Trump's FBI boss, Attorney General picks reckon your encryption's getting backdoored

This isn't going to end well


US President Donald Trump's pick for his Attorney General and head of the FBI will have security specialists nervous, since both believe breaking encryption is a good idea.

Senator Jefferson Beauregard "Jeff" Sessions III (R‑AL) is Trump's pick for the top legal job in the US. In congressional testimony, he outed himself as a committed backdoor man when it comes to encryption. In the written testimony [PDF] to Senator Patrick Leahy, (D‑VT) he laid out his position.

"Encryption serves many valuable and important purposes," Sessions wrote. "It is also critical, however, that national security and criminal investigators be able to overcome encryption, under lawful authority, when necessary to the furtherance of national security and criminal investigations."

That's going to be bad news for people who favor strong encryption. The finest minds in cryptography have repeatedly pointed out the impossibility of building a backdoor for law enforcement into secure encryption, since there's no way to stop others from finding and exploiting the Feds-only access. If backdoors are mandated, then it could open up all our data to attackers. Encryption is either strong or backdoored.

Sessions' appointment is also going to cause Apple CEO Tim Cook and other tech execs to wear long faces. During the San Bernardino iPhone case, Sessions was one of the main voices in Congress calling for Apple to create hacking tools for its own operating system and hand them over to the FBI.

"Coming from a law enforcement background, I believe this is a more serious issue than Tim Cook understands," Sessions said at the time. "In a criminal case, or could be a life-and-death terrorist case, accessing a phone means the case is over. Time and time again, that kind of information results in an immediate guilty plea, case over."

Meanwhile, Trump has reportedly decided to keep James Comey as director of the FBI. FBI bosses are appointed on 10-year terms to shield them from American politics and similar influences, although presidents can fire them.

Republican-leaning Comey too thinks backdoors (or front doors as he likes to call them) are going to be essential for law enforcement to stop the communications channels of crooks and terrorists "going dark."

Comey has said that he wants an adult conversation about encryption this year, and by adult he presumably means that anyone who opposes him is being childish. With the new AG getting his back, Comey might have more success than before in weakening encryption. ®


Keep Reading

European recommendations following Schrems II Privacy Shield ruling cast doubt on cloud encryption practices

Bring-your-own-key may no longer be enough for EU data protection body

Micropayments company Coil distributes new privacy policy with email that puts users' addresses in the ‘To:’ field

Hundreds of email addresses exposed, customers predictably less-than-thrilled

Reply-All storm flares as email announcing privacy policy puts 500 addresses in the 'To' field, not 'BCC'

Newsletter-as-a-service outfit Substack does the usual apologising

Zoom-er or later, your past catches up with you: Vid chat service hit by sueball over end-to-end encryption claim

US consumer nonprofit alleges it was false advertising

Americans should have strong privacy-protecting encryption ...that the Feds and cops can break, say senators

I don't care if it's mathematically impossible, make it happen nerds!

Anatomy of a business email scam: FBI dossier details how fraudster pocketed $500k+ by redirecting payments

Electrolux, construction biz fooled into handing over money funneled out of the US to South Africa

Zoom strong-armed by US watchdog to beef up security after boasting of end-to-end encryption that didn't exist

Vid-chat giant promises never again to make 'misrepresentations about its privacy and security practices'

Backdoors won't weaken your encryption, wails FBI boss. And he's right. They won't – they'll fscking torpedo it

Give it a Wray, give it a Wray, give it a Wray now: Big Chris steps in to defend blowing a hole in personal crypto

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020