You can find me in da club, database full of faces… but this ain't privacy watchers' jam
Facial recognition app promises to verify your age to bouncers
Five clubs in Bournemouth are now accepting ID in the form of an app that verifies who you are through facial recognition – to the disdain of privacy activists.
The town is the first in the UK to accept the digital identity app Yoti, which claims to offer users a safer way to prove they are who they claim to be.
Users sign up to Yoti, which verifies their face and identification, and acts as a trusted third party when the person gets to the club and scans their Yoti app at the door.
Cameo, Halo, Truth, Yates and Walkabout rolled out the tech on Wednesday night.
The first step in the sign-up process is for a user to send a selfie and a live video clip of them saying three words to Yoti, and then use their phone camera to scan their ID, such as a driving licence or passport.
The biz then verifies that the faces match using facial recognition technology, and claims to carry out "additional checks" to ensure the ID is authentic.
Emma Butler, the data protection officer for Yoti, said that not all these checks are automated, and that there is a team of people trained to spot potentially fraudulent docs.
But the biz told The Register that it can't say anymore about those checks in case someone games it – so we don't know, for instance, if the team works with the issuing agencies to guarantee the documents.
Yoti also lays its privacy and security credentials on thick, trotting out phrases like "advanced hybrid encryption" and "secure 'cleanroom'" in its PR puff.
But Alan Woodward, a security researcher at the University of Surrey, said: "If they want the security community to take a look they need to provide a lot more detail.
"Unless they are willing to open it up to such scrutiny I'd suggest anyone thinks twice before entrusting their most valuable ID documents to them. Security through obscurity is no security at all."
However, Yoti is bullish about its security systems, so much so that it points to high-profile hacks like Equifax and Uber as examples of what can go wrong without a new approach.
"Because, despite what the pundits say, the Pandora's Box of personal data can be sealed again," co-founder and CEO Robin Tombs said in a blogpost.
Its answer is to encrypt each piece of information – date of birth, name, address and so on – individually using different 256-bit keys, and store it separately in the biz's UK data centres.
"They can only be retrieved and put back together using the private keys stored on your device," the firm said.
"So, even if our database was breached, hackers would only see a random jumble of data from millions of different users. Just names, dates of birth, genders... nothing to connect them together to create a meaningful profile."
Users need a PIN and their face to log into the app on their phone and Yoti insists it can't access any of its users' data, ever. The ID documents, meanwhile, are stored for seven days while the details are verified.
When they want to get into the club, they choose what type of data to hand over – like date of birth – without having to pass on their name or address at the same time.
They scan a QR code, which shows the bouncer their pic and date of birth and the bouncer checks that picture with the person in front of them. Every time the user hands over some of the information, both parties get a receipt that creates an audit trail.
At this point it's worth noting that some police and licensing authorities now require clubs to keep a record of club-goers, leading to a rise in compulsory ID scanning (no, El Reg hasn't been out in a while, either).
Butler argued that using Yoti means people are handing over less data to the club, because it is limited to the salient points of face and date of birth.
However, privacy activists see the use of facial recognition technology to verify your ID just to get into a club as a step too far.
"This software uses a biometric analysis of its users' faces, creating data that is as sensitive as DNA or fingerprints," said Big Brother Watch.
"The growing prevalence of facial recognition in China has caused great controversy, yet this intrusive technology is now being normalised and trivialised in the UK. We are deeply concerned by such casual use of biometric checks." ®
- Black Hat
- Common Vulnerability Scoring System
- Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency
- Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act
- Data Breach
- Data Theft
- Digital certificate
- Identity Theft
- Kenna Security
- Palo Alto Networks
- Privacy Sandbox
- Trusted Platform Module
- Zero trust