Google settles Right To Be Forgotten case on eve of appeal hearing

Adtech monolith had won previous High Court fight against NT1

Google has settled a legal case brought against it by a convicted criminal who wanted the adtech company to delete embarrassing search results about his criminal past.

This morning, the Court of Appeal in London was due to hear the anonymised businessman's appeal against an earlier High Court ruling which said he couldn't have the results deleted.

Known only as NT1 thanks to a reporting restriction order, the man was found guilty of conspiracy to account falsely in the late 1990s. At the time he was involved with a controversial property company and his conviction was covered in national newspapers as well as being referred to in a book.

Two news articles and one book extract that had been indexed by Google were the focus of NT1's attempts to get the search results deleted.

The Royal Courts of Justice in London

Anon biz bloke wins milestone Google Right To Be Forgotten lawsuit


High Court judge Mr Justice Warby ruled in April this year that NT1 was not entitled to have his embarrassing past deleted from Google's search results in spite of asserting his so-called Right To Be Forgotten, stating that the married businessman had "misled" the court. NT1's convictions had become spent under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act.

NT1 appealed but Google settled the case out of court, on the eve of its going ahead. Google ignored our request for comment, while law firm Carter-Ruck, which represents NT1, declined to comment.

The Right To Be Forgotten stems from an EU court ruling in 2014 after an aggrieved man in Spain demanded a search result about his embarrassing past (a mortgage foreclosure) be wiped from Google.

The EU decreed that "outdated or irrelevant" search results must be deleted on request. As can be imagined, this vague ruling caused much confusion.

Google's barrister during the High Court case, Antony White QC, told the court in April: "This case is different in that the convictions arose not out of activities in NT1's private life, but out of activities in his, at the time, very high profile business venture. And our submission will be that spent convictions relating to serious business malpractice, particularly involving businesses which target consumers and investors, are likely to be of continuing relevance, especially where the convicted person is still active in business."

Google: Class search results as journalism so we can dodge Right To Be Forgotten


Observers had hoped that a Court of Appeal case on the Right To Be Forgotten (or, as Mr Justice Warby put it, "the right to not be remembered inaccurately") would clarify English law on the process of getting search results deleted. A settlement out of court, however, deprives the wider world of that.

At the time of writing, the offending search results were still showing up against searches for NT1's real name. ®

Similar topics

Broader topics

Other stories you might like

  • Dog forgets all about risk of drowning in a marsh as soon as drone dangles a sausage

    It's not the wurst idea in the world

    Man's best friend, though far from the dumbest animal, isn't that smart either. And if there's one sure-fire way to get a dog moving, it's the promise of a snack.

    In another fine example of drones being used as a force for good, this week a dog was rescued from mudflats in Hampshire on the south coast of England because it realised that chasing a sausage dangling from a UAV would be a preferable outcome to drowning as the tide rose.

    Or rather the tantalising treat overrode any instinct the pet had to avoid the incoming water.

    Continue reading
  • Almost there: James Webb Space Telescope frees its mirrors and prepares for insertion

    Freed of launch restraints, mirror segments can waggle at will

    NASA scientists have deployed mirrors on the James Webb Space Telescope ahead of a critical thruster firing on Monday.

    With less than 50,000km to go until the spacecraft reaches its L2 orbit, the segments that make up the primary mirror of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) are ready for alignment. The team carefully moved all 132 actuators lurking on the back of the primary mirror segments and secondary mirror, driving the former 12.5mm away from the telescope structure.

    Continue reading
  • Arm rages against the insecure chip machine with new Morello architecture

    Prototypes now available for testing

    Arm has made available for testing prototypes of its Morello architecture, aimed at bringing features into the design of CPUs that provide greater robustness and make them resistant to certain attack vectors. If it performs as expected, it will likely become a fundamental part of future processor designs.

    The Morello programme involves Arm collaborating with the University of Cambridge and others in tech to develop a processor architecture that is intended to be fundamentally more secure. Morello prototype boards are now being released for testing by developers and security specialists, based on a prototype system-on-chip (SoC) that Arm has built.

    Arm said that the limited-edition evaluation boards are based on the Morello prototype architecture embedded into an Armv8.2-A processor. This is an adaptation of the architecture in the Arm Neoverse N1 design aimed at data centre workloads.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022