Has Google gone too far? Indie labels say it's crunch time for The New Economy

The Man 2.0 is far worse than The Man 1.0


Indie music labels say today's tech giants are behaving more badly than the old record industry at its worst.

At a press conference in London yesterday, the labels' reps explained why they're seeking emergency action against Google from Europe's anti-competition authorities: Google is negotiating music-streaming royalties with the indies, and they compared the internet giant's tactics to those of Amazon, which is in a dispute with publisher Hachette.

"What we’re witnessing is the collapse of a marketplace which has plurality, which has multiple choice, into individual companies being 'the market'," said Alison Wenham, chief exec of the Association of Independent Music (AIM).

"It’s quite clear that with Amazon, with Google, they are the market. They can dictate the supply chain terms to their hearts' content.

"I don't think at the dawn of the internet we ever thought we'd be looking down the wrong end of a telescope that way."

The indies say Google is trying to force labels to sign unfair terms for a forthcoming, and as yet unnamed, audio streaming service. The labels were approached individually, rather than through their collective licensing agency Merlin, and YouTube threatened to block them from its web service if they refused to sign the new deals, we're told.

Indie labels are typically cottage businesses employing anywhere from one to a handful of people – yet together employ 80 per cent of all workers in the music industry.

"Every sector of the music industry is behind this action,” one independent music publisher said. “Publishers are just as frightened. One of my copyright people was told by YouTube was told there’s no point in continuing this discussion as a publisher because my stuff would be taken down. They don’t know half of my repertoire is on Universal."

"It's a service we can ill afford to be removed from," said Mark Chung, formerly of German industrial band Einstürzende Neubauten and now a music publisher.

"I can not think of a more obvious abuse of a market dominating position that we have here."

Independent music groups including UK trade body AIM, global trade body WIN, Brussels-based IMPALA, and the Featured Artists Coalition, said they will write to the European Commission's Directorate-General for Competition within the next ten days to seek emergency measures.

It called for the directorate-general to investigate the market leverage.

"We want the European Commission to come out and say that while we’re investigating, we want YouTube not to issue any more threats, not to carry out threats in the contracts, or abide by the agreements in those contracts that were signed under threat," said IMPALA executive chairwoman Helen Smith.

Independents have had some success with European authorities before, by blocking mergers and forcing more equitable terms when giants have merged. Universal was obliged to divest significant parts of EMI before it swallowed the major UK label. UMG-EMI was also obliged to allow its digital music contracts to be examined for the next ten years.

"Google is a company that makes more money than the entire music industry combined," said Helienne Lindvall, a songwriter. "It almost makes artists long for the days when they were only being abused by major labels. At least then, artists got some investment.”

Her point was echoed by musician Billy Bragg:

I can’t believe the majors aren’t complicit in this, in some way. We should look behind the curtain of the record industry and see how it really works… and how those multinational corporations like Apple and Google are acting.

YouTube was compared to Amazon, which has been using its dominant status in retail, technically a monopsony, to force new terms on its supply chain. Amazon sells 50 per cent of books sold in the US, and offered new contracts for ebooks that one publisher Hachette refused to sign. Amazon retaliated by removing the ability to pre-order Hachette titles, and – at least according to the French publisher – slowing delivery from one to two days to two to three weeks. Hachette saw its Amazon sales hit. And in the book business, Hachette is a "major label", owning Time Warner Book Group and Hyperion.

"Amazon is the Goliath here," best-selling Hachette author Malcolm Gladwell told an interviewer. "I don’t think anyone is under any illusions it stops with Hachette.

Yesterday in London, music publisher Chung shed light on the dark side of the streaming negotiations. He said music groups resent Google's inability to promote licensed music and demote unlicensed music, and say this depresses royalty rates.

"Songwriters are negotiating with a gun to their heads. The gun is piracy," musician David Lowery wrote last year. Yesterday, Chung claimed Google was "the biggest enabler and profiteer from piracy".

Chung said it was reasonable to expect technology giants to seek a monopoly position, but said whether or not they get away with it is a test for a civilised society.

"You should probably be trying to dominate whatever market, and break any rule you can get away with breaking. It's the job of regulators and the Courts to stop that,” he said.

"If the Directorate-General for Competition do not succeed in rectifying this problem, then clearly competition law in online markets is not functioning. Which means we have to review competition law.”  ®

Similar topics

Broader topics


Other stories you might like

  • Google has more reasons why it doesn't like antitrust law that affects Google
    It'll ruin Gmail, claims web ads giant

    Google has a fresh list of reasons why it opposes tech antitrust legislation making its way through Congress but, like others who've expressed discontent, the ad giant's complaints leave out mention of portions of the proposed law that address said gripes.

