This article is more than 1 year old
Google cyber-knight lances Microsoft for bug-hunter 'hostilities'
While revealing a Windows 0-day security flaw
Top Google engineer Tavis Ormandy has slammed Microsoft for apparently treating security bug hunters with “great hostility”.
He blasted Redmond's behaviour towards those who report vulnerabilities as he publicly revealed a new unpatched security hole in the Windows operating system - a bug that can be exploited to crash systems or gain administrator privileges. The vulnerable driver is present in "all currently supported versions" of Windows, according to the Googler.
Ormandy discovered the flaw in the bezier curve-handling bit of the Win32k.sys kernel-level driver in March. However, triggering Microsoft's programming cock-up was difficult and at first the results were unpredictable.
In short, the "next" pointer in a double-linked list of graphical objects is not initialised by the kernel. By putting the Windows memory allocator under pressure, so that it reuses memory previously edited by the user, it is possible to prime this vulnerable "next" pointer so that the kernel follows it into a block of user-controlled memory. Exploiting this to write arbitrary data to sensitive areas of the system, to elevate privileges for example, is left as an exercise for the reader.
In a related post on his personal blog, Ormandy invited others to look into the flaw, before finishing the essay with trenchant criticism of Redmond's attitude towards computer security professionals.
“Note that Microsoft treat vulnerability researchers with great hostility, and are often very difficult to work with. I would advise only speaking to them under a pseudonym, using Tor and anonymous email to protect yourself,” he warned.
The Windows software giant is understood to be investigating the Win32k.sys issue highlighted by Ormandy. It's unclear if or when a possible patch may arrive. The corporation declined to respond to Ormandy's criticism, which although sincere is out of step with the opinion of many bug hunters we've spoken to over recent years: while Microsoft is praised for eventually engaging the computer security community, it's usually Oracle and Apple that are spoken about through gritted teeth.
Vulnerability management specialists Secunia warned that the flaw discovered by Ormandy can be used to launch denial-of-service assaults or elevate a local user's privilege. The danger is that the bug could be combined with other security flaws to carry out attacks remotely. Secunia classified the flaw as "less critical", which is towards the bottom end of its scale of severity.
“The vulnerability is caused due to an error within 'win32k.sys' when processing certain objects and can be exploited to cause a crash or execute arbitrary code with the kernel privilege,” Secunia noted in its advisory.
“The vulnerability is confirmed on a fully patched Windows 7 x86 Professional (win32k.sys version 6.1.7601.18126) and reported on Windows 8. Other versions may also be affected,” it added.
Ormandy has had dust-ups with other vendors over security bugs in the past. Three years ago he publicly disclosed a zero-day Windows XP Help Center security bug that he had notified Microsoft about only five days before. The flaw was far more serious than this latest coding blunder. In any case, Ormandy's antipathy towards Redmond's security gnomes is not a recent development.
Last year Ormandy went out of his way to criticise Sophos for “poor development practices and coding standards” after he found a number of vulnerabilities in its security software. Two years ago he accused Adobe of "trying to bury" scores of bugs in its Flash Player software. ®