NEC insists its face-recog training dataset isn't biased, but refuses to share details of Neoface system with UK court

Magical Black Box of Suspects to Arrest is updated annually, says firm


Facial-recognition technology used by British police forces does not rely on trawling the internet for random face photos to use as training data, an NEC manager told the courts.

The statement was referred to in the Court of Appeal last week by South Wales Police's barrister Jason Beer QC and obtained by The Register yesterday.

"Our biometric templates are unique to NEC and are not portable between vendors," said Paul Roberts, head of global facial recognition at NEC Global subsidiary Northgate Public Services.

NEC also refused to tell even the British courts where it obtained its facial-recognition training dataset or to give details about its makeup.

Roberts' witness statement was deployed by South Wales Police (SWP) as part of its defence against a legal challenge brought by human rights pressure group Liberty, as reported at length last week.

Responding to two written statements made by an American expert witness on Liberty's behalf, Roberts denied that Neoface Watch (rebranded by police workers as "AFR Locate") incorporates machine-learning technology for continual evolution during and after deployments.

Instead, he said: "We train our Neoface algorithm in our laboratories and, on a typically annual basis, release a new version of the algorithm containing improvements ranging from, among other things, additional training."

Liberty's expert, Dr Anil Jain, had made the opposite claim. An academic and consultant for NEC, he had told the court: "Typically, all state-of-the-art [automated facial recognition] systems, such as AFR Locate, employ a deep learning network... When given a large number of face images of different individuals under various PIE and occlusion conditions, the network automatically learns patterns in the Features that best represent the person..."

You know nothing, go away

The two engaged in a revealing proxy war of words that helped push some further details of the latest police gadget into the public domain.

NEC's man told the court that Liberty's expert only had direct knowledge of "an older version of the Neoface algorithm SDK" that was used "for internal testing". He added: "In any event the facial recognition product utilised in the United States and in which Dr Jain is involved on a consultancy basis, is not [Neoface Watch]."

Roberts was saying that Jain could only give the court generalised descriptions of how different AFR software deployed in a foreign country worked. If this is accurate, a significant part of Liberty's evidence against the creepy cameras may have lost its force.

Nonetheless, Jain was not to be cowed. In a follow-up to Roberts he told the court: "I cannot comment on whether AFR Locate has a discriminatory impact as I do not have access to the datasets on which the system is trained and therefore cannot analyse the biases in those datasets. For the same reason, the Defendant [South Wales Police] is not in a position to evaluate the discriminatory impact of AFR Locate."

We're telling you nothing, now go away

Roberts also refused to explain to the court what the makeup of NEC's training datasets was, claiming these were "commercially sensitive". Jain built on this, saying that SWP's solicitors had told him "that NEC/Northgate are not prepared to disclose summary statistics (in terms of gender, race/ethnicity, age) or any empirical evaluation of the Neoface Algorithm training dataset". The force is said to have asked NEC to answer questions about where it got the training dataset from, which, as Jain pointed out, suggested the force didn't know the answer itself, making it "difficult for SWP to confirm whether the technology is in fact biased".

In terms of function, Jain asserted that SWP was using a Bosch Mic Starlight 7000 HD camera to feed Neoface Watch, running at 1080x1920p, something likely to be echoed by Metropolitan Police, which is the deploying Neoface Watch in London from not-quite-unmarked vans. Back in January an NEC spokesman with the Met told the nation's press that the technology had a 70 per cent accuracy rate – an interesting contrast between the police's courtroom claims of 78 per cent accuracy in Cardiff and police-sponsored tests establishing a 98 per cent inaccuracy rate when used against innocent Londoners. That test was carried out later in the same year as the Cardiff deployment.

Although intended to be a landmark case that sets the law on the technology's use against the general public, the Court of Appeal judges hearing last week's case seemed pointedly uninterested in wider legal and societal issues raised by the Cardiff AFR deployment. The Met's assistant commissioner, Nick Ephgrave, previously praised judges for their "very helpful" rulings in favour of police earlier in this case.

Judgment from the Court of Appeal is expected later this year. ®


Other stories you might like

  • NASA installs a new and improved algorithm to better track near-Earth asteroids

    Nearly 20 year-old software used to protect humanity gets an upgrade

    NASA has upgraded its near-Earth asteroid monitoring algorithm to model hazardous space rocks more accurately after nearly two decades, it announced on Tuesday.

    The new system, dubbed Sentry-II, is more powerful than its predecessor, Sentry. Astronomers working at the space agency's Center for Near Earth Object Studies can now automatically calculate thermal influences that nudge an asteroid’s orbit, potentially sending it hurtling towards our home planet.

    The so-called Yarkovsky effect describes the subtle and gradual change of motion when asteroids are heated by the Sun’s light. When asteroids spin, one side of its surface exposed to the star gets heated. As it continues to rotate, the hot region enters shade and cools down. Infrared energy is radiated outwards; the photons carry momentum and impart a tiny thrust on the asteroid. Over long periods of time, these small kicks can change their paths and knock them out of their original orbit.

    Continue reading
  • Facebook slapped with an eyepopping $150B lawsuit for spreading hate speech against Rohingya refugees

    Lawsuit claims social media giant's algos helped Myanmar military crackdown on the Rohingya

    Meta was sued on Tuesday for a whopping $150 billion in a class-action lawsuit for allegedly amplifying hate speech and aiding the Myanmar military in the genocide of the Rohingya people.

    The case, led by an anonymous Rohingya refugee living in the US, accuses the entity formerly known as Facebook of inciting hatred and inflicting real harm on the predominantly Muslim group for years. Not only did the social media platform ignore hate speech posts, it's alleged that the service's algorithms actively promoted anti-Rohingya propaganda as hundreds of thousands of people fled from Myanmar to escape persecution.

    Facebook has already acknowledged its role in the campaign, which saw an estimated 25,000 people perish and 700,000 forced from the country. The lawsuit also comes after ex-employee and whistleblower Frances Haugen leaked internal documents demonstrating how its algorithms prioritized engagement over safety.

    Continue reading
  • Power management IC shortage holding cars, laptops, hostage

    Couple of cents-worth of kit causing big problems for the year to come

    The shortage of power management chips is worsening and holding back companies from building cars, PCs and items with batteries or an on-off switch, Trendforce said in a study this week.

    Power management ICs cost just a few cents, and are among cheap chips that include display driver and USB-C components that are in short supply. These chips are as important to PCs and other electronics as CPUs or memory.

    The demand for PMICs has gone through the roof with the emergence of electric cars and growing demand for PCs and consumer electronics during the past 20 plus months. Trendforce expects the prices will go up by 10 per cent to a six-year high of $0.23.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021