Bitcoinica sued for $460,000 by 'out-of-pocket' punters

Virtual bank accused of holding onto dosh after heist


The operators of a website that earlier this year reported that a hacker had stolen units of virtual currency worth hundreds of thousands of pounds are being sued by four users that claim to be owed more than $460,000.

According to documents submitted to a US court, four users of the Bitcoinica website have sued those involved in running the site, claiming that they have "knowingly and willfully conspired and agreed upon themselves to hinder, delay and deprive" them of their right to withdraw their money from the site.

In addition the four users claim that those involved "acted willfully and with the intent to cause injury" to them and that therefore they had been "guilty of malice, oppression and/or fraud in conscious disregard" for their rights and should be liable to pay "punitive damages".

In May the Bitcoinica site, which allowed users to trade real currency for virtual Bitcoin units (BTC), announced that 18,547 BTC had been stolen by a hacker of its systems. Currently a BTC is worth approximately $10. The operators said at the time that it would honour all "withdrawal requests" from those that had made deposits via its exchange. It subsequently announced that those making such claims would be provided with 50% of what they claimed in an initial payment.

More than 43,000 BTC were reportedly stolen from Bitcoinica following a hacking incident in March.

Since the second breach Bitcoinica has remained closed to trading whilst "the transitional process" for upgrading the exchange "to a professional level of security" is completed. The four users have only been able to withdraw half their money from the site and are claiming that those involved in running the site have acted in breach of contract by failing to repay $460,457.20 they claim they are still owed, according to the court documents.

Copyright © 2012, Out-Law.com

Out-Law.com is part of international law firm Pinsent Masons.

Similar topics

Broader topics


Other stories you might like

  • Don't hate on cryptomining, hate the power stations, say Bitcoin super-fans
    We're not the ones telling them to burn fossil fuels, top names write in response to probe request

    Big names in Bitcoin have defended cryptocurrency mining, issuing a jointly signed letter hitting back at US lawmakers who last month urged a government watchdog to probe the practice.

    Twitter founder and Bitcoin champion Jack Dorsey, the CEO of Bitcoin-collecting MicroStrategy Michael Saylor, and others on Monday signed the letter [PDF] that is a point-by-point rebuttal to a memo [PDF] sent last month to America's Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) by Representative Jared Huffman (D-CA) and a couple dozen other Democrats.

    In that first letter, Huffman and pals asked the EPA to probe proof-of-work cryptocurrency mining facilities to ensure they're following US laws such as the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, and not having an outsized effect on climate change. Proof-of-work cryptocurrencies include Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Monero. Ethereum, for one, is planning to move to fully proof-of-stake approach, which is more energy efficient.

    Continue reading
  • Wiki community votes to stop accepting cryptocurrency donations
    Cryptocurrencies make up less than 1% of wiki donations, but as member points out, that $130k could pay a salary

    The wiki community held a vote as to whether the Wikimedia Foundation should continue to accept cryptocurrency donations, the result of which was a resounding "no".

    The proposal was made by Wikipedia administrator, checkuser and oversighter GorillaWarfare based on three points: it could be seen as an endorsement of cryptocurrency by the organization; the tech is not environmentally sustainable; and, last of all, accepting crypto could damage the reputation of the foundation.

    The Wikimedia Foundation currently accepts donations in Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash and Ethereum, as well as traditional payment types. According to the community, crypto is one of the foundation's smallest revenue channels, making up a mere .08 percent of 2021 revenue, equating to $130,100. Total revenue for 2021 was around $162 million.

    Continue reading
  • Crypto inferno: Intel's Bitcoin-mining Blockscale ASIC to arrive in Q3
    Gelsinger's firm drops details on crypto chip – including hash rate of up to 580GHps

    Intel has disclosed more details of its Blockscale ASIC, the firm's entry into the realm of cryptocurrency mining with a dedicated chip built to provide users with energy-efficient hashing for proof-of-work consensus networks.

    As previously revealed, the chip now identified as the Intel Blockscale ASIC is designed to provide hardware acceleration for SHA-256 (Secure Hash Algorithm-256) processing for blockchain proof-of-work applications. It will start shipping in the third quarter of 2022.

    Intel has now claimed that its Blockscale ASIC has a hash rate of up to 580GHps, or giga hashes per second, and can support up to 256 integrated circuits per chain. The latter means that a customer could theoretically build and operate a mining system comprising 256 of the Blockscale chips, which would be capable of over 148THps, or tera hashes per second.

    Continue reading
  • Europe advances crypto-coin regulation – without potential ban on Bitcoin
    Vote held after red-tape targeting proof-of-work assets removed

    Europe's lawmakers this week moved ahead with their proposed cryptocurrency regulations, having ditched a rule that might have banned financial services from dealing in Bitcoin and Ethereum.

    The European Union is considering ways to regulate digital coins, particularly to stamp out money laundering, and as such in 2020 drew up a draft framework dubbed the Markets in Crypto Assets (MiCA) to achieve this. During the development of this red tape, an amendment was proposed that, depending on its interpretation, could have made it illegal for app and web services to handle transactions involving proof-of-work coins, such as Bitcoin and Ethereum.

    Proof-of-work algorithms underpin these cryptocurrencies, how they are mined, and how transactions are confirmed by the network. These algorithms have been criticized for being computationally intensive and consuming large amounts of energy, prompting some lawmakers to propose restrictions. Under the European Green Deal, member states are trying to slash greenhouse gas emissions, and are heavily scrutinizing activities like running proof-of-work algorithms.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022