SUSE, what? Adoption's still growing, shrugs OpenStack Foundation

Attention has shifted away from VMs, however, COO tells El Reg


OpenStack chief operating officer Mark Collier told The Reg that while SUSE's decision to abandon its OpenStack Cloud product is "obviously disappointing", adoption is "strong and growing".

SUSE's decision that it will "cease production of new versions of SUSE OpenStack Cloud" and "discontinue sales of SUSE OpenStack Cloud" is significant, given that it had a seat on the OpenStack board as a Platinum member – one of only eight companies which commits to provide major funding and full-time resources to the OpenStack Foundation, the others being AT&T, Ericsson, Huawei, Intel, Rackspace, Red Hat and Tencent. SUSE will now "carefully transition our board position and sponsorship level" according to a statement sent to The Reg, though it promises continued involvement at some level.

It is tempting therefore to treat Collier's remarks to The Reg as damage limitation, but in this case he has a point. OpenStack, which is a set of projects that enables users to run private clouds, has a huge customer base and its market is growing by about 20 per cent a year, according to recent figures and projections. There is not much competition if you want to run an open-source private cloud, and there can be good reasons to do so.

In 2017, Adobe (despite announcing a love-in with Microsoft Azure the previous year) said that it saved around 30 per cent by migrating an Advertising Cloud service from AWS to OpenStack. Another driver is to avoid vendor lock-in, cited by 83 per cent of organisations in a 2018 user survey as a reason for adoption.

OpenStack software providers are dominated by Huawei and EasyStack, then Red Hat and Rackspace.

OpenStack software providers are dominated by Huawei and EasyStack, then Red Hat and Canonical (click to enlarge)

China loves OpenStack, defending perhaps against political as well as vendor lock-in. The two biggest providers of OpenStack software are China-based Huawei and EasyStack, between them accounting for 50 per cent of deployments. Next is Red Hat, then Canonical. SUSE claimed just 3 per cent of the market, according to this same survey.

Man in office flippantly throws balls of paper in bin

SUSE tosses OpenStack Cloud to double down on application delivery

READ MORE

This is not the whole story, though. OpenStack remains important, but attention is shifting away from VMs to containers, and in particular Kubernetes (K8s). OpenStack is perceived more as a VM-based platform. "OpenStack is more VM-based infrastructure. I don't think they offer Kubernetes clusters," GitLab CEO Sid Sijbrandij said, rather inaccurately, when asked about GitLab's support for the product.

Similarly, Puppet CTO Nigel Kersten told The Reg: "I think a lot of the demand that was driving OpenStack, that energy and attention is going towards Kubernetes."

Container yourselves

This accounts for SUSE's change of direction. Products it will focus on instead of SUSE OpenStack Cloud include its CaaS (Container as a Service) Platform, based on K8s, and SUSE Cloud Application Platform, based on Cloud Foundry and with K8s deployment as an option. The model is that once set up, developers can simply code and deploy with auto-scaling built in.

Has OpenStack missed the K8s wave? "More than half our users run K8s on OpenStack," said Collier. In addition, "with all the big customers who run OpenStack, the OpenStack services are in containers," he told us. "If you look at someone like CERN, they have hundreds of thousands of cores of computer managed by OpenStack and then hundreds of clusters of K8s running on top of OpenStack using the OpenStack Magnum installer," he added.

In this context, several OpenStack projects are interesting. Magnum, for example, provides an API that automates K8s provisioning on OpenStack; Ironic does bare-metal provisioning; and Airship automates OpenStack and K8s deployment.

According to the user survey: "Within the deployments that are using Kubernetes to manage applications on OpenStack, there are notable increases in adoption of certain OpenStack projects, such as Ironic, as users turn to OpenStack to run container orchestration on bare metal. Thirty-seven per cent of OpenStack deployments that indicated they are running Kubernetes to manage applications indicated they are running Ironic in production."

The direction here is to abstract away the VMs and focus on provisioning K8s ready for application deployment. Could this be even better integrated into the core of OpenStack? "It is needed; it is happening," said Collier.

