Whois privacy shambles becomes last-minute mad data scramble

Internet address industry given one week to introduce unfinished GDPR policy

Thousands of internet registries and registrars will have just one week to overhaul their customer databases to fit with a policy that is still under development, or face ruinous fines.

That is the end result of an extraordinary failure by the organization that oversees the internet's domain name system to address a change in European law: a change finalized two years ago.

The companies that sell internet address and run fundamental pieces of the internet's infrastructure, such as the .com registry, have been told by DNS overseer ICANN that its board expects to approve a new temporary policy covering the storing and publication of domain name registration data – called Whois - this week.

tired businessman

Europe fires back at ICANN's delusional plan to overhaul Whois for GDPR by next, er, year


A draft of that new Whois policy [PDF] was only published five days ago but ICANN has told the companies - that are under contract to it - that they need to implement its contents before May 25 in order to bring themselves in line with the GDPR privacy legislation.

If they are found not to be in compliance with the law, those companies face multi-million-dollar fines from European regulators, and ICANN also warned that it would carry out compliance audits to its still-unfinished rules to make sure they are being followed.

The task of complying with that temporary policy has been made even harder however by the fact that the draft policy was changed three days after it was first published and further changes may happen before it is finally approved on Thursday, especially if European data protection regulators respond to questions ICANN asked them less than a week ago.

So, um, details...

In addition, several critical aspects of the new policy remain undecided, making it hard for registries and registrars to know what to do.

And the entire policy will expire in 90 days, at which point it will either be extended, or it will be tweaked to include more changes aimed at bringing ICANN in line with the new law.

Unsurprisingly, the response by the impacted companies has been one of anger tinged with confusion.

Many of those companies started implementing their own policies ahead of the GDPR deadline after ICANN failed to develop a policy in time and instead asked for European regulators to give it a special one-year "moratorium" on applying the law: something that those regulators pointed out they were in no position to approve.

The heart of the problem is that the personal details of domain name registrants – including their name, home and email address, and phone number – are published on the internet under the current Whois system.

That approach is illegal under the new GDPR legislation since it does not allow people to withhold their personal information; there is no permission sought for publication.

But ICANN has been resistant to changing the current rules, in large part because powerful US corporate interests want the current rules retained and feel that European laws should not override the current system put in place by US corporations and overseen by a US organization. That resistance has led ICANN right up to the deadline with no agreed solution.

It was only when European registries informed ICANN they would be disregarding parts of the US-based organization's contract because they were not compatible with the law of the countries in which they are based, that ICANN finally took action.

Three-legged stool

There are three main issues that ICANN seeks to address with its last-minute temporary policy:

  1. It wants companies to continue to gather all the same registration information – including people's names, home addresses and telephone numbers - even if they don't publish it all.
  2. It wants them to come up with some kind of system to let authorized users to access that information.
  3. It wants them to make it possible for third parties to contact registrants via email without having to seek permission from anyone else.

While those aims are understandable and legitimate given the purpose of the Whois service – to allow people to recognize who controls a given internet address – it will require significant changes to the companies computer systems in an incredibly tight window, with no certainty that those changes won't need to be discarded in a few months time when a revised policy in put out.

Previously, registrars had warned that shifting all their systems just to handle anonymized email address so domain owners can be contacted without being directly identified would take four months. They will have little more than four days.

The most critical and complex aspect however is the accredited access component. Registries and registrar will need to figure out a way to grant specific people access to non-private data but there is no guidance over the best way to do this or even who is eligible to gain that level of access.

ICANN hopes to be able to come up with a permanent solution to Whois that will answer those – and many more – questions within a year by running a special fast-track policy process.

Even if that process runs smoothly, however, the internet infrastructure industry is now going to have to deal with 12 months of uncertainty with the prospect of huge fines if they get it wrong. ®

Similar topics

Other stories you might like

  • Chip shortage forces temporary Raspberry Pi 4 price rise for the first time

    Ten-buck increase for 2GB model 'not here to stay' says Upton

    The price of a 2GB Raspberry Pi 4 single-board computer is going up $10, and its supply is expected to be capped at seven million devices this year due to the ongoing global chip shortage.

    Demand for components is outstripping manufacturing capacity at the moment; pre-pandemic, assembly lines were being red-lined as cloud giants and others snapped up parts fresh out of the fabs, and the COVID-19 coronavirus outbreak really threw a spanner in the works, so to speak, exacerbating the situation.

    Everything from cars to smartphones have been affected by semiconductor supply constraints, including Raspberry Pis, it appears. Stock is especially tight for the Raspberry Pi Zero and the 2GB Raspberry Pi 4 models, we're told. As the semiconductor crunch shows no signs of letting up, the Raspberry Pi project is going to bump up the price for one particular model.

    Continue reading
  • Uncle Sam to clip wings of Pegasus-like spyware – sorry, 'intrusion software' – with proposed export controls

    Surveillance tech faces trade limits as America syncs policy with treaty obligations

    More than six years after proposing export restrictions on "intrusion software," the US Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) has formulated a rule that it believes balances the latitude required to investigate cyber threats with the need to limit dangerous code.

