Uber is killing off iconic black cabs, warns Zac Goldsmith

MP also asks if company is practising predatory pricing to drive out competition


London's iconic black cabs could disappear from the capital's streets in a few years due to an unfair playing field created by Uber, Conservative mayoral candidate Zac Goldsmith has warned.

"The tragedy is that black cabs’ days could soon be numbered. If trends continue, I do not think that there is any doubt that they will be extinct in a matter of years," he said, speaking in a Westminster debate.

The number of minicab drivers in London has increased by 46 per cent to 86,500 compared with five years ago and is increasing by 1,000 every month, said Goldsmith.

Black cabs bear greater costs as they are subject to more regulation, although this allows them to pick up anyone from the street. In contrast, private hire vehicles are subject to less regulation because they are booked in advance, he said.

"That system largely worked fine until recently, but the emergence of Uber has turned it on its head," he said. According to Goldsmith the speed of the Uber app means that its cars are effectively hailed by users.

Goldsmith called on under-secretary of state for transport Andrew Jones to work with the Competition and Markets Authority to look at the London taxi market as a whole.

He added: "Uber enjoys a significant price advantage by not paying UK corporation tax, because jobs are booked through the Netherlands. Despite Uber being a $50bn (£32bn) company, its drivers earn far less than the London living wage; in some cases, they earn a lot less than the minimum wage."

He also questioned whether the low prices offered by some apps are kept artificially low to drive out competition — a form of predatory pricing. "I am not clear how much evidence exists on that, but there is a strong suspicion, which I think I share, that it is happening."

Sadiq Khan, MP for Tooting and Labour's mayoral candidate, echoed Goldsmith's concerns, adding that his constituents have told him that "some private hire vehicles are being driven out of the market by the pricing model of Uber".

Goldsmith said there is "no question of banning Uber, but there is a need for more clarity in the regulatory system" and said the government should also look at some of the "unnecessary regulations" applied to black cab drivers.

Under-secretary of state for transport Andrew Jones acknowledged that Uber and other new entrants to the market present "major challenges to established business models". However, he said the company has now been granted licences in 26 licensing authority areas in England.

"Therefore, 26 different authorities have decided that Uber is a fit and proper company, that its operating model meets the requirements of private hire legislation and that it keeps such records as the law requires," he said. ®

Similar topics

Broader topics


Other stories you might like

  • Enemies Waymo, Uber now friends making self-driving-ish trucks for US highways
    When you think about it, it makes cents

    Waymo and Uber announced on Tuesday a "long-term strategic partnership" promising to work together to deploy autonomous freight trucks on US roads, years after both companies fought bitterly over self-driving technology. 

    The collaboration will see Waymo retrofitting trucks with its AI-powered driving software operating on Uber's logistics and network infrastructure. Shippers can tap into the Uber Freight service to connect with truckers willing to deliver their goods across the country. Vehicles running the Waymo Driver software will be able to complete part of the journey autonomously, although human drivers will still need to be present.

    "With trucking, we plan to first tackle highway driving," a spokesperson from Waymo told The Register. "It's a natural environment to start this deployment due to the large number of highway miles, which are often the most tiring stretches for humans to drive, and which are a large opportunity to improve efficiency in the industry."

    Continue reading
  • Indian government accuses Uber of jacking up prices for loyal customers
    Six ride sharing companies forced into consumer redress scheme

    India has accused ride-sharing companies of over-charging loyal customers who regularly take the same route, and directed six platforms to become part of a scheme that offers third-party grievance handling services.

    The directive to join the scheme was issued during a meeting with officials of India's Department of Consumer Affairs, attended by Ola, Uber, Rapido, Meru Cabs and Jugnoo. The platforms were advised to improve responses to customer concerns and rights and directed to become "convergence partners" in India's National Consumer Helpline. Such partners are required to accept and resolve consumer grievances reported to the Helpline.

    The Department said ride-sharing companies need to sign up for the helpline for reasons including that their algorithms set fares in ways that are not easy to understand – sometimes even charging loyal customers higher rates than first-timers on the same route.

    Continue reading
  • Uber, Meta to reduce hiring as stocks slide
    Is winter coming already for the US tech sector?

    Some tech companies are tightening their belts as they adjust to ongoing financial turbulence, with Uber and Meta both looking to reduce expenses and hiring.

    Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi told employees in an internal email that the ride-hailing service is going to try harder to stop losing so much money. Khosrowshahi's email, obtained by CNBC's Deirdre Bosa, begins, "It's clear that the market is experiencing a seismic shift and we need to react accordingly."

    The memo says hiring will be more cautious and promises cost cutting.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022