Crazy idea but hear us out... With robots taking people's jobs, can we rethink this whole working to survive thing?

A nation of takeout deliverers

The adoption of industrial robots in France makes manufacturing businesses more productive and profitable but at the expense of jobs, according to a recent paper presented by the National Bureau of Economic Research, a private, non-profit, non-partisan research organization in America.

In a paper titled "Competing with Robots: Firm-Level Evidence from France," economics professors Daron Acemoglu (MIT), Claire LeLarge (University of Paris Saclay), and Pascual Restrepo (Boston University) analyzed 55,390 French manufacturing firms to study the economic impact of robot adoption.

Within that data set, 598 French companies deployed industrial robots between 2010 and 2015. The researchers found, as they expected, that firms adopting robots shed jobs as they became more profitable and productive. They also created jobs internally, but those gains were more than offset nationally by job losses among competitors who were unable to keep up with the early adopters.

"Overall, even though firms adopting robots expand their employment, the market-level implications of robot adoption are negative," the paper says.

In 2017, Acemoglu and Restrepo conducted a similar analysis in the US and found in that instance robots were depressing wages.

This latest research argues against the notion that automation technology will create more jobs than it will destroy. But the case isn't clear cut.

In a phone interview with The Register, Andrew McAfee, co-founder and co-director of the Initiative on the Digital Economy and a principal research scientist at the MIT Sloan School of Management, said, "One of the points Acemoglu and his co-authors keep making that I violently agree with is that the effect of technology on employment is ambiguous."

It's way too simplistic, McAfee emphasized, to say that automation always or never takes jobs.


Universal basic income is a great idea, which is also why it won't happen


That said, McAfee observed that the tendency during the current economic expansion has been to dismiss the notion that robots might take jobs. What happened in France, he said, shows that robots can have a negative effect on employment.

McAfee explained that robots have had a disproportionate effect on the middle class, which in the US, France, and other wealthy countries was built upon routine labor associated with relatively high productivity. Assembly line workers, he said, contribute a lot in terms of productivity and took some of that value home in the form of higher pay.

Many of those jobs, which often had good benefits thanks to unions, have become automated, McAfee said, and recent gig economy jobs don't provide the same potential for productivity or profit.

"A person on a moped delivering meals generates less revenue," he said. "It doesn't mean the job is less valuable but with lower productivity you expect pay to be lower."

McAfee argues the job quality conversation should focus on politicians rather than robots. Gig economy jobs, he said, may not have the same benefits associated with them as traditional factory jobs used to have, but that's a choice we've made.

Instead of blaming robots or demonizing gig economy jobs, "what I would recommend is re-thinking the social safety net and having it less tightly coupled with the kind of job you're doing," he said. "That's not easy to do politically but it's not impossible or crazy." ®

Other stories you might like

  • Amazon shows off robot warehouse workers that won't complain, quit, unionize...
    Mega-corp insists it's all about 'people and technology working safely and harmoniously together'

    Amazon unveiled its first "fully autonomous mobile robot" and other machines designed to operate alongside human workers at its warehouses.

    In 2012 the e-commerce giant acquired Kiva Systems, a robotics startup, for $775 million. Now, following on from that, Amazon has revealed multiple prototypes powered by AI and computer-vision algorithms, ranging from robotic grippers to moving storage systems, that it has developed over the past decade. The mega-corporation hopes to put them to use in warehouses one day, ostensibly to help staff lift, carry, and scan items more efficiently. 

    Its "autonomous mobile robot" is a disk-shaped device on wheels, and resembles a Roomba. Instead of hoovering crumbs, the machine, named Proteus, carefully slots itself underneath a cart full of packages and pushes it along the factory floor. Amazon said Proteus was designed to work directly with and alongside humans and doesn't have to be constrained to specific locations caged off for safety reasons. 

    Continue reading
  • Tencent Cloud slaps googly eyes on a monitor, says it can care for oldies
    It's called 'i-Care' and it screams 'I don't, actually'

    Tencent Cloud has released an odd robot-adjacent device designed to provide telemedicine services.

    The effort is called i-Care and is the result of a tie up with USA-based IT services Millennium Technology Services (MTS)'s subsidiary Invincible Technology. The two companies set out to create "a digital solution that aims to improve patients' experience and quality of life as well as draw patients, families and caregivers closer than ever."

    "Customers' habits and expectations have evolved dramatically over the last few years across various industries including the medical and healthcare field, driven by the further emergence of digital technologies and cloud computing," said Tencent Cloud in a canned statement.

    Continue reading
  • Tata Consultancy Services to create touchy feely 'Internet of Actions'
    Gets a grip on tech from Japanese startup to make it work

    The Japanese outpost of Indian services giant Tata Consultancy Services has revealed it is working on the "Internet of Actions" – an effort to bring the sense of touch to the internet.

    Tata has paired with a Japanese upstart from Keio University, Motion Lib, to spearhead the endeavor.

    TCS said it will eventually deliver a "new social infrastructure" by commercializing Motion Lib tech. But first and more practically, the company will create a demonstration environment for "real haptics" technology at its Digital Continuity Experience Center (DCEC) showroom.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022