Two drones, two crashes in two months: MoD still won't say why

We now know when they crashed – but not even a hint about the cause


A damning Ministry of Defence report into the UK government department's safety oversight systems has revealed when two unmanned aerial vehicles crashed into the sea off Wales.

The Watchkeeper WK450-series drone fleet, built and partially operated by French defence contractor Thales, has been marred by a number of crashes in British service over the past few years.

The MoD has tried to keep the crashes hidden from the public, not admitting they had happened until a chance remark made by an admiral in September disclosed this year's incidents.

The two drones, tail numbers WK042 and WK043, crashed within seven weeks of each other, in February and March this year. Both "remotely piloted aerial systems" (RPAS) were lost in Cardigan Bay, immediately west of West Wales Airport, Aberporth, causing the remaining 52 drones to be grounded for four months.

The Watchkeeper is undergoing lengthy flight testing with the Army. Initially proposed as a surveillance drone, the programme has achieved relatively little for the 12 years and £1.2bn+ spent on it, though the Bureau of Investigative Journalism found two years ago that the drones had seen a total of 146 hours of active duty – equating to two days' operational flying each.

WK042 was lost in the sea on February 3, according to the Defence Safety Authority's latest biannual report published this week. The drone was being flown from its ground station by a combined crew of Thales and UAV Tactical Systems (UAVTS) operators who were testing de-icing equipment. Historical weather data for Aberystwyth, around 20 miles north of Aberporth and also on the edge of Cardigan Bay, shows that temperatures on the day averaged about 9oC.

WK043 was lost on March 24 in the same area while being flown by a combination of Army, Thales and UAVTS operators, while a soldier was being trained to pilot the drone. Watchkeepers cannot be flown in the "stick and rudder" sense; instead, operators select waypoints on a map display and the drone flies itself towards them.

Though the MoD also operates other drones, including Predators bought from America, these seem to crash less often. However, an MQ-9 Reaper, serial number ZZ205, is now the subject of a formal service inquiry following an unspecified incident in August 2016.

We asked the MoD to comment on what type of investigation is being undertaken into the latest Watchkeeper crashes and why it did not come clean about the crashes when they first occurred. A spokesman for the department told us that no injury or loss of life had occurred and added: "We paused Watchkeeper flying for a short period whilst conducting initial investigations, but resumed flight trials in early July. Service inquiries into the specific incidents are ongoing as we look to learn all we can from the events."

A Watchkeeper operational field trial exercise has been taking place from West Wales Airport since mid-September and is due to end this Sunday, November 5. A company-sized unit from 47 Regiment, Royal Artillery, has been flying its drones from the Aberporth airfield.

A safety and reputational risk in the making

Watchkeeper is a relatively old programme (as this authoritative history by top blogger Think Defence explains) that has absorbed large sums of public money for a return that is largely invisible to the taxpayer.

Previous crashes highlighted Watchkeeper's poor controllability in marginal weather conditions and poor onboard software, in combination with its use of laser altimeters as a primary height sensor – a strange choice for aircraft operating in the wet and cloudy skies of Wales. While El Reg has sympathy for trainees cocking up a landing, this does not excuse the MoD for hiding behind self-regulation to pretend that all is well.

As Watchkeepers do make flights over the UK mainland as well as the sea, the MoD must be open and transparent about when its unmanned aircraft crash and why. Civil aviation has long grasped this essential point and the Air Accidents Investigation Branch is proactive with publishing interim reports into civil aircraft crashes and malfunctions. In contrast, the Military Aviation Authority says very little on matters of public interest.

There is no justification for the MoD keeping quiet and hoping nobody notices just because these latest crashes were into the sea and didn't involve human victims. For all the public knows, the next Watchkeeper crash could result in one of these million-pound airframes landing in their back gardens – or even a built-up area. ®

Similar topics


Other stories you might like

  • Google to build cut of its cloud operated by France’s Thales, for French government clients
    Sovereign cloud meets hyperscale

    Google and French defence and industry titan Thales have cooked up an interesting arrangement that will see the latter create a sovereign version of the G-Cloud.

    The two have created a joint venture in which Thales – a sprawling entity with interests in aerospace, defence, transport, and energy – will hold a majority share. Together, they'll build a hyperscale cloud that uses Google's cloud tech but doesn't touch any of the ad giant's physical infrastructure.

    The result will be a cloud that behaves like the G-Cloud but, as it is resident on French soil and Google doesn't control it, meets local standards for government use.

    Continue reading
  • Thales launches payment card with onboard fingerprint scanner
    Would you like to pay with a poke?

    Thales has announced what it claims is the "world's first" payment card to include an onboard fingerprint sensor, promising improved security and usability – and an end to contactless payment limits.

    The Thales Gemalto Biometric Sensor Payment card (BSPC), the company explained, replaces the traditional PIN with an on-card fingerprint sensor and requires no modifications to existing point-of-sale (POS) payment terminals. Banks signing up to use it, though, will need to implement a procedure for enrolling users' fingerprints onto the card's secure element.

    Thales claimed to have implemented the card with banks worldwide, boasting of 30 months of live trials and 10,000 users across nine countries including the UK. "Over 80 per cent of users interviewed confirmed they love it and feel it's more convenient and provides greater security," Frédéric Martinez, product line manager for biometric and advanced payment at Thales, told The Register.

    Continue reading
  • Software in space race heats up: Microsoft eyes satellite image processing with Thales Alenia Space's digital image analyst
    DeeperVision software coming to Azure Marketplace

    Microsoft has buddied up with Thales Alenia Space as it continues to set up ground stations in its data centres as part of its Azure Orbital push.

    The company is up against stiff competition from cloud rival AWS in the Ground-station-as-a-Service stakes. Last month Bezos' team dangled $1m of cloud credit before space startups as part of its Space Accelerator programme. AWS Ground Station itself became available ahead of Azure Orbital in 2019, leaving Microsoft with a bit to do to win the hearts and hydrazine of satellite operators.

    To help it on its way, Microsoft has signed up Thales Alenia Space (TAS), a joint venture between Thales (67 per cent) and Leonardo (33 per cent). In 2020 TAS laid claim to revenues of €1.85bn and its 7,700 employees over ten countries.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022