    The BIS on Wednesday announced an interim final rule that defines when an export license will be required to distribute what is basically commercial spyware, in order to align US policy with the 1996 Wassenaar Arrangement, an international arms control regime.

    The rule [PDF] – which spans 65 pages – aims to prevent the distribution of surveillance tools, like NSO Group's Pegasus, to countries subject to arms controls, like China and Russia, while allowing legitimate security research and transactions to continue. Made available for public comment over the next 45 days, the rule is scheduled to be finalized in 90 days.

    Continue reading
  • Global IT spending to hit $4.5 trillion in 2022, says Gartner

    The future's bright, and expensive

    Corporate technology soothsayer Gartner is forecasting worldwide IT spending will hit $4.5tr in 2022, up 5.5 per cent from 2021.

    The strongest growth is set to come from enterprise software, which the analyst firm expects to increase by 11.5 per cent in 2022 to reach a global spending level of £670bn. Growth has fallen slightly, though. In 2021 it was 13.6 per cent for this market segment. The increase was driven by infrastructure software spending, which outpaced application software spending.

    The largest chunk of IT spending is set to remain communication services, which will reach £1.48tr next year, after modest growth of 2.1 per cent. The next largest category is IT services, which is set to grow by 8.9 per cent to reach $1.29tr over the next year, according to the analysts.

    Continue reading
  • Memory maker Micron moots $150bn mega manufacturing moneybag

    AI and 5G to fuel demand for new plants and R&D

    Chip giant Micron has announced a $150bn global investment plan designed to support manufacturing and research over the next decade.

    The memory maker said it would include expansion of its fabrication facilities to help meet demand.

    As well as chip shortages due to COVID-19 disruption, the $21bn-revenue company said it wanted to take advantage of the fact memory and storage accounts for around 30 per cent of the global semiconductor industry today.

    Continue reading
  • China to allow overseas investment in VPNs but Beijing keeps control of the generally discouraged tech

    Foreign ownership capped at 50%

    After years of restricting the use and ownership of VPNs, Beijing has agreed to let foreign entities hold up to a 50 per cent stake in domestic VPN companies.

    China has simultaneously a huge market and strict rules for VPNs as the country's Great Firewall attempts to keep its residents out of what it deems undesirable content and influence, such as Facebook or international news outlets.

    And while VPN technology is not illegal per se (it's just not practical for multinationals and other entities), users need a licence to operate one.

    Continue reading
  • Microsoft unveils Android apps for Windows 11 (for US users only)

    Windows Insiders get their hands on the Windows Subsystem for Android

    Microsoft has further teased the arrival of the Windows Subsystem for Android by detailing how the platform will work via a newly published document for Windows Insiders.

    The document, spotted by inveterate Microsoft prodder "WalkingCat" makes for interesting reading for developers keen to make their applications work in the Windows Subsystem for Android (WSA).

    WSA itself comprises the Android OS based on the Android Open Source Project 1.1 and, like the Windows Subsystem for Linux, runs in a virtual machine.

    Continue reading
  • Software Freedom Conservancy sues TV maker Vizio for GPL infringement

    Companies using GPL software should meet their obligations, lawsuit says

    The Software Freedom Conservancy (SFC), a non-profit which supports and defends free software, has taken legal action against Californian TV manufacturer Vizio Inc, claiming "repeated failures to fulfill even the basic requirements of the General Public License (GPL)."

    Member projects of the SFC include the Debian Copyright Aggregation Project, BusyBox, Git, GPL Compliance Project for Linux Developers, Homebrew, Mercurial, OpenWrt, phpMyAdmin, QEMU, Samba, Selenium, Wine, and many more.

    The GPL Compliance Project is described as "comprised of copyright holders in the kernel, Linux, who have contributed to Linux under its license, the GPLv2. These copyright holders have formally asked Conservancy to engage in compliance efforts for their copyrights in the Linux kernel."

    Continue reading
  • DRAM, it stacks up: SK hynix rolls out 819GB/s HBM3 tech

    Kit using the chips to appear next year at the earliest

    Korean DRAM fabber SK hynix has developed an HBM3 DRAM chip operating at 819GB/sec.

    HBM3 (High Bandwidth Memory 3) is a third generation of the HBM architecture which stacks DRAM chips one above another, connects them by vertical current-carrying holes called Through Silicon Vias (TSVs) to a base interposer board, via connecting micro-bumps, upon which is fastened a processor that accesses the data in the DRAM chip faster than it would through the traditional CPU socket interface.

    Seon-yong Cha, SK hynix's senior vice president for DRAM development, said: "Since its launch of the world's first HBM DRAM, SK hynix has succeeded in developing the industry's first HBM3 after leading the HBM2E market. We will continue our efforts to solidify our leadership in the premium memory market."

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021