Will SUSE leave a gap in the OpenStack team? Collier made the point that skilled OpenStack developers are in high demand. "When one company decides to do less, the individuals with that expertise typically land at another organisation very quickly."

OpenStack, then, is not currently under threat as a useful technology, though in principle it is vulnerable if the big cloud vendors grab more share of IT infrastructure, as seems likely. The smaller cloud vendors may themselves run OpenStack.

Either way, though, OpenStack is becoming less interesting, unless you happen to be in the business of provisioning cloud infrastructure. The same may well happen to K8s itself. SUSE's move may well be a smart one. ®


Other stories you might like

  • End of the road for biz living off free G Suite legacy edition
    Firms accustomed to freebies miffed that web giant's largess doesn't last

    After offering free G Suite apps for more than a decade, Google next week plans to discontinue its legacy service – which hasn't been offered to new customers since 2012 – and force business users to transition to a paid subscription for the service's successor, Google Workspace.

    "For businesses, the G Suite legacy free edition will no longer be available after June 27, 2022," Google explains in its support document. "Your account will be automatically transitioned to a paid Google Workspace subscription where we continue to deliver new capabilities to help businesses transform the way they work."

    Small business owners who have relied on the G Suite legacy free edition aren't thrilled that they will have to pay for Workspace or migrate to a rival like Microsoft, which happens to be actively encouraging defectors. As noted by The New York Times on Monday, the approaching deadline has elicited complaints from small firms that bet on Google's cloud productivity apps in the 2006-2012 period and have enjoyed the lack of billing since then.

    Continue reading
  • D-Wave opens up access to small-scale Advantage2 quantum computer
    Via a cloud subscription, natch – this is the 2020s

    D-Wave Systems has put its next-generation Advantage2 quantum computer into the cloud, or at least some form of it.

    This experimental machine will be accessible from D-Wave's Leap online service, we're told. We first learned of the experimental system last year when the biz revealed its Clarity Roadmap, which includes plans for a gate-model quantum system. Advantage2 sports D-Wave's latest topology and qubit design that apparently increases connectivity and aims to deliver greater performance by reducing noise.

    "By making the Advantage2 prototype available in the Leap quantum cloud service today, the company is providing an early snapshot for exploration and learning by developers and researchers," D-Wave said in a canned statement.

    Continue reading
  • Former US state agency CIO, IT exec plead guilty to bribery and extortion scheme
    Pair's multimillion-dollar contract caper unraveled

    A former Maryland Cabinet-level official and a former IT executive have pleaded guilty to involvement in a bribery and extortion scheme related to technology contracts about a decade ago.

    According to the US Attorney's Office of the State of Maryland, Isabel FitzGerald, 52, of Annapolis, Maryland, and Kenneth Coffland, 67, of Riva, Maryland, pleaded guilty last week to charges of bribery and extortion, respectively. They were indicted in 2017.

    From 2009 through September 2011, Coffland worked [PDF] at ACS, which held a $129 million IT hosting contract and $229 million applications contract with the State of Maryland Department of Human Resources (DHR). ACS, acquired by Xerox in 2010, managed the datacenter that hosted DHR applications for administering welfare benefits under federal and state programs.

    Continue reading
  • Cloudflare says it thwarted record-breaking HTTPS DDoS flood
    26m requests a second? Not legit traffic, not even Bill Gates doing $1m giveaways could manage that

    Cloudflare said it this month staved off another record-breaking HTTPS-based distributed denial-of-service attack, this one significantly larger than the previous largest DDoS attack that occurred only two months ago.

    In April, the biz said it mitigated an HTTPS DDoS attack that reached a peak of 15.3 million requests-per-second (rps). The flood last week hit a peak of 26 million rps, with the target being the website of a company using Cloudflare's free plan, according to Omer Yoachimik, product manager at Cloudflare.

    Like the attack in April, the most recent one not only was unusual because of its size, but also because it involved using junk HTTPS requests to overwhelm a website, preventing it from servicing legit visitors and thus effectively falling off the 'net.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022