Passions run high in EU parliament debate over air passengers' privacy

Warring MEPs do battle over proposals to collect data for state security agencies


MEPs are massively split on whether or not to hand over air passengers’ personal data to security authorities.

Members of the European Parliament’s civil liberties committee debated the planned PNR (passenger name record) law that would involve storing all the information collected by airlines about passengers – including sensitive and personal information such as email addresses, credit card details, phone numbers, meal choices (halal, kosher, etc) for use by security agencies.

MEPs originally rejected the proposal last year but after months of pressure from national governments for increased access to personal data, it is now back on the table in a revised form. But even the revised text has attracted more than 800 amendments. Some are minor while others call for the proposal to be scrapped altogether.

Europarl’s resident “Mr Data” said there is no proof that data retention stops terrorism. In an impassioned speech, German Green MEP Jan Philipp Albrecht said it was “a scandal” that member states and the European Commission were still pushing for this law even after the European Court of Justice ruled blanket data retention illegal.

Mocking the position of the European People’s Party, he said: “Criminals adjust to retention loopholes, so why don’t we keep the data for 100 years? Or why don’t we retain data on train passengers? I could travel throughout Europe by train, am I not then a huge security threat? Or by car? Why don’t we track cars? Why don’t we just tape everything everyone does all the time? That is your [EPP] agenda.”

Britain's police forces retain the data of all persons arrested by them for 100 years, whether or not they are ever charged with a crime or found guilty.

Dutch MEP Sophie In’t Veld also rejected EPP claims that storage of passenger data would have prevented the Charlie Hebdo attacks in Paris earlier this year.

However, Swedish MEP Kristina Winberg of the Europe of Freedom and Direct Democracy group, which includes British political party UKIP, said she didn’t “feel safe in my own country” and that PNR data retention was necessary. British Conservative MEP Timothy Kirkhope added: “I am still convinced of the necessity and proportionality of the instrument. The threats we face are real and we need to find solutions.”

Albrecht rejected the idea that storing personal data will reduce the risk of terrorism and said that in fact blanket data retention hampers the work of security and law enforcement as is a drain on time, money and personnel. Kirkhope, whose job it is to find a compromise, admitted that MEPs are split: “Do we agree on every on this at the moment? No, but I do think we are trying to find solutions.”

The parliament’s Transport and Foreign Affairs committee have also proposed amendments to the current text. Once all the committees have voted on their recommendations, the Parliament as a whole will vote. Only then will discussions with member states and the Commission begin.

What will happen after that is not clear, but as digital rights group EDRi, which is heavily lobbying against the proposal, points out, the history of the law closely resembles that of the Data Retention Directive that was struck down by the European Court of Justice. Both were rejected by the civil liberties committee and dropped, only to be resurrected and fast-tracked following a terrorist attack. ®

Similar topics


Other stories you might like

  • Battlefield 2042: Please don't be the death knell of the franchise, please don't be the death knell of the franchise

    Another terrible launch, but DICE is already working on improvements

    The RPG Greetings, traveller, and welcome back to The Register Plays Games, our monthly gaming column. Since the last edition on New World, we hit level cap and the "endgame". Around this time, item duping exploits became rife and every attempt Amazon Games made to fix it just broke something else. The post-level 60 "watermark" system for gear drops is also infuriating and tedious, but not something we were able to address in the column. So bear these things in mind if you were ever tempted. On that note, it's time to look at another newly released shit show – Battlefield 2042.

    I wanted to love Battlefield 2042, I really did. After the bum note of the first-person shooter (FPS) franchise's return to Second World War theatres with Battlefield V (2018), I stupidly assumed the next entry from EA-owned Swedish developer DICE would be a return to form. I was wrong.

    The multiplayer military FPS market is dominated by two forces: Activision's Call of Duty (COD) series and EA's Battlefield. Fans of each franchise are loyal to the point of zealotry with little crossover between player bases. Here's where I stand: COD jumped the shark with Modern Warfare 2 in 2009. It's flip-flopped from WW2 to present-day combat and back again, tried sci-fi, and even the Battle Royale trend with the free-to-play Call of Duty: Warzone (2020), which has been thoroughly ruined by hackers and developer inaction.

    Continue reading
  • American diplomats' iPhones reportedly compromised by NSO Group intrusion software

    Reuters claims nine State Department employees outside the US had their devices hacked

    The Apple iPhones of at least nine US State Department officials were compromised by an unidentified entity using NSO Group's Pegasus spyware, according to a report published Friday by Reuters.

    NSO Group in an email to The Register said it has blocked an unnamed customers' access to its system upon receiving an inquiry about the incident but has yet to confirm whether its software was involved.

    "Once the inquiry was received, and before any investigation under our compliance policy, we have decided to immediately terminate relevant customers’ access to the system, due to the severity of the allegations," an NSO spokesperson told The Register in an email. "To this point, we haven’t received any information nor the phone numbers, nor any indication that NSO’s tools were used in this case."

    Continue reading
  • Utility biz Delta-Montrose Electric Association loses billing capability and two decades of records after cyber attack

    All together now - R, A, N, S, O...

    A US utility company based in Colorado was hit by a ransomware attack in November that wiped out two decades' worth of records and knocked out billing systems that won't be restored until next week at the earliest.

    The attack was detailed by the Delta-Montrose Electric Association (DMEA) in a post on its website explaining that current customers won't be penalised for being unable to pay their bills because of the incident.

    "We are a victim of a malicious cyber security attack. In the middle of an investigation, that is as far as I’m willing to go," DMEA chief exec Alyssa Clemsen Roberts told a public board meeting, as reported by a local paper.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021