Dell plans sale of non-core assets to reduce EMC buy debt

SEC filing warns of weak PC business, tax risk of new stock and reveals executive pay


Dell and EMC have agreed on the documentation to be put to the latter's shareholders at a forthcoming meeting that will vote on the merger of the two companies. And the document reveals that Dell plans to sell off some non-core businesses after the merger.

The document in question is a Form S-4, one of the many regulatory niceties EMC and Dell have to submit to the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to make their planned merger a reality. As with many documents businesses are required to submit to the SEC, it's a warts-and-all affair designed to put on the record just about anything an investor might want to know and anything a company director needs known to avoid lawsuits. Which is why the main document is 341 pages long.

The document is bullish on the synergies that will flow from Dell and EMC merging. But it also points out that Dell will soon have US$59.1bn of debt, which will mean it won't be flush with cash for the next little while. The document says Denali Holding Inc (DHI), the company that owns Dell, “... has an objective of reducing its indebtedness in the first 18-24 months after completion of the merger and achieving an investment grade credit rating for such indebtedness. The cash necessary to achieve that objective is expected to come from divestitures of non-core businesses of the DHI Group, including EMC, cash flows from operations of the DHI Group and cash generated by reductions in the working capital needed to operate the DHI Group.”

Is that a buy-then-break-apart job? All parties to the transaction have said, long and loud, that there are mutual benefits to be had. It's unlikely all those statements are undone by this fragment of the S-4. But it does beg the question of just what will be non-core to Dell once it owns EMC? RSA's not going well. Dell's storage business might be surplus to requirements once it owns EMC. Dell's tried to offload its services business before. How might the Labs bit of Pivotal fit in the combined company? And what about various bits of EMC that don't fit well inside Dell Software. Or maybe Dell Software will be considered surplus.

Whatever's on Dell the man's mind, we won't know for ages!

The document also spends a lot of time on the fate of the “Class V” “tracking stock” that investors will score to compensate them for the 81 per cent of VMware that EMC currently owns. The Risk Factors section of the S-4 points out that tracking stocks are unusual and unpredictable.

“Because there is no established trading market or market price of Class V Common Stock, the value of the merger consideration that EMC shareholders will receive in the merger is uncertain,” the document says, later adding that “As a result of the characteristics of tracking stocks, tracking stocks often trade at a discount to the estimated value of the assets or businesses they are intended to track.”

Another section of the Risk Factors section is titled “There is a lack of certainty regarding the US federal income tax treatment of the merger and the Class V Common Stock.” Lots of legalese follows suggesting that Dell's legal counsel is probably right, but also pointing out that the United States Internal Revenue Service is yet to rule on the matter. If Dell's hoped-for tax treatment isn't approved, it's not a deal-breaker. But it is going to mean some messy and likely expensive re-arranging of the deal.

The document also foreshadows lots of renegotiation of Dell and EMC's many alliances, as partners feel new agreements are appropriate once they're dealing with a new company.

Dell also admits that it has a worrying dependency on its PC business, which generates 65 per cent of its net revenue and is challenged by low demand, longer refresh cycle and customer preference for lower-margin products or mobile devices Dell doesn't make. Here's an excerpt:

Other challenges include declining margins as demand for PC products shifts from higher-margin premium products to lower-cost and lower-margin products, particularly in emerging markets, and significant and increasing competition from efficient and low-cost manufacturers and from manufacturers of innovative and higher-margin PC products. For example, the built-to-order model that Dell has historically used is losing competitiveness in an environment where profit pools are moving toward lower-margin segments primarily based on a build-to-stock model, and Dell also lacks a strong offering in tablets.”

Ouch.

There's plenty more, including an admission that if Michael Dell were hit by a bus he'd be just-about-irreplacable, and lots of box-ticking about the threats posed by hacking, supply chain disruption, currency fluctuations and other eminently-unforeseeable events. The prurient can also find details of salary packages and shareholdings (Michael Dell's on $950,000 a year with the chance of two $2m bonuses).

If you make it through the full document and the merger goes pear-shaped, you can't say you weren't warned. ®

Similar topics


Other stories you might like

  • (Our) hardware is still key in a multicloud world, Dell ISG chief insists
    IT giant may be shifting its focus to software and services, but systems remain the foundation

    Analysis At this month's Dell Technologies World show in Las Vegas, all the usual executives were prowling the keynote stages, from CEO Michael Dell to co-COOs Chuck Witten and Jeff Clark, all talking about the future of the company.

    Noticeably absent were the big servers or storage systems that for decades had joined them on stage, complete with all the speeds and feeds. Though a PC made an appearance, there was no reveal of big datacenter boxes.

    It's a continuing scenario that is likely to play out to various degrees at user events for other established IT hardware vendors, such as when Hewlett Packard Enterprise later next month convenes its Discover show, also in Las Vegas. It's having to adapt to the steady upward trend in multicloud adoption, the ongoing decentralization of IT and the understanding that in today's world, data is king, Hardware is still needed, but the outcomes they deliver are what is most important.

    Continue reading
  • Zero trust is more than just vendors and products – it requires process
    IT orgs need to adapt their procedures to make it all work, says Dell

    Dell Technologies World Zero-trust architectures have become a focus for enterprises trying to figure out how to secure an IT environment where data and applications are increasingly distributed outside of the traditional perimeter defenses of central datacenters.

    With the attack surface expanding and cyberthreats growing in number and complexity, many organizations are sorting through a cybersecurity space that has myriad vendors and products to choose from, according to Chad Dunn, vice president for product management for Dell's Apex as-a-service business.

    Zero trust – which essentially dictates that any person or device trying to access the network should not be trusted and needs to go through a strict authentication and verification process – will be foundational for companies moving forward, but it has to be more than simply buying and deploying products, Dunn told The Register in an interview here in Las Vegas at the Dell Technologies World show.

    Continue reading
  • Dell brings data recovery tools to Apex and the cloud
    Dell shows off full stack of cyber recovery SaaS, partners with Snowflake for data analytics

    LAS VEGAS – Dell is giving enterprises new ways to protect the data they store in public clouds.

    At the Dell Technologies World event Monday, the company unveiled a full-stack cyber-recovery managed services offering in its Apex -as-a-service portfolio and data protection technologies that will be available in both the Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Microsoft Azure public clouds.

    In addition, Dell is partnering with high-profile cloud-based data analytics vendor Snowflake to enable organizations to take the data they're keeping in their data centers in Dell object storage and run it in Snowflake's Data Cloud while keeping the data on premises or copying it to the public cloud, an important capability for companies with data sovereignty or privacy concerns who can't freely move it around.

    Continue reading
  • Dell trials 4-day workweek, massive UK pilot of shortened week begins
    Hopes to tap into pool of tech workers who aren't keen to be tied down for 40 hours per week

    Dell employees in the Netherlands will be able to work four days a week from this month, a director of Dell Technologies Netherlands has confirmed to The Register.

    The news comes just before the biggest ever 4-day working week trial begins in the UK.

    Isabel Moll, newly appointed vice president and general manager at Dell Netherlands, told us the part-time pilot has already been rolled out by the Dutch and Argentinian operations.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022