Facebook, Google, Microsoft scolded for tricking people into spilling their private info

Manipulative user interfaces lead netizens away from privacy

Five consumer privacy groups have asked the European Data Protection Board to investigate how Facebook, Google, and Microsoft design their software to see whether it complies with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).

Essentially, the tech giants are accused of crafting their user interfaces so that netizens are fooled into clicking away their privacy, and handing over their personal information.

In a letter sent today to chairwoman Andrea Jelinek, the BEUC (Bureau Européen des Unions de Consommateurs), the Norwegian Consumer Council (Forbrukerrådet), Consumers International, Privacy International and ANEC (just too damn long to spell out) contend that the three tech giants "employed numerous tricks and tactics to nudge or push consumers toward giving consent to sharing as much data for as many purposes as possible."

The letter coincides with the publication a Forbrukerrådet report, "Deceived By Design," that claims "tech companies use dark patterns to discourage us from exercising our rights to privacy."

Dark patterns here refers to app interface design choices that attempt to influence users to do things they may not want to do because they benefit the software maker.

The report faults Google, Facebook and, to a lesser degree, Microsoft for employing default settings that dispense with privacy. It also says they use misleading language, give users an illusion of control, conceal pro-privacy choices, offer take-it-or-leave it choices and use design patterns that make it more laborious to choose privacy.

It argues that dark patterns deprive users of control, a central requirement under GDPR.

As an example of linguistic deception, the report cites Facebook text that seeks permission to use facial recognition on images:

If you keep face recognition turned off, we won’t be able to use this technology if a stranger uses your photo to impersonate you. If someone uses a screen reader, they won’t be told when you’re in a photo unless you’re tagged.

The way this is worded, the report says, pushes Facebook users to accept facial recognition by suggesting there's a risk of impersonation if they refuse. And it implies there's something unethical about depriving those forced to use screen readers of image descriptions, a practice known as "confirmshaming."

Hand locking door

GDPR forgive us, it's been one month since you were enforced…


Similar issues are called out in Google's app interface design. If users elect to turn off ad personalization, they are presented with another menu presenting the supposed benefits of personalization that asks users to reconsider their choice. There's no such menu presenting potential benefits of disabling ad personalization or the negative impact of leaving personalization enabled, the report points out.

Criticism of Microsoft's Windows 10 is more muted, though it too gets chided for encouraging acceptance of ad personalization and employing menu language and graphics designed to maximize data collection.

Asked to comment on the report's findings, a Facebook spokesperson did not address the claims directly and instead, in an email, said the company has been preparing for GDPR over the past 18 months and, as a consequence, has made its policies and privacy settings clearer.

"Our approach complies with the law, follows recommendations from privacy and design experts, and are designed to help people understand how the technology works and their choices," a Facebook spokesperson said.

Google too choose not to attempt to challenge any of the report's claims and simply insisted it tests its designs.

"We've evolved our data controls over many years to ensure people can easily understand, and use, the array of tools available to them," a Google spokesperson told The Register via email.

"Feedback from both the research community and our users, along with extensive UI testing, helps us reflect users’ privacy preferences. For example, in the last month alone, we’ve made further improvements to our Ad Settings and Google Account information and controls."

Microsoft said it was aware of the report without specifically addressing any of the claims therein.

"We have seen the report from Norway and would like to reinforce that we are committed to GDPR compliance across our cloud services, and provide GDPR related assurances in our contractual commitments," a Microsoft spokesperson said, pointing to a past blog post on the subject. ®

Other stories you might like

  • Running Windows 10? Microsoft is preparing to fire up the update engines

    Winter Windows Is Coming

    It's coming. Microsoft is preparing to start shoveling the latest version of Windows 10 down the throats of refuseniks still clinging to older incarnations.

    The Windows Update team gave the heads-up through its Twitter orifice last week. Windows 10 2004 was already on its last gasp, have had support terminated in December. 20H2, on the other hand, should be good to go until May this year.

    Continue reading
  • Throw away your Ethernet cables* because MediaTek says Wi-Fi 7 will replace them

    *Don't do this

    MediaTek claims to have given the world's first live demo of Wi-Fi 7, and said that the upcoming wireless technology will be able to challenge wired Ethernet for high-bandwidth applications, once available.

    The fabless Taiwanese chip firm said it is currently showcasing two Wi-Fi 7 demos to key customers and industry collaborators, in order to demonstrate the technology's super-fast speeds and low latency transmission.

    Based on the IEEE 802.11be standard, the draft version of which was published last year, Wi-Fi 7 is expected to provide speeds several times faster than Wi-Fi 6 kit, offering connections of at least 30Gbps and possibly up to 40Gbps.

    Continue reading
  • Windows box won't boot? SystemRescue 9 may help

    An ISO image you can burn or drop onto a USB key

    The latest version of an old friend of the jobbing support bod has delivered a new kernel to help with fixing Microsoft's finest.

    It used to be called the System Rescue CD, but who uses CDs any more? Enter SystemRescue, an ISO image that you can burn, or just drop onto your Ventoy USB key, and which may help you to fix a borked Windows box. Or a borked Linux box, come to that.

    SystemRescue 9 includes Linux kernel 5.15 and a minimal Xfce 4.16 desktop (which isn't loaded by default). There is a modest selection of GUI tools: Firefox, VNC and RDP clients and servers, and various connectivity tools – SSH, FTP, IRC. There's also some security-related stuff such as Yubikey setup, KeePass, token management, and so on. The main course is a bunch of the usual Linux tools for partitioning, formatting, copying, and imaging disks. You can check SMART status, mount LVM volumes, rsync files, and other handy stuff.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022