    The law bill in question is S.2992, the Senate version of the American Innovation and Choice Online Act (AICOA), which is closer than ever to getting votes in the House and Senate, which could see it advanced to President Biden's desk.

    AICOA prohibits tech companies above a certain size from favoring their own products and services over their competitors. It applies to businesses considered "critical trading partners," meaning the company controls access to a platform through which business users reach their customers. Google, Apple, Amazon, and Meta in one way or another seemingly fall under the scope of this US legislation. 

    Continue reading
  • Makers of ad blockers and browser privacy extensions fear the end is near
    Overhaul of Chrome add-ons set for January, Google says it's for all our own good

    Special report Seven months from now, assuming all goes as planned, Google Chrome will drop support for its legacy extension platform, known as Manifest v2 (Mv2). This is significant if you use a browser extension to, for instance, filter out certain kinds of content and safeguard your privacy.

    Google's Chrome Web Store is supposed to stop accepting Mv2 extension submissions sometime this month. As of January 2023, Chrome will stop running extensions created using Mv2, with limited exceptions for enterprise versions of Chrome operating under corporate policy. And by June 2023, even enterprise versions of Chrome will prevent Mv2 extensions from running.

    The anticipated result will be fewer extensions and less innovation, according to several extension developers.

    Continue reading
  • I was fired for blowing the whistle on cult's status in Google unit, says contractor
    The internet giant, a doomsday religious sect, and a lawsuit in Silicon Valley

    A former Google video producer has sued the internet giant alleging he was unfairly fired for blowing the whistle on a religious sect that had all but taken over his business unit. 

    The lawsuit demands a jury trial and financial restitution for "religious discrimination, wrongful termination, retaliation and related causes of action." It alleges Peter Lubbers, director of the Google Developer Studio (GDS) film group in which 34-year-old plaintiff Kevin Lloyd worked, is not only a member of The Fellowship of Friends, the exec was influential in growing the studio into a team that, in essence, funneled money back to the fellowship.

    In his complaint [PDF], filed in a California Superior Court in Silicon Valley, Lloyd lays down a case that he was fired for expressing concerns over the fellowship's influence at Google, specifically in the GDS. When these concerns were reported to a manager, Lloyd was told to drop the issue or risk losing his job, it is claimed. 

    Continue reading
  • End of the road for biz living off free G Suite legacy edition
    Firms accustomed to freebies miffed that web giant's largess doesn't last

    After offering free G Suite apps for more than a decade, Google next week plans to discontinue its legacy service – which hasn't been offered to new customers since 2012 – and force business users to transition to a paid subscription for the service's successor, Google Workspace.

    "For businesses, the G Suite legacy free edition will no longer be available after June 27, 2022," Google explains in its support document. "Your account will be automatically transitioned to a paid Google Workspace subscription where we continue to deliver new capabilities to help businesses transform the way they work."

    Small business owners who have relied on the G Suite legacy free edition aren't thrilled that they will have to pay for Workspace or migrate to a rival like Microsoft, which happens to be actively encouraging defectors. As noted by The New York Times on Monday, the approaching deadline has elicited complaints from small firms that bet on Google's cloud productivity apps in the 2006-2012 period and have enjoyed the lack of billing since then.

    Continue reading
  • UK competition watchdog seeks to make mobile browsers, cloud gaming and payments more competitive
    Investigation could help end WebKit monoculture on iOS devices

    The United Kingdom's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) on Friday said it intends to launch an investigation of Apple's and Google's market power with respect to mobile browsers and cloud gaming, and to take enforcement action against Google for its app store payment practices.

    "When it comes to how people use mobile phones, Apple and Google hold all the cards," said Andrea Coscelli, Chief Executive of the CMA, in a statement. "As good as many of their services and products are, their strong grip on mobile ecosystems allows them to shut out competitors, holding back the British tech sector and limiting choice."

    The decision to open a formal investigation follows the CMA's year-long study of the mobile ecosystem. The competition watchdog's findings have been published in a report that concludes Apple and Google have a duopoly that limits competition.

    Continue reading
  • Google recasts Anthos with hitch to AWS Outposts
    If at first you don't succeed, change names and try again

    Google Cloud's Anthos on-prem platform is getting a new home under the search giant’s recently announced Google Distributed Cloud (GDC) portfolio, where it will live on as a software-based competitor to AWS Outposts and Microsoft Azure Stack.

    Introduced last fall, GDC enables customers to deploy managed servers and software in private datacenters and at communication service provider or on the edge.

    Its latest update sees Google reposition Anthos on-prem, introduced back in 2020, as the bring-your-own-server edition of GDC. Using the service, customers can extend Google Cloud-style management and services to applications running on-prem.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022