NAND chips are going to stay too pricey for flash to slit disk's throat...

For a while at least... spinning rust is going to stick around

Analysis Flash chip bits cost eight times more than spinning rust and SSDs aren't going to get cheap enough to kill off disk entirely.

The cost/TB of flash storage has been dropping for several years as chip capacity has increased through making smaller cells then layering cells with 3D NAND. It means you can get more chips from a NAND wafer and they cost less.

Flash is much faster to access than disk, but it is more expensive, meaning that performance-sensitive use cases have been moving from disk to flash, where the extra cost is justified.

So we have seen 15,000rpm disk drives being replaced by SSDs, and facing potential and probable demise, and the 10,000rpm disk drive space facing SSD invasion too.

What about higher-capacity, nearline drives?

SSD capacities have been rising faster than disk, with 15TB+ SSDs now available – witness the 100TB Viking SSD – compared to the largest 14TB disk drives.

Another leap in capacity is coming with QLC (4bits/cell) flash, offering a third more capacity per cell than current TLC (3bits/cell).

The effect of this, with flash being so much faster than disk, will be for fast-access nearline drive use cases to transition to flash too.

Disk drive capacity is also getting cheaper, as Seagate's drive roadmap shows, with capacities rising to 40TB+ in a few years time.

As more flash manufacturing capacity comes on stream will SSDs kill HDDs? And will SSD capacity cost reductions beat disk capacity cost reductions to enable a crossover?

Gartner research suggests not.

Here's a chart showing Gartner SSD and HDD cost trends from 2014 out to 2021:


Click to enlarge

We saw the chart at an Infinidat briefing. It shows a dramatic drop in average SSD prices, from around $0.84/GB in 2014 to an anticipated $0.10/GB in 2021. Disk drive price erosion is happening at what looks like a slower rate, from around $0.085/GB in 2014 to $0.001 or so in 2021. Surely there will be a coming together of the two lines?

The green line shows the percentage difference (right-hand axis) between SSD and HDD $/GB prices. It is just above 90 per cent, meaning a 9X differential in 2014, moving to around 85 per cent in 2021.

What this indicates is that the SDD and HDD price erosion curves are moving in parallel, not coming together.

So long as the disk drive manufacturers can keep increasing capacity fast enough then they will retain a cost/GB advantage over SSDs. We can model this continued separation simply enough.

Here's a chart showing a 30 per cent annual price reduction in SSD and HDD prices, starting with a $1,000 SSD price and $100 disk price:


The difference columns are steady across the time periods. If we change the vertical axis to a log scale then these steady state parallel erosion curves become obvious:


The Infinidat angle

Why is Infinidat bothered?

It doesn't make all-flash arrays. All the main disk drive array suppliers are moving to all-flash arrays (AFAs) while Infinidat sticks with disk arrays leavened with a bit of secondary flash cache, relying for performance on primary DRAM caching. It claims a 90 per cent or more read hit rate from its DRAM cache.

So the AFA people say flash performance trumps disk. But Infinidat says DRAM cache-enhanced performance off disk is even better and a deal cheaper than AFAs.

OK, if its DRAM cache technology is so great then why aren't the AFA suppliers using it?

The Infinidat price/performance advantage comes into effect with high-capacity arrays, 1PB and upwards, which the AFA suppliers tend to ignore. And in this area, Infinidat says, it has an enduring advantage. That depends upon high-end arrays from Dell EMC (VMAX), IBM (DS8000) and Hitachi Vantara (USP) not developing their own DRAM caching technology.

If Infinidat makes any kind of dent in their sales enough then they will, and/or look at other performance boosters like storage-class memory and NVMe over Fabrics. Life in this business is just so much fun! ®

Broader topics

Other stories you might like

  • Gartner predicts 9.5% drop in PC shipments
    Stark contrast to 11 percent increase year-over-year in 2021 shipments

    The party is over for PC makers as figures from Gartner suggest the market is on course for a breathtaking decline this year.

    According to the analysts, worldwide PC shipments will decline by 9.5 percent, with consumer demand leading the way – a 13.5 percent drop is forecast, far greater than business PC demand, which is expected to drop by 7.2 percent year on year.

    The PC market in the EMEA region is forecast to fare even worse, with a 14 percent decline on the cards for 2022. Gartner pointed the finger of blame at uncertainty caused by conflicts, price increases and simple unavailability of products. Lockdowns in China were also blamed for an impact in consumer demand.

    Continue reading
  • Governments opt for XaaS, dump datacenters in droves
    Outsource all the things! To whom? The lowest bidder of course, says Gartner

    The world's governments are eager to let someone else handle their IT headaches, according to a recent Gartner report, which found a healthy appetite for "anything-as-a-service" (XaaS) platforms to cut the costs of bureaucracy.

    These trends will push government IT spending to $565 billion in 2022, up 5 percent from last year, the analyst house claims. Gartner believes the majority of new government IT investments will be on service platforms by 2026.

    "The pandemic sped up public-sector adoption of cloud solutions and the XaaS model for accelerated legacy modernization and new service implementations," Gartner analyst Daniel Snyder said in a release. "Fifty-four percent of government CIOs responding to the 2022 Gartner CIO survey indicated that they expect to allocate additional funding to cloud platforms in 2022, while 35 percent will decrease investments in legacy infrastructure and datacenter technologies."

    Continue reading
  • Western Digital open to spinning out flash, hard disk businesses
    Messrs Elliott strike again

    Western Digital has confirmed the board is considering "strategic alternatives" for the storage supplier, including spinning out its flash and hard disk businesses.

