Qualcomm, China shake hands, all is forgiven – if Qualcomm pays $975m

Antitrust probe resolved with fines, new patent license terms


Qualcomm says that although it is "disappointed" that China has slapped it with nearly $1bn in penalties for alleged antitrust violations, it plans to pay the fine and move on.

The California mobile chipmaker said in a press release [PDF] on Monday that the PRC government has fined it 6.088 billion Chinese yuan renminbi, or approximately $975m, a sum that Qualcomm says it will not contest.

"Although Qualcomm is disappointed with the results of the investigation," the chipmaker said in a statement, "it is pleased that the NDRC has reviewed and approved the Company's rectification plan."

Qualcomm has been under investigation by China's National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) – the nation's top antitrust regulator – since early 2014, over alleged abuses of its dominant position in the smartphone chips market.

The agency had accused Qualcomm of unfair and discriminatory pricing policies, particularly in the licensing of various patents the company holds related to wireless technologies.

As part of the new settlement, Qualcomm has agreed to license its patents on 3G and 4G mobile phone tech separately from the rest of its patent portfolio. In addition, if it seeks to cross-license patents from a Chinese firm as part of its licensing agreement, it promises to "negotiate with the licensee in good faith and provide fair consideration for such rights."

Qualcomm also promises not to force licensees to agree to any license that the NDRC has deemed unreasonable, and it says it won't deny any licensee just for challenging the terms of its agreement.

License fees for Qualcomm's patents in China will be pegged at 5 per cent for 3G devices and 3.5 per cent for 4G devices, on a basis of 65 per cent of the net selling price of each device.

Existing licensees can also choose to opt in to the new terms retroactively to January 1, 2015.

The settlement wasn't entirely one-sided, however. The new arrangement "does not require Qualcomm to sell chips to any entity that is not a Qualcomm licensee, and does not apply to a chip customer that refuses to report its sales of licensed devices as required by its patent license agreement."

Qualcomm has long complained that some of its licensees in China have not been accurately reporting the number of devices they have sold that include Qualcomm-patented technologies – meaning the firm hasn't been able to collect all of the fees that it believes it is owed.

What's more, the chipmaker has also cautioned its shareholders that some Chinese firms that use its tech may have avoided taking up new patent licenses while the NDRC investigation was underway.

The new settlement should give Qualcomm more leverage to negotiate new licenses and to collect fees from its existing licensees, in addition to removing a cloud that has had shareholders worried about the future of its business in the all-important China market.

"We are pleased that the resolution has removed the uncertainty surrounding our business in China, and we will now focus our full attention and resources on supporting our customers and partners in China and pursuing the many opportunities ahead," Qualcomm CEO Steve Mollenkopf said in a statement.

The settlement will not be without its costs for Qualcomm, however. To address the fine, the company said it expects to pay a charge equal to approximately $0.58 per diluted share, which it will recognize in fiscal 2015.

Still, investors seemed pleased that the matter has been resolved, sending the company's share price up around 3 per cent in after-hours trading. ®


Other stories you might like

  • Train once, run anywhere, almost: Qualcomm's drive to bring AI to its phone, PC chips
    Software toolkit offered to save developers time, effort, battery power

    Qualcomm knows that if it wants developers to build and optimize AI applications across its portfolio of silicon, the Snapdragon giant needs to make the experience simpler and, ideally, better than what its rivals have been cooking up in the software stack department.

    That's why on Wednesday the fabless chip designer introduced what it's calling the Qualcomm AI Stack, which aims to, among other things, let developers take AI models they've developed for one device type, let's say smartphones, and easily adapt them for another, like PCs. This stack is only for devices powered by Qualcomm's system-on-chips, be they in laptops, cellphones, car entertainment, or something else.

    While Qualcomm is best known for its mobile Arm-based Snapdragon chips that power many Android phones, the chip house is hoping to grow into other markets, such as personal computers, the Internet of Things, and automotive. This expansion means Qualcomm is competing with the likes of Apple, Intel, Nvidia, AMD, and others, on a much larger battlefield.

    Continue reading
  • Qualcomm wins EU court battle against $1b antitrust fine
    Another setback for competition watchdog as ruling over exclusive chip deal with iPhone nullified

    The European Commission's competition enforcer is being handed another defeat, with the EU General Court nullifying a $1.04 billion (€997 million) antitrust fine against Qualcomm.

    The decision to reverse the fine is directed at the body's competition team, headed by Danish politico Margrethe Vestager, which the General Court said made "a number of procedural irregularities [which] affected Qualcomm's rights of defense and invalidate the Commission's analysis" of Qualcomm's conduct. 

    At issue in the original case was a series of payments Qualcomm made to Apple between 2011 and 2016, which the competition enforcer had claimed were made in order to guarantee the iPhone maker exclusively used Qualcomm chips.

    Continue reading
  • Former chip research professor jailed for not disclosing Chinese patents
    This is how Beijing illegally accesses US tech, say Feds

    The former director of the University of Arkansas’ High Density Electronics Center, a research facility that specialises in electronic packaging and multichip technology, has been jailed for a year for failing to disclose Chinese patents for his inventions.

    Professor Simon Saw-Teong Ang was in 2020 indicted for wire fraud and passport fraud, with the charges arising from what the US Department of Justice described as a failure to disclose “ties to companies and institutions in China” to the University of Arkansas or to the US government agencies for which the High Density Electronics Center conducted research under contract.

    At the time of the indictment, then assistant attorney general for national security John C. Demers described Ang’s actions as “a hallmark of the China’s targeting of research and academic collaborations within the United States in order to obtain U.S. technology illegally.” The DoJ statement about the indictment said Ang’s actions had negatively impacted NASA and the US Air Force.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022