Rival French mobe firms sue Orange and Vivendi's SFR for €1.4bn

Bouygues et amis demand payout after free call fracas

7 Reg comments Got Tips?

Dominant French mobile operators Orange and SFR have been hit with a compensation claim from their diminutive rivals after a court ruled their offer of free calls was anti-competitive.

Between 2005 and 2008 Orange and SFR offered customers free calls within the same network, forcing third-position operator Bouygues to offer loss-leading deals, as the two dominant players own 85 per cent of the French mobile market.

Last December, the courts ruled the free calls were anti-competitive and fined the companies €183m (£159m, $243m), paving the way for this compensation claim.

The claim is detailed, in French, by news website L'Express and we're grateful to Rude Baguette for the translation.

Bouygues has been joined by various French MVNOs (mobile virtual network operators) in the claim, and is asking for €790m (£684m, $1bn) from Orange and €650 (£563, $863m) from SFR to make up for the cost of lost customers and loss-leading deals.

Notably absent from the action is Free, which only launched 20 months ago and thus can't claim to have been damaged by tariffs which were withdrawn in 2008.

One might argue that Orange and SFR should be allowed to offer free calls within their own networks. Yet questions about monopoly abuse of this type have come up several times before and courts have generally ruled that a monopoly can exist even if it only applies to customers of a specific carrier. For example, Orange has monopoly access to Orange customers, even if that monopoly extends no further.

That's how the French court ruled in December, fining both Orange and SFR as well as releasing customers from their contracted agreements. With more than a billion euros on the table, the companies are unlikely to concede quickly and this litigation should run and run. ®

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR WEEKLY TECH NEWSLETTER


Keep Reading

Forget toilet roll, bandwidth is the new ration: Amazon, YouTube also degrade video in Europe to keep 'net running amid coronavirus crunch

Pair join Netflix to turn it down for what? Connectivity stability

TalkTalk says it's yet to close deal on FibreNation as UK telecoms industry reels over Labour's nationalisation plans

'The news overnight ... making everybody in the sector pause and consider'

UK govt finds £200,000 under sofa to kick off research into improving mobile connectivity on nation's crap railways

Do people still use trains? Anyway, wireless antennas on overhead line equipment looks like the solution

Internet samurai says he'll sell 14,700,000 IPv4 addresses worth $300m-plus, plow it all into Asia-Pacific connectivity

Special report Alternative headline: Jun Murai remembers he has a /8 under the fridge

As internet governance meetings go virtual, compromise becomes harder to reach

Asia-Pacific internet address registry strategist says smaller nations get better access – when their broadband works

If you can read this, your Windows 10 2004 PC really is connected to the internet no matter what the OS claims

May 2020 build warns of no internet connection when, er, there is

TalkTalk, UK2 sitting in a tree, not T-A-L-K-I-N-G: Hosting biz cut off after ISP broadband upgrade

Updated 'Not an issue with our network', say UK2.net techies

If there's 5G connectivity but no 5G devices on it, does it make a sound? Wait, no, that's not right

Vodafone blesses Birmingham New Street station with amazing network tech of far-flung future

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020