Splitting off Google Shopping wouldn't fix the pay-to-play problem

Underdogs fail to see how that's a competition 'remedy'

As the European Commission mulls Google's own remedy to its anti-competitive behaviour on the web, the former startup behind the original complaint has warned of possible consequences.

Foundem was destroyed by Google's promotion of its own Google Shopping – which doesn't offer customers the best deal, but is another pay-for-placement ad channel, a shop window.

The European Commission already found that Alphabet is guilty of infringing Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union by introducing this, but spent years stalling a formal decision in the hope Google would reform.

Faced with a record fine, Google is now invited to come up with its own solution that should, we learn from a tender document, create a level playing field.

Any measure chosen by Google must, however, ensure that it treats competing comparison shopping services no less favourably than its own comparison shopping service within its general search results pages. The above-mentioned principles should apply irrespective of whether Google chooses to display a Shopping Unit3 or another equivalent form of grouping of links to or search results from comparison shopping services.

Surprisingly the pay-for-placement (aka "pay to play") solution is back on the table, already proposed three times during former competition commissioner Joaquín Almunia's tenure. And apparently it's finding favour.

Here are the options.

google options

A Cease and Desist solution would mean that results from bona fide vertical search companies would appear in the search results. Foundem says Google is lobbying furiously to avoid this.

A second option would be a capped auction. Prospective sellers would still need to pay Google to appear, but the amount would be capped at a nominal cost-recoupment level. This might qualify as "equal treatment". It's the closest to the randomised "browser ballot" imposed on Microsoft for abusing its Windows monopoly to promote Internet Explorer.

Google also has the options to close down Google Shopping, or split it off into a separate company. So Google Search Inc. would operate independently of Alphabet. Both of these are called "structural" remedies. Three years ago the Parliament, in a political shot across the bow of the Commission, voted to break up Google.

But Foundem isn't keen.

"It would be horrible for consumers," Shivaun Raff told The Register. "Consumers would still be getting pay-for-placement ads, not proper price comparison engines. Real price comparison engines present the item with the lowest price – and they wouldn't be able to compete."

Last week a French comparison site said it couldn't take part.

"It doesn't work for us: how could we bid on a system that will cost us a lot more than what we make on a sale? We cannot bid without changing the philosophy of our website," an executive told Bloomberg.

Raff thinks that ultimately Google benefits from being seen to play fair – and not bet with the house's money.

"If Google ignores this opportunity for a don't-be-evil reset, and instead carries on with its greed-fuelled pretence that pay-for-placement ads and relevance-based search results are interchangeable, this could even make the beginning of the end for Google," Foundem concludes.

In 2001 Alphabet CEO Larry Page said that Google would win more users if it was trustworthy. Turning search results into another ad channel makes it less so.

"We believe that advertising and editorial should be split. We do the best job we can with computers and such to give you the best search result content. We don't do pay for placement," said Page.

Sounds like another era. ®

Broader topics

Other stories you might like

  • VMware claims 'bare-metal' performance on virtualized GPUs
    Is... is that why Broadcom wants to buy it?

    The future of high-performance computing will be virtualized, VMware's Uday Kurkure has told The Register.

    Kurkure, the lead engineer for VMware's performance engineering team, has spent the past five years working on ways to virtualize machine-learning workloads running on accelerators. Earlier this month his team reported "near or better than bare-metal performance" for Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) and Mask R-CNN — two popular machine-learning workloads — running on virtualized GPUs (vGPU) connected using Nvidia's NVLink interconnect.

    NVLink enables compute and memory resources to be shared across up to four GPUs over a high-bandwidth mesh fabric operating at 6.25GB/s per lane compared to PCIe 4.0's 2.5GB/s. The interconnect enabled Kurkure's team to pool 160GB of GPU memory from the Dell PowerEdge system's four 40GB Nvidia A100 SXM GPUs.

    Continue reading
  • Nvidia promises annual updates across CPU, GPU, and DPU lines
    Arm one year, x86 the next, and always faster than a certain chip shop that still can't ship even one standalone GPU

    Computex Nvidia's push deeper into enterprise computing will see its practice of introducing a new GPU architecture every two years brought to its CPUs and data processing units (DPUs, aka SmartNICs).

    Speaking on the company's pre-recorded keynote released to coincide with the Computex exhibition in Taiwan this week, senior vice president for hardware engineering Brian Kelleher spoke of the company's "reputation for unmatched execution on silicon." That's language that needs to be considered in the context of Intel, an Nvidia rival, again delaying a planned entry to the discrete GPU market.

    "We will extend our execution excellence and give each of our chip architectures a two-year rhythm," Kelleher added.

    Continue reading
  • Amazon puts 'creepy' AI cameras in UK delivery vans
    Big Bezos is watching you

    Amazon is reportedly installing AI-powered cameras in delivery vans to keep tabs on its drivers in the UK.

    The technology was first deployed, with numerous errors that reportedly denied drivers' bonuses after malfunctions, in the US. Last year, the internet giant produced a corporate video detailing how the cameras monitor drivers' driving behavior for safety reasons. The same system is now apparently being rolled out to vehicles in the UK. 

    Multiple camera lenses are placed under the front mirror. One is directed at the person behind the wheel, one is facing the road, and two are located on either side to provide a wider view. The cameras are monitored by software built by Netradyne, a computer-vision startup focused on driver safety. This code uses machine-learning algorithms to figure out what's going on in and around the vehicle.

    Continue reading
  • AWS puts latest homebrew ‘Graviton 3’ Arm CPU in production
    Just one instance type for now, but cheaper than third-gen Xeons or EPYCs

    Amazon Web Services has made its latest homebrew CPU, the Graviton3, available to rent in its Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2) infrastructure-as-a-service offering.

    The cloud colossus launched Graviton3 at its late 2021 re:Invent conference, revealing that the 55-billion-transistor device includes 64 cores, runs at 2.6GHz clock speed, can address DDR5 RAM and 300GB/sec max memory bandwidth, and employs 256-bit Scalable Vector Extensions.

    The chips were offered as a tech preview to select customers. And on Monday, AWS made them available to all comers in a single instance type named C7g.

    Continue reading
  • Beijing reverses ban on tech companies listing offshore
    Announcement comes as Chinese ride-hailing DiDi Chuxing delists from NYSE under pressure

    The Chinese government has announced that it will again allow "platform companies" – Beijing's term for tech giants – to list on overseas stock markets, marking a loosening of restrictions on the sector.

    "Platform companies will be encouraged to list on domestic and overseas markets in accordance with laws and regulations," announced premier Li Keqiang at an executive meeting of China's State Council – a body akin to cabinet in the USA or parliamentary democracies.

    The statement comes a week after vice premier Liu He advocated technology and government cooperation and a digital economy that supports an opening to "the outside world" to around 100 members of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Congress (CPPCC).

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022