Mystery co. sues Apple, IBM, Microsoft, Adobe, Oracle...

'Software installation? We own it!'

34 Reg comments Got Tips?

An east-Texas company, BetaNet LLC, has filed a patent-infringement suit against Apple, Microsoft, Adobe, Oracle, IBM, SAP, and a dozen other companies.

The patent in question, "Secure system for activating personal computer software at remote locations," describes in sweeping terms a remote software installation and registration process that - at first blush - appears to be similar if not identical to the standard activation system used by a vast array of software.

Exactly who or what is BetaNet LLC, and what is their relationship with the asignee of the original patent, Tau Systems Corporation? And seeing as how the patent was granted to Tau Systems in 1993, why the wait of over 16 years to claim infringment?

We asked those and other questions of BetaNet's lawyer in the Longview, Texas offices of Spangler Law, P.C., a firm specializing in patent-infringement cases, and he declined to respond, even refusing to identify BetaNet. His repeated comment: "I'm sorry but I have no comment."

The full list of defendants in the lawsuit, filed in the US District Court of Eastern Texas, is an impressive cadre of deep-pocket targets: Adobe, Apple, Arial Software, Autodesk, Carbonite, Corel, Kodak, IBM, Intuit, Microsoft, McAfee, Online Holdings, Oracle, Rockwell, Rosetta Stone, SAP, Siemens, and Sony.

The abstract of patent #5,222,134, the core of the dispute, describes a system in which, after registration, an "overlay" is transmitted to the licensee's computer that "includes critical portions of the main program, without which the main program would not operate and also contains licensee identification and license control data."

In the suit, specific applications are called out as infringing on the patent. Apple, for example, is said to infringe upon it in iTunes, Aperture, QuickTime, and MobileMe. Considering that iTunes and QuickTime are free and thus don't require registration (an email address is reqested, but not required), it's difficult to understand how the "the main program would not operate", as described in the patent, without the aforementioned "overlay."

Other specifically cited apps seem iffy, as well, such as Adobe Acrobat - which isn't an app, per se, but actually a family of apps that includes the free Acrobat Reader.

Such oversight may simply be sloppy lawyering, but there are plenty of other paid apps cited in the suit, from Adobe Creative Suite to Microsoft Office to SAP Xcelsius and more. Many more. ®

Bootnote

If the terms "patent" and "US District Court of Eastern Texas" ring a bell, it may be because that's the court in which a judge granted an injunction this August to prevent Microsoft from selling Word because it infringed on a patent owned by Canadian software firm i4i. Redmond's appeal of that judgment was heard in late September, with a decision expected soon.

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR WEEKLY TECH NEWSLETTER


Keep Reading

Caltech takes billion-dollar bite out of Apple, Broadcom for using its patented Wi-Fi tech without paying a penny

Knock knock knock: Give us the money! Knock knock knock: Give us the money!

Caltech to Apple, Broadcom: You know that $1.1bn you owe for ripping off Wi-Fi patents? Double it, hotshots

US uni goes full honey badger on iPhone giant and its chip sidekick

Broadcom sends its England-based staff back into office as UK lockdown eases – though Welsh workers get a free pass

'Split-shift model' to safely help 'critical infrastructure workforce' do its thing

If there's something strange in Symantec's neighborhood, who you gonna call? Not Broadcom, it seems: Systems go down, cut off customers

And now back on their feet after global two-hour wobble

Sure is wild that Apple, Google app store monopolies are way worse than what Windows got up to, sniffs Microsoft prez

Analysis 'Far more formidable gates to access to other applications than anything that existed in the industry 20 years ago'

Apple-Google COVID-19 virus contact-tracing API to bar location-tracking access

Renamed 'ExposureNotification' will only only one app per nation

First it was toilet paper. Then pasta. Now Broadcom suspects hoarders are behind its surprisingly good-looking Q2 sales

But warns things probably aren’t great long term, which HPE has just done too

Broadcom sues Netflix for its success: You’re stopping us making a fortune from set-top boxes, moans chip designer

Where there's a hit, there's a writ

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020