Post-pub nosh neckfiller: The gargantuan Gatsby

South African supersized spicy steak sarnie

It's February, and the weather's crap this side of the equator, so travel with us if you will to South Africa's sunny Cape Town for a wobbly dining experience so substantial it's more of a team sport than a post-pub dining exercise.

Yes indeed, prepare to get your laughing gear round the "Gatsby", recommended by reader Simon McKay-Mills, who was recently on a business trip to Cape Town and therefore "had to partake" of this local classic.

The Gatsby is simply a bloody enormous sandwich constructed from a 30cm loaf commonly packed with steak, chips, piri-piri sauce, and a touch of salad. The chips and the hot sauce are apparently the only obligatory elements, and alternative fillings include, squid, chicken, sausage, polony, cheese, and so forth.

The story goes that the Gatsby was born in 1976 when Rashaad Pandy, a fish shop owner in Cape Town's Athlone suburb, combined "a round Portuguese roll, polony, slap chips and achar" (pickles) to create an instant meal for four labourers.

One of the recipients, who'd "recently watched the film The Great Gatsby at the Athlone Theatre, gleefully exclaimed, 'this is a Gatsby smash' (meaning, it’s a winning dish), and the name just stuck".

The rest is history. explains: "For many locals, this colossal sandwich is not just a meal; it's a way of life, a cultural symbol and an important part of their heritage."

Well, if you fancy knocking up this cultural symbol, you'll need some piri-piri sauce. That would normally require chilli peppers, but we couldn't get those, so cunningly substituted a big red pepper and Tabasco. Here's the full spread of ingredients:

The ingredients to make piri-piri sauce

  • 1 large red pepper
  • 4-5 cloves garlic
  • 2g cayenne pepper
  • 2g salt
  • Juice of 1 lemon
  • Parsley
  • 5g hot paprika
  • A few drops of Tabasco
  • 100ml olive oil

There's no great culinary science involved in preparing the sauce, as our step-by-step shows:

How to prepare piri-piri

It's just a matter of adjusting the ingredient amounts to taste and tweaking the hotness to suit. Once you've simmered your piri-piri, keep it in the fridge in a sealed container, where it will improve with age over about a week.

So, here's everything else you'll need for a Gatsby...

The ingredients to finish making the Gatsby


  • 1 long (30cm) loaf
  • 300-400g Steak
  • Chopped lettuce
  • 800g spuds

The loaf in this case is a ciabatta-style offering, available locally hereabouts, and which did the job admirably. Get the best steak you can afford, thinly cut.

Now, there's the matter of the chips. Gatsby aficionados reportedly favour local "slap" chips, from the Afrikaans for "soft". However, when we had a shufti at a few recipes, some called for a crispy exterior.

No matter how soft they ultimately turn out - and our were admittedly crispy - the chips demand a two-stage frying process, and a provocative vinegar pre-soak:

The six steps in making slap chips

The idea is that the first fry should be in cooler oil than the second, for which you crank up the heat for the browning process. The vinegar bit of the operation seemed a bit odd, but certainly adds a nice tang to the finished result.

Having handed all that, the final furlong to the finishing tape is as follows:

The six final steps for making the Gatsby

Here's the finished Gatsby, a monster requiring a panoramic aspect ratio to encompass it's awesome wideness...

Katarina peers over the top of the Gatsby

...and here's glamorous assistant Katarina preparing to tackle the beast:

Katarina prepares to take a bite from the mighty Gatsby

In fact, this behemoth will easily feed four in gloriously messy style. Napkins are recommended and, if you really crank up the piri-piri, have iced beer on hand.

Our correspondent Simon reports that the Gatsby he enjoyed boasted fried chilli peppers - as well as the piri-piri. He describes the result on the throat as "a reason for going out and consuming more beer". ®

Our post-pub nosh menu in full...

JavaScript Disabled

Please Enable JavaScript to use this feature.

Similar topics

Similar topics

Similar topics


Send us news

Other stories you might like