScale ticks most of the XaaS boxes — cloud-like consumption model, subscription pricing — and it works just like you'd expect. Sign up for a certain amount of compute capacity and a short time later a rack full of pre-plumbed compute, storage, and network boxes are delivered to your place of choosing, whether that's a private datacenter, colo, or edge location.

    Continue reading
  • Intel is running rings around AMD and Arm at the edge
    What will it take to loosen the x86 giant's edge stranglehold?

    Analysis Supermicro launched a wave of edge appliances using Intel's newly refreshed Xeon-D processors last week. The launch itself was nothing to write home about, but a thought occurred: with all the hype surrounding the outer reaches of computing that we call the edge, you'd think there would be more competition from chipmakers in this arena.

    So where are all the AMD and Arm-based edge appliances?

    A glance through the catalogs of the major OEMs – Dell, HPE, Lenovo, Inspur, Supermicro – returned plenty of results for AMD servers, but few, if any, validated for edge deployments. In fact, Supermicro was the only one of the five vendors that even offered an AMD-based edge appliance – which used an ageing Epyc processor. Hardly a great showing from AMD. Meanwhile, just one appliance from Inspur used an Arm-based chip from Nvidia.

    Continue reading
  • NASA's Psyche mission: 2022 launch is off after software arrives late
    Launch window slides into 2023 or 2024 for asteroid-probing project

    Sadly for NASA's mission to take samples from the asteroid Psyche, software problems mean the spacecraft is going to miss its 2022 launch window.

    The US space agency made the announcement on Friday: "Due to the late delivery of the spacecraft's flight software and testing equipment, NASA does not have sufficient time to complete the testing needed ahead of its remaining launch period this year, which ends on October 11."

    While it appears the software and testbeds are now working, there just isn't enough time to get everything done before a SpaceX Falcon Heavy sends the spacecraft to study a metallic-rich asteroid of the same name.

    Continue reading
  • Rise in Taiwanese energy prices may hit global chip production
    National provider considering cost increase of 8%, which could be passed on to tech customers

    Taiwan's state-owned energy company is looking to raise prices for industrial users, a move likely to impact chipmakers such as TSMC, which may well have a knock-on effect on the semiconductor supply chain.

    According to Bloomberg, the Taiwan Power Company, which produces electricity for the island nation, has proposed increasing electricity costs by at least 8 percent for industrial users, the first increase in four years.

    The power company has itself been hit by the rising costs of fuel, including the imported coal and natural gas it uses to generate electricity. At the same time, the country is experiencing record demand for power because of increasing industrial requirements and because of high temperatures driving the use of air conditioning, as reported by the local Taipei Times.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022