Pot, meet kettle: Google claims Australia's pay-for-news plan could see personal data put to nefarious uses

YouTubers advised of opportunity to ‘get involved’ in some kind of push-back

19 Reg comments Got Tips?

Google's Australian tentacle has published a pair of protestations that repudiate Australia's "News Media Bargaining Code" plan to have the advertising giant pay local news outlets for linking to their content.

One is an open letter to Australians by Google Australia managing director Mel Silva, and offers the following argument: "A proposed law, the News Media Bargaining Code, would force us to provide you with a dramatically worse Google Search and YouTube, could lead to your data being handed over to big news businesses, and would put the free services you use at risk in Australia."

It's not clear why Google believes the code "could lead to your data being handed over to big news businesses", given that an FAQ for the draft code says the following:

The code does not include any requirements for digital platforms to increase sharing of user data with news media businesses. Accordingly, the code does not have an impact on the privacy protections currently applicable to digital platform users.

Silva's letter is closer to the mark with its observation that "news media businesses alone would be given information that would help them artificially inflate their ranking over everyone else, even when someone else provides a better result" as the code was created explicitly to see funds flow from Google and Facebook to organisations that run newsrooms.

"We deeply believe in the importance of news to society," Silva continued. "We partner closely with Australian news media businesses – we already pay them millions of dollars and send them billions of free clicks every year. We've offered to pay more to license content."

But Silva said the code will lower the quality of Google's services and pledged the company will therefore "do everything we possibly can to get this proposal changed so we can protect how Search and YouTube work for you in Australia and continue to build constructive partnerships with news media businesses – not choose one over the other."

thumbs down facebook

Facebook caves to Australia's call for explanations of News Feed algo changes


A second post by APAC head of YouTube Gautam Anand argued that the code will make it harder for creators that use YouTube to turn a quid.

"The imbalances created by this proposed law could potentially affect all types of Australian creators, far beyond those who focus on news: from vloggers, to educational creators, to music artists and beyond," he said.

He signed off by telling YouTubers: "In the coming days, you'll hear more from us about how you can get involved."

Which sounds like Google Australia may try to foment some grass-roots activism.

The company appears to be already using its platform to ensure Australians get a chance to learn of its opposition to the code, with locals sharing search results featuring pop-ups linked to the posts above. ®


A quick reminder that The Register is not eligible to receive payment for our news under Australia's plan and is reporting this matter because it is potentially a global precedent for how publishers and web giants interact and therefore of likely interest to readers as you contemplate your future experience of the web.


Keep Reading

Google Australia says government pulled pin on content-for-cash talks, hands in its homework anyway

And fires back with 'we do for free what meatspace distributors charge for' argument

Australia to force Google and Facebook to pay for news and reveal algorithm changes before they whack web traffic

And is willing to fine them hundreds of millions if they don't play nice

Australia starts second fight with Google, this time over whether app stores leak data, gouge devs, steal ideas and warp markets

Apple also in sights of inquiry that could spark more new laws

Australia sues Google over data collection practices that merged DoubleClick data to create single user profiles

Alleges opt-in that promised “more control” actually sent more data without informed consent. Google 'strongly disagrees'

Facebook rejects Australia's pay-for-news plan, proposes its own idea: How about no more articles at all, sunshine?

+Comment The toys are maintaining a constant horizontal velocity from the pram

Australia to make Google and Facebook disclose ranking algorithms and pay for local content

Months of negotiation on voluntary code of conduct didn’t make progress

Facebook caves to Australia's call for explanations of News Feed algo changes

But The Social Network™ won't pay for news and tells publishers it can get along just fine without them

Australia's contact-tracing app still basically borked on iOS, says new bug report – and GAPPLE API version tested

On the upside, it's been used to trace contacts about 30 times and downloaded six million times

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020