IT contractor has £240k bill torn up after IR35 win against UK taxman

HMRC vows to appeal


IT contractor Richard Alcock has won an appeal against HMRC after the UK taxman said he owed more than £200,000 in national insurance contributions (NICs) and income tax under off-payroll rules.

The IR35 legislation states that individuals who work alongside PAYE staff in similar roles should pay the same amount in income tax and national insurance contributions as employees. However, as contractors, they are not entitled to the same holiday and sick pay benefits.

Alcock contracted with Accenture and the Department for Work and Pensions as a consultant via his company, RALC Consulting, between April 2010 and April 2015, working on the Universal Credit IT project.

In March 2017, HMRC determined that Alcock owed income tax and NICs of £164,482 and £78,842 respectively for that period. However, it is unlikely he would have had to pay the entire sum because of offsets for tax already paid.

In its ruling, the tribunal stated that it was "satisfied on balance that the hypothetical contracts between Mr Alcock and his end clients, DWP and Accenture, would be contracts for services (self-employment)".

It concluded: "All HMRC's Determinations, decisions and notices are cancelled. The Appellant is not liable to pay the Income tax and NICs assessed by HMRC. The appeal is allowed in full."

Dave Chaplin, CEO of ContractorCalculator, which helped Alcock in his defence, noted that RALC won the case on the key tests of IR35 status known as Mutuality of Obligation.

That is used to determine the employment status examined by all tax tribunals in IR35 as to whether a contractor is in fact a "disguised employee" and therefore subject to the provisions of IR35.

However, Alcock's contract explicitly stated that he could only charge for work actually completed – unlike employees. For example, in his statement, he noted that he had to cease work three weeks early due to the birth of his first child, which meant he was not paid.

On another occasion, one Universal Credit IT programme was stopped. "This was an extremely political and contentious move and several weeks of debate and options analysis followed," Alcock said in his submission. "While this discussion took place and with no firm decision, I decided to continue to support the programme at RALC's risk and continued to work into January 2013.

"I was hopeful that the decision would be overturned, that Accenture would have their contract extended and that RALC would be rewarded with a new contract. Unfortunately this did not happen and ultimately RALC stopped work and was not paid for around 10 days of my effort. The contract was brought to an end in January 2013."

Image by Ensuper http://www.shutterstock.com/gallery-585532p1.html

HMRC: We 'rigorously tested' IR35 tax-check tool... but have almost nothing to show for it

READ MORE

Commenting on the ruling, Alcock said: "The pressure on me and my family has been immense. I cannot understand why HMRC pursues contractors so much. Their bullying tactics have been extremely stressful, made all the more difficult to bear since the verdict has ruled in my favour. I should never have had to go through this in the first instance."

ContractorCalculator's Chaplin commented: "HMRC should have spotted that IR35 clearly did not apply from the outset. In my view the investigation was not conducted in a balanced manner and HMRC cherry-picked from evidence that they wrote themselves and which had not been corroborated. It demonstrates a clear investigative failure by HMRC.

"What's more striking is the fact that the case was won primarily on mutuality of obligation, which should surely now be the final nail in the coffin for CEST, HMRC's online assessment tool – because this essential employment status test is still missing from their tool."

An HMRC spokesman said the department "is disappointed with the decision of the tribunal and intends to appeal". ®

Similar topics

Narrower topics


Other stories you might like

  • Red Hat Kubernetes security report finds people are the problem
    Puny human brains baffled by K8s complexity, leading to blunder fears

    Kubernetes, despite being widely regarded as an important technology by IT leaders, continues to pose problems for those deploying it. And the problem, apparently, is us.

    The open source container orchestration software, being used or evaluated by 96 per cent of organizations surveyed [PDF] last year by the Cloud Native Computing Foundation, has a reputation for complexity.

    Witness the sarcasm: "Kubernetes is so easy to use that a company devoted solely to troubleshooting issues with it has raised $67 million," quipped Corey Quinn, chief cloud economist at IT consultancy The Duckbill Group, in a Twitter post on Monday referencing investment in a startup called Komodor. And the consequences of the software's complication can be seen in the difficulties reported by those using it.

    Continue reading
  • Infosys skips government meeting – and collecting government taxes
    Tax portal wobbles, again

    Services giant Infosys has had a difficult week, with one of its flagship projects wobbling and India's government continuing to pressure it over labor practices.

    The wobbly projext is India's portal for filing Goods and Services Tax returns. According to India's Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC), the IT services giant reported a "technical glitch" that meant auto-populated forms weren't ready for taxpayers. The company was directed to fix it and CBIC was faced with extending due dates for tax payments.

    Continue reading
  • Google keeps legacy G Suite alive and free for personal use
    Phew!

    Google has quietly dropped its demand that users of its free G Suite legacy edition cough up to continue enjoying custom email domains and cloudy productivity tools.

    This story starts in 2006 with the launch of “Google Apps for Your Domain”, a bundle of services that included email, a calendar, Google Talk, and a website building tool. Beta users were offered the service at no cost, complete with the ability to use a custom domain if users let Google handle their MX record.

    The service evolved over the years and added more services, and in 2020 Google rebranded its online productivity offering as “Workspace”. Beta users got most of the updated offerings at no cost.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022