UK draft super-spy law 'not fit for purpose,' say 100s of senior lawyers

Open letter criticizes UK government for pushing bill that fails to meet standards


IPB An open letter signed by hundreds of senior lawyers and several high-profile QCs (Queen's Counsels) has criticized the UK's Conservative government for pushing a surveillance bill that is "not fit for purpose."

More than 200 lawyers, including several who have been closely involved in cases surrounding evidence from the security services, signed the letter, which argues that there need to be "significant revisions" to the draft Investigatory Powers Bill (IPB) – otherwise known as the Snooper's Charter – if it is to meet "international standards" for surveillance.

The letter states: "A law that gives public authorities generalized access to electronic communications contents compromises the essence of the fundamental right to privacy and may be illegal."

That statement is especially pertinent given the EU's recent "Privacy Shield" agreement with the United States that was developed following very similar concerns over mass surveillance.

The UK Bill does not include several critical distinctions that were drawn up in that agreement, including the concept of "targeted" collection and data only being collected where "strictly necessary." As such, the IP Bill as it currently stands is almost certain to be challenged in the European Court of Justice (assuming the UK doesn't vote to leave Europe later this year).

The letter also criticizes the draft law for failing to include any verification of "reasonable suspicion" in instances of interception of data. It notes: "The investigatory powers bill does not mention 'reasonable suspicion' – or even suspects – and there is no need to demonstrate criminal involvement or a threat to national security."

In summary, it says the Bill – which receives its Second Reading on Tuesday – "fails to meet these [surveillance] standards – the law is unfit for purpose." It adds: "If the law is not fit for purpose, unnecessary and expensive litigation will follow, and further reform will be required."

Who

Signatories to the letter include chair of the Bar Human Rights Committee, Kirsty Brimelow QC, special advocate Tom de la Mare QC, former appeal court judge Sir Stephen Sedley, and renowned human rights lawyer Michael Mansfield QC. A significant number of signatories come from the UK's most prominent law schools.

It should be noted, however, that despite Edward Snowden's claim that "practically the entire legal community of the UK" has signed the letter, there are around 1,700 QCs in the UK currently and the letter represents less than 10 per cent of them.

While the Conservative government is pushing the IP Bill as having reached an adequate balance between privacy and security, the main opposition Labour Party had said it will abstain from the second reading and has threatened to vote against it later if significant changes are not made (a decision the other main party, the Liberal Democrats, called "gutless"). The Liberal Democrats and the Scottish National Party are opposed to the bill. ®

Similar topics

Broader topics


Other stories you might like

  • AI tool finds hundreds of genes related to human motor neuron disease

    Breakthrough could lead to development of drugs to target illness

    A machine-learning algorithm has helped scientists find 690 human genes associated with a higher risk of developing motor neuron disease, according to research published in Cell this week.

    Neuronal cells in the central nervous system and brain break down and die in people with motor neuron disease, like amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) more commonly known as Lou Gehrig's disease, named after the baseball player who developed it. They lose control over their bodies, and as the disease progresses patients become completely paralyzed. There is no currently no verified cure for ALS.

    Motor neuron disease typically affects people in old age and its causes are unknown. Johnathan Cooper-Knock, a clinical lecturer at the University of Sheffield in England and leader of Project MinE, an ambitious effort to perform whole genome sequencing of ALS, believes that understanding how genes affect cellular function could help scientists develop new drugs to treat the disease.

    Continue reading
  • Need to prioritize security bug patches? Don't forget to scan Twitter as well as use CVSS scores

    Exploit, vulnerability discussion online can offer useful signals

    Organizations looking to minimize exposure to exploitable software should scan Twitter for mentions of security bugs as well as use the Common Vulnerability Scoring System or CVSS, Kenna Security argues.

    Better still is prioritizing the repair of vulnerabilities for which exploit code is available, if that information is known.

    CVSS is a framework for rating the severity of software vulnerabilities (identified using CVE, or Common Vulnerability Enumeration, numbers), on a scale from 1 (least severe) to 10 (most severe). It's overseen by First.org, a US-based, non-profit computer security organization.

    Continue reading
  • Sniff those Ukrainian emails a little more carefully, advises Uncle Sam in wake of Belarusian digital vandalism

    NotPetya started over there, don't forget

    US companies should be on the lookout for security nasties from Ukrainian partners following the digital graffiti and malware attack launched against Ukraine by Belarus, the CISA has warned.

    In a statement issued on Tuesday, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency said it "strongly urges leaders and network defenders to be on alert for malicious cyber activity," having issued a checklist [PDF] of recommended actions to take.

    "If working with Ukrainian organizations, take extra care to monitor, inspect, and isolate traffic from those organizations; closely review access controls for that traffic," added CISA, which also advised reviewing backups and disaster recovery drills.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022