Boffins: It's EASY to make you GRASS YOURSELF UP for crimes you never did

A few 'wrong details' in an interview and you'll confess to anything

Got Tips? 64 Reg comments

New research has found that people are often surprisingly willing to confess to having committed crimes – even when they're innocent, or when the crimes never actually took place.

According to psychboffins Julia Shaw of the University of Bedfordshire, UK and Stephen Porter of the University of British Columbia, Canada, interviewers need only seed their questions with a few "wrong details" to cause false memories to form in subjects' minds.

"Our findings show that false memories of committing crime with police contact can be surprisingly easy to generate, and can have all the same kinds of complex details as real memories," Shaw said in a statement.

To prove the point, the researchers gave a questionnaire to the primary caregivers of 60 university students, asking then to describe events that the students experienced between the ages of 11 and 14. The boffins then brought the students in to their lab for a series of three 40-minute interviews about their past histories.

The twist? Although the scientists asked each student about two different life events, only one of the events mentioned in the questioning actually happened. The other event was pure fiction, but a surprising number of test subjects came to believe it happened anyway, even when it involved them committing a crime.

Of the 30 students who were told they had done something that led to a run-in with police, 71 per cent were classified as having developed a false memory of the crime following the interviews. Of those, 11 who had been told their crime was an assault of some kind reported "elaborate false memory details of their exact dealings with police."

Other students were told they had experienced "emotional events," such as a personal injury, being attacked by a dog, or losing a large amount of money. In these cases, 77 per cent of study participants formed false memories.

Among the tricks the researchers used was to pepper the false account with real-life details provided by the subjects' caregivers, such as the name of an actual childhood friend. Scientists believe this and the fact that the accounts were supposedly corroborated by the students' caregivers were what caused the false memories to germinate.

"In such circumstances, inherently fallible and reconstructive memory processes can quite readily generate false recollections with astonishing realism," Shaw said. "In these sessions we had some participants recalling incredibly vivid details and re-enacting crimes they never committed."

Shaw said her research, which was published in the journal Psychological Science, has clear implications for criminal interrogation and other aspects of legal procedure.

"By empirically demonstrating the harm 'bad' interview techniques – those which are known to cause false memories – can cause, we can more readily convince interviewers to avoid them and to use 'good' techniques instead," Shaw said. ®

Sponsored: Ransomware has gone nuclear


Keep Reading

A robot doing some coding

Facebook, AWS team up to produce open-source PyTorch AI libraries, grad student says he successfully used GPT-2 to write his homework....

Roundup ...Nvidia CEO to unveil new tech on YouTube, and more from machine-learning world
Brad Smith

Everything OK with Microsoft? Windows giant admits it was 'on the wrong side of history' with regard to open source

Tell-all with president Brad Smith reveals Obama warned tech giants that a privacy reckoning was coming
two-fork person

Dell spins up a supported distro of Microsoft’s SONiC open-source switch software

If you want a flat fabric, Dell wants in and is eyeing off NSX integrations too

The great big open-source census: Most-used libraries revealed – plus 10 things developers should be doing to keep their code secure

Linux Foundation hears your gripes about naming schemes, legacy code, and more
Finding bugs in code

Nine in ten biz applications harbor out-of-date, unsupported, insecure open-source code, study shows

Free-as-in-speech software is wildly popular – keeping libraries, components up to date is not
Abby Kearns, recently appointed CTO at Puppet

Ex-Cloud Foundry boss to pull strings at Puppet as CTO, says open-source software 'evolves faster, is more mature'

Abby Kearns says she will continue to foster OSS culture in new role
Figure left behind on a dock as a boat sails away

Copy-left behind: Permissive MIT, Apache open-source licenses on the up as developers snub GNU's GPL

Share all our code modifications with others? Think again, hippie
Oracle's Java is 20 years old

Oracle teases prospect of playing nicely with open-source Java in update to WebLogic application server

'Low cost of ownership'? This must be an April Fools

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020