Sir John Redwood backs IR35 campaign, notes review would have to start 'immediately' before new off-payroll working rules kick in

Do election promises mean anything?

The Right Honourable Sir John Redwood is supporting contractors in their battle to overturn IR35 tax rules before they hit the private sector, demanding the new Tory government meets its pledge to review the legislation.

Redwood, MP for Wokingham for the past 32 years, who has been periodically referred to as a Vulcan due to his similar appearance to Star Trek's Spock, has written to Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer Sajid Javid to press for change.


Tory chancellor pledges to review IR35 rollout in UK private sector – just like all the other parties


The letter, published on Redwood's blog, said that many of his constituents expressed concern about the tax changes both before and during the election campaign.

The Conservative MP said one of his constituents had told him several major companies had already ended IR35 arrangements due to the complexity of the new rules and extra administrative burden it places on employers.

As The Reg reported in recent times – GlaxoSmithKline, along with a bunch of banks including Barclays, RBS, Lloyds and HSBC, are among the businesses taking this cautious route and warning self-employed contractors that from 6 April when IR35 is introduced to the private sector, it will not employ off-payroll workers. According to recruitment agency Harvey Nash, one in five UK businesses is considering following suit.

Redwood wrote:

The freedom, flexibility and autonomy of contract work is an attractive proposition for independent contractors but there is also a downside in terms of no holiday and sick pay as well as company benefits. For this reason, it is important that they are taxed fairly.

There is also the real danger of losing business to overseas outsources at the expense of self-employed people in the UK. I have been told of cases this now happening.

While I welcome the Government’s commitment to hold a review this would need to commence immediately before the new off-payroll working rules come into effect and potentially become a dampener on enterprise and undermine the self-employed. The self-employed are crucial to our prosperity and we should to do all we can to support them.

I would be grateful to know the date of the review and if the proposed changes to IR35 will be suspended pending the outcome.

Liability for defining a contractor's employment status will transfer from the employee to the employer from April, meaning businesses will be financially liable if UK tax collector HMRC decides off-payroll rules are applicable to specific a freelancer.

The legislation, which was introduced to the public sector some years ago with initially devastating impact, state that a contractor who does the same job as a full-time employee must pay similar tax and National Insurance despite not getting access to benefits including holiday or sick pay.

Political parties jumped on the IR35 bandwagon as a potential vote winner prior to last weeks General Election. The Conservatives vowed to review IR35 rules, as did the Liberal Democrats, Labour and the Scottish National Party.

Dave Chaplin, CEO of contracting authority ContractorCalculator and director of Stop The Off-Payroll Tax campaign, said:

"In the run-up to this election we heard a number of political parties pledge to review IR35 and as Boris Johnson re-enters No. 10 I am pleased to see John Redwood reminding the Government of that promise. Having a complex employment status test at the heart of the tax system hasn't worked for 20 years under the intermediaries legislation and hasn't worked under the new rules in the public sector either."

He said Off-Payroll rules have the "potential to poison the entire engagement process between contractor, client and agency", and possibly "force thousands of contractors into false employment, expose self-employed contractors to excessive taxation as well as depriving UK plc. of essential access to talent and key skills and drive up project costs."

According to the Office for National Statistics, the number of contractors in the UK fell for the first time in five years in 2018 amid fears over the impact of the tax reforms.

Redwood's blog is here. ®

Similar topics

Broader topics

Other stories you might like

  • India seizes $725 million of Xiaomi's cash
    Chinese giant really got something in return for those cross-border payments, say money laundering cops

    India's government has seized over $724 million of bank deposits held by Chinese gadget-maker Xiaomi and alleged the company has improperly moved funds offshore.

    The Directorate of Enforcement, an arm of the Department of Revenue charged with investigating money laundering and violations of foreign exchange laws, did the deed. In a statement [PDF], the Directorate justified the seizure of ₹5551.27 Crore with a claim that Xiaomi has sent similar sums abroad under the guise of paying royalties and payments to other members of the Xiaomi group but did not receive any services in return.

    "Xiaomi India has not availed any service from the three foreign-based entities to whom such amounts have been transferred," the statement reads, later adding an allegation that Xiaomi "also provided misleading information to the banks while remitting the money abroad."

    Continue reading
  • No help for IT contractors on IR35 tax errors
    NAO says £263m in IR35 tax mistakes is just the start...

    UK IT contractors have been given no guidance on how to claw back tax erroneously taken by employers under IR35 rules, which already cost central government bodies £263m when they failed to correctly adhere to the guidelines.

    According to a report from public spending watchdog the National Audit Office (NAO), the UK's tax collector has failed to clarify the controversial new rules which govern contractor's tax status, while there is no new legal framework to interpret the rules.

    The IR35 reforms, which put the onus on the employer, rather than the contractor, for determining their employment status, were introduced in the public sector in 2017. Following a year's delay, they were introduced to large and medium-sized private sector businesses in April 2021.

    Continue reading
  • Infosys quits Russia, ending UK political and tax scandal … maybe
    Founder's daughter is married to top UK politician, holds billion dollar stake that was maxed for tax efficiency

    Indian IT services giant Infosys has announced it will quit Russia, after finding itself at the center of a political storm in the UK.

    Infosys is one of few major global tech companies that had not revealed its intentions regarding Russia, but on yesterday's Q4 2022 earnings call CEO Salil Parekh stated the company will pull out. Parekh told investors Infosys has around 100 employees in the nation, all working for global clients. Infosys has no engagements with Russian entities, the CEO added.

    But in recognition of Vladimir Putin's illegal invasion of Ukraine, Parekh said Infosys has decided to move the work performed by staff in Russia to other unspecified locations. The fate of those staff was not discussed. Infosys has also donated $1 million towards Ukrainian relief efforts and is "launching a program to digitally re-skill up to 25,000 individuals."

    Continue reading
  • HMRC: UK techies' IR35 tax appeals could take years
    Challenges to blanket bans on PSCs could face long road to redemption

    IT contractors who have faced blanket bans on employment via their personal services companies (PSCs) could face years trying to challenge the decision, according to officials from the UK's tax collector.

    Speaking to members of parliament, Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs (HMRC) compliance director Nicole Newbury acknowledged that businesses implementing blanket bans on contracting PSCs could be found not to have complied with freelancer tax reforms, dubbed IR35, but challenging decisions could be a lengthy process.

    The new rules, which place the burden of determining the tax status of freelancers on the employer, were brought into the public sector in 2017. They came into force for medium and large businesses in April 2021 following a report from the House of Lords, which said they were "riddled with problems, unfairnesses, unintended consequences."

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022