This article is more than 1 year old
Chick-lit star snubs Menshn.com password flaw alert
'Snippy geek' finds fresh holes in MP's web-jabber thing
Updated A security researcher has warned of new vulnerabilities in Tory MP and former chick-lit queen Louise Mensch's three-month-old chatroom-cum-microblogging service.
A "trivial" CSRF attack (cross-site request forgery) can change a Menshn.com user's password, according to developer Danny Moules. El Reg has seen proof-of-concept code developed by Moules (@Rushyo) – which has not been publicly released – that backs up his concerns. Assuming targets are logged into Menshn.com, any third-party site might be able to change a victim's Menshn password and registered email address, by using the unresolved CSRF vulnerability on the site to forge requests.
However, both Louise Mensch and the site's co-founder Luke Bozier, a one-time Labour party flack who defected to the Tories earlier this year, were quick to dismiss concerns about the alleged flaw when approached for comment by El Reg.
Bozier responded: "My official response to the security hole would be that we take all of these things very seriously and where there are flaws we fix them straight away. As with any piece of technology, there is always a chance of vulnerabilities - the important thing is to ensure they're fixed rapidly. I maintain that no user data has been stolen and menshn goes above and beyond to ensure the platform is secure, including the use of https encryption as a basic requirement for all users."*
Mensch added: "Passwords are encrypted: HTTPS."
Menshn.com was the subject of a barrage of criticism from security experts when it launched in the UK back in June. Bozier described critics at the time as "snippy geeks".
Since its launch, Menshn has mandated the use of an SSL encrypted tunnel for password exchange and applied a basic filter to stop basic XSS (cross-site scripting) attacks. However many problems remain, according to Moules.
Moules told El Reg: "The CSRF is just the latest in a long list of issues they've had, many of which are still at large. Some people are actively exploiting some XSS holes using a technique that I warned them about months ago (a 'social network worm', so to speak)."
Nick Shearer, a London-based mobile software engineer, who was among the first to document XSS issues on Menshn.com back in June, said that the latest CSRF flaw warning is all too credible.
"It definitely looks sound. I haven't tested it because CSRF attacks are a bit more serious than XSS scripting, and English law takes a fairly backwards view of doing this sort of thing, even with the best of intentions. But there's nothing in that code that suggests it's not a real exploit," he told El Reg.
Menshn.com social network aims to differentiate from other web jabber services such as Twitter by offering online chat rooms featuring on-topic discussion around a particular theme, such as UK politics or the Paralympics. Posted comments are deleted after a week and Menshn promises to offer an environment free of spam and trolls. ®
Sadly, the quote below – originally attributed to Bozier and which had already been a contender for El Reg glory in our Quote of a Week column – actually originated from a Twitter impersonator, according to the Menshn co-founder:
Not true at all. Menshn is 100% secure. There has never been a CSRF attack and I'm sure I know how to Google what that is.