Vital fair use copyright defense lands – thanks to warring YouTubers

Using someone else's material in your reaction vid is A-OK, says NYC judge

8 Reg comments Got Tips?

The law

Not that the judge was entirely in the Kleins' favor. She schooled them about copyright law, pointing out that fair use considers what proportion of the copyrighted work the infringing work uses, not how much of it is included in the overall reaction video. In other words, the amount of the Bold Guy video that appeared in their video, regardless of how long their own video is.

The judge also agreed with Hosseinzadeh that the video was not documentary-style, real-life content since it was clearly scripted and acted (the Kleins claimed otherwise because it strengthened their fair use argument.)

The critical factor was that "without using actual clips, the commentary and critique here would lose context and utility."

And the judge noted that the Kleins' video in no way provided a "market substitute" for the Hoss video, since the Kleins' video provided a "very different experience" in that it was interspersed with commentary and the Hoss clips did not run seamlessly.

The judge then discussed and threw out the defamation claims, noting that Ethan Klein's statement: "I think that the heart and soul of this is ... he doesn't like that we made fun of him, and so he's suing us" was "a quintessential statement of pure opinion."

The Kleins are, naturally, delighted and celebrated by reuploading their original video mocking Hoss.

Hosseinzadeh, presumably, is less delighted. Despite promising to keep his 170,000 subscribers updated on the case as it progresses, no video has been released on his MattHossZone YouTube channel. We'll keep you updated if this goes to appeal. ®

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR WEEKLY TECH NEWSLETTER


Keep Reading

Escobar lines up COO... for lawsuit: Controversial bendy phone slinger sues exec over 'missing cash, YouTube hijack'

Dust up after sales money vanishes from bank account, it is claimed

Facebook does the right thing for once: Joins Google, LinkedIn, Microsoft, Reddit, Twitter, YouTube to clean out dodgy COVID-19 info

What took you so long, eh?

Forget toilet roll, bandwidth is the new ration: Amazon, YouTube also degrade video in Europe to keep 'net running amid coronavirus crunch

Pair join Netflix to turn it down for what? Connectivity stability

Hypochondriacs – are your eyes all blurry? It's just YouTube trying to cut video-stream quality worldwide amid the coronavirus pandemic

You can still watch in HD, but, please, maybe not?

India crowdsources COVID-19 response – startups told to make YouTube vids to win

Online hackfest designed to help government response, provided entries arrive in 12-point Arial

Instagram, YouTube 'iron man' marketer first to be nabbed by Feds cracking down on fake coronavirus web cures

Videos claiming to have magic savior pills racked up millions of views amid allegedly fraudulent investment scheme

Google, YouTube cough up $170m to make that trifling little thing about slurping kids' info without consent go away

Ad giant gets slap on the wrist, promises not to do it again

Google, YouTube, Twitter tell face-rec upstart Clearview to stop harvesting people's content – that's their job

Updated Tech-for-cops CEO claims First Amendment rights as a legal defense

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020