    This follows calls last month by activist investor Elliott Management, which has amassed a $1 billion investment in WD equating to a six percent share stake, for a "full separation" based on those product lines.

    In a statement, CEO David Goeckeler said: "The board is aligned in the belief that maximizing value creation warrants a comprehensive assessment of strategic alternatives focused on structural options for the company's Flash and HDD businesses.

    Continue reading
  • Renegotiating a Salesforce software agreement? It could take up to two years
    Salesforce complexity can be 'difficult and expensive to govern', especially for multicloud, warns Gartner

    The set of enterprise technologies acquired by Salesforce in recent years, together with its own applications, have proved "more difficult and expensive to govern than expected for many customers," says Gartner.

    The global tech analyst offered a balanced view of the SaaS company in a research report, saying Salesforce was "strong" in both its strategy and corporate viability. However, its overall rating had fallen from "strong" to "positive".

    For context, Gartner offers a five step rating, with the first three being "weak", "caution" and "variable." Salesforce's rating for products and services also slid, dropping from "strong" to "positive."

    Continue reading
  • Samsung unveils hardened SD card that can last 16 years if you treat it right
    And apply an asterisk or two

    Samsung has dished up a new variety of SD card that can, it claims, sustain 16 years of continual writes.

    The Korean giant's calculations for the longevity of the PRO Endurance Memory Card – for that is the new tech's name – assume their use to record 1920×1080 video content at 26Mbit/sec (3.25MB/sec).

    At that rate, the 256GB model is rated to endure 140,160 hours of use. Smaller capacity models won't last as long because they'll be overwritten more often, so the 128GB, 64GB and 32GB each halve their larger sibling's lifetime.

    Continue reading
  • Oracle contracts and pricing a 'challenge', says Gartner
    While heaping praise on Big Red, analysts find room to criticize licensing, negotiations, and integration

    Oracle's pricing models and contracts can be "challenging to navigate" and "frustrating for customers," according to a Gartner report that otherwise heaps praise on the omnipresent enterprise software company.

    The global analyst has published its vendor rating report on Big Red, judging the Larry Ellison-founded company to have a broad and competitive technology portfolio, a vertically integrated and mostly self-developed platform, and a proven track record in revenue retention, growth, and profitability.

    But elsewhere Gartner found cause for concern. "Oracle's pricing models and contracts can be challenging to navigate, which, coupled to Oracle's focus on increasing cloud product revenue, can be frustrating for customers who wish to only maintain their existing on-premises commitments," the report said.

    Continue reading
  • Cloud spending to scrape $500 billion this year – Gartner
    Growing enterprise demand for more complex cloud-native services carries a higher price tag

    Global spending on public cloud services will come close to $500 billion this year, according to research firm Gartner.

    Growing uptake of cloud-native infrastructure services is identified as one of the key drivers, but the trend towards hybrid work scenarios driven by the pandemic is also playing a part.

    Gartner forecasts that the spend on public cloud services will grow by 20.4 percent this year to reach a total $494.7b, a rate of growth that the researchers believes will continue through 2023 to deliver a total of nearly $600b next year.

    Continue reading
  • Linux kernel patch from Google speeds up server shutdowns
    First world problems: Too many NVMe drives, not enough seconds to spare

    A new Linux kernel patch from a Google engineer resolves a problem caused by a condition that many of us might quite like to experience – having too many NVMe drives.

    The problem is caused by the relatively long time it takes to properly shut down a drive: apparently, as much as four-and-a-half seconds.

    Remember Sun's X4500 storage server, originally codenamed Thumper? It was truly radical when it appeared: a 3U dual-processor server, but with a stonking 48 drive bays. These days Google has a bunch of boxes with a still-fairly-impressive 16 NVMe drives attached to each one. And when they have to reboot, they take a long time.

    Continue reading
  • Backblaze report finds SSDs as reliable as HDDs
    But warns sample size is a bit small to leap to big conclusions

    Backblaze has published the first SSD edition of its regular drive statistics report, which appears to show that flash drives are as reliable as spinning disks, although with surprising failure rates for some models.

    The cloud storage and backup provider publishes quarterly and annual Drive Stat reports, which focused exclusively on rotating hard drives until last year. Backblaze said it will initially publish the SSD edition twice a year, but that this may change depending on how valuable readers find it. The 2021 Drive Stats report was published in February.

    In a blog post detailing the latest probing, Backblaze cloud storage evangelist Andy Klein said the SSDs are all used as boot drives in the firm's storage servers, and that Backblaze only began using SSDs this way from Q4 of 2018. He pointed out the drives do more than just boot the servers, they also store log files and temporary files produced by the servers, and so each SSD will read, write, and delete files depending on the activity of the server during the day.

    Continue reading
  • Only 29% of techies truly want to stay in current job
    Great Resignation? Flexibility and work-life-balance key factors in how IT staff choose next employer

    Researchers at Gartner are finding that only 29 percent of IT workers globally have a "high intent" to stay in their current roles.

    Younger techies are even less likely to stick around than their older counterparts, according to the survey of 18,000 employees conducted in the final three months of 2021 – with 1,755 of the respondents working in IT. The study found only 16 percent of IT workers aged between 19 and 29 plan to stay put, versus 48 percent for the 50- to 70-year-old bracket.

    IT workers in Europe were most likely to remain loyal, at 40 percent, while 28 percent of those in the US said they weren't planning to move on. Australia and New Zealand had the most fleetfooted IT workforce: only 18 percent were intending to stay with their current employer.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022