You want a 6% Google Tax? Get lost, German copyright bods told

Only snippets longer than seven words are chargeable


After months of deliberations, Germany's national arbitration board on copyright has told German copyright collection company VG Media to go whistle over its proposal for a six per cent “Google Tax”.

Although the ancillary copyright tax law does indeed apply to Google, said the board, which is part of the German Patent Trademark Office (DPMA), VG’s request for six per cent of the Chocolate Factory’s German revenue was far too high.

The collecting agency originally wanted a massive 11 per cent.

The board based its decision on a specific word count threshold for snippets, so the ancillary copyright fee can now only be collected on snippets of more than seven words, plus the search term.

The law was introduced in 2013 to allow publishers to claim royalties from news aggregators for using very small portions of stories; Google News is, unsurprisingly, the biggest target, hence the scheme’s labelling as a "Google Tax".

This is a bit of a misnomer, however, as the ad-flinger has yet to pay this sort of tax.

The scheme was tried in Spain, where law-makers also made it illegal for publishers to waive their right to fees. The outcome? Google News upped and left Spain altogether.

Now the very publishers that wanted legislation to guarantee them royalties are lobbying the government to repeal the law, as traffic to their sites has dropped.

Europe’s digi commissioner, Gunther H-dot Oettinger, is due to present his proposal for an overhaul of the EU’s copyright laws before the end of the year. Last year, before he took office, H-dot was keen to tell the German press that he wanted to find a way to “protect intellectual works” and “demand a levy from Google”.

“If Google takes intellectual property from the EU and works with it, the EU can protect this property and can demand a charge for it,” he told the daily Handelsblatt.

Since then, however, he has backtracked, so it is unclear whether or not a so-called Google Tax will form part of his draft law.

The Commish is currently holding public consultations on everything from the Audiovisual Media Services Directive to unjustified geo-blocking, but not, strikingly, on ancillary copyright.

This could mean Oetti has already made up his mind... or that he’s not going to touch this particular hot potato with a barge pole. ®

Similar topics

Narrower topics


Other stories you might like

  • Germany to host Europe's first exascale supercomputer
    Jupiter added to HPC solar system

    Germany will be the host of the first publicly known European exascale supercomputer, along with four other EU sites getting smaller but still powerful systems, the European High Performance Computing Joint Undertaking (EuroHPC JU) announced this week.

    Germany will be the home of Jupiter, the "Joint Undertaking Pioneer for Innovative and Transformative Exascale Research." It should be switched on next year in a specially designed building on the campus of the Forschungszentrum Jülich research centre and operated by the Jülich Supercomputing Centre (JSC), alongside the existing Juwels and Jureca supercomputers.

    The four mid-range systems are: Daedalus, hosted by the National Infrastructures for Research and Technology in Greece; Levente at the Governmental Agency for IT Development in Hungary; Caspir at the National University of Ireland Galway in Ireland; and EHPCPL at the Academic Computer Centre CYFRONET in Poland.

    Continue reading
  • Germany makes new move to attract chip manufacturers
    $14.7b in state aid on offer for companies to set up shop in the country

    Germany's government is looking to attract chipmakers to the country by offering €14 billion ($14.7 billion) in financial support, apparently spurred on by global semiconductor supply chain problems.

    The move follows the European Chips Act from the European Commission and Intel's decision earlier this year to build a new fabrication plant in Germany.

    The latest announcement was made by Germany's vice chancellor and federal minister for Economic Affairs Robert Habeck at a business event in Hanover, according to Reuters, who said that his government wants to attract chip makers with €14 billion ($14.7 billion) in state aid.

    Continue reading
  • Germany advises citizens to uninstall Kaspersky antivirus
    Russian biz founder calls it 'an insult'

    Germany's BSI federal cybersecurity agency has warned the country's citizens not to install Russian-owned Kaspersky antivirus, saying it has "doubts about the reliability of the manufacturer."

    Russia-based Kaspersky has long been a target of suspicious rumors in the West over its ownership and allegiance to Russia's rulers.

    In an advisory published today, the agency said: "The BSI recommends replacing applications from Kaspersky's virus protection software portfolio with alternative products."

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022