Motorola stung for £838k after Chinese digital mobile radio biz Hytera wins appeal against UK asset-freezing order

Appeal judges say lower court stumbled with ruling over 'without prejudice' negotiations

Motorola must pay a Chinese mobile network radio maker more than £800,000 after losing a Court of Appeal case over claims its rival threatened to "retreat to China" and evade a previous judgment.

The complex case was summarised in a Court of Appeal ruling where senior judges reversed a High Court asset-freezing order against Hytera Communications Corporation Ltd, a digital mobile radio (DMR) biz.

Motorola previously sued Hytera in the US. Back in 2008, the Chinese company allegedly lured three of Motorola's engineers into its own ranks, taking "confidential documents and source code" with them. A US jury duly awarded Motorola $763m in compensatory and punitive damages in February 2020.

Worried that the Chinese company would evade the US verdict by moving its assets outside US jurisdiction, Motorola filed in London for a freezing injunction against Hytera and two of its UK subsidiaries, Project Shortway Ltd and Sepura Ltd in April last year.

"In summary," noted the Court of Appeal, Motorola's legal arguments were "that Hytera would take various steps to limit Motorola's ability to enforce a judgment in western jurisdictions such as the United States or the United Kingdom, by concentrating its assets in China and other jurisdictions where enforcement would be more difficult. This was said to have been described by Hytera as a 'retreat to China'."

During the High Court case, Motorola relied on that "retreat to China" statement to get Hytera's UK assets frozen, although it was made in so-called "without prejudice" negotiations between the two sides.

Statements and offers made under "without prejudice" cover are not admissible in court proceedings unless they contain an "unambiguous impropriety". An "unambiguous impropriety" is a statement by one side showing that it intends to break the law – in this case by fleeing the jurisdiction.

Judge Mr Justice Jacobs admitted the "retreat to China" statement and ruled that Hytera's assets should be frozen. Unfortunately for Motorola, the Court of Appeal ruled yesterday that the High Court judge had made a legal mistake in doing so.

Lord Justice Males sighed that it is "common for potential problems of enforcement to be a factor to which both parties will be alive in international litigation and it would be unfortunate if that was a subject which could not be discussed in settlement meetings for fear of being interpreted as a threat to move assets improperly."

Mr Justice Jacobs, said the Court of Appeal judge, had applied the wrong legal test. After the US jury verdict against Hytera, it and Motorola began negotiating about enforcement of the judgment. During those negotiations, Hytera's (now former) CFO Nuo Xu said Hytera would "retreat to China". Although Motorola took this as a threat to hide assets and evade the US judgment, the Court of Appeal took it rather differently, explaining that what the Chinese exec meant was "if there was enforcement of any judgment over Hytera's western assets, then the commercial reality would force Hytera to exit from the western markets".

Xu responded by claiming Hytera only had "about $40m in cash outside of China" as of 30 September 2019, telling Motorola its "more profitable markets were in China, Russia and Africa".

Describing both sides' evidence about the "retreat to China" as "equally plausible", Lord Justice Males ruled that the High Court had got the law on "unambiguous improprieties" wrong, wrongly admitted the "retreat to China" statement into evidence, and then made the wrong decision based upon that evidence.

The court therefore ordered Motorola to reimburse Hytera's legal and other costs from the High Court case, totalling £838,367.27.

Hytera was previously included on a US military "do not buy" list of vendors in 2018. ®

Similar topics

Other stories you might like

  • Lenovo to slap ThinkShield security standard for laptop line-up on its Motorola mobiles
    Scheme to roll out across firm's device portfolio in coming months

    Motorola will push ThinkShield onto the business end of its smartphone portfolio, as an extension of the security and management programme on Lenovo's laptop and desktop line.

    ThinkShield for mobile devices consists of four components, with the first being a "clean OS". In practice, this means Motorola will avoid loading up devices with unnecessary non-stock software, from additional bloatware to UI overlays. This element feels somewhat redundant given that Motorola has historically shipped devices with a near-untouched Android experience, in stark contrast to rival vendors like Samsung and Huawei.

    The second pillar is the vague "secure by design." Here, Moto promises to build upon Android's existing security features with additional hardware and software-level components. These include a "fuse" that breaks when the phone's bootloader is unlocked, signifying the phone has been tampered with, as well as unspecified AI-powered protections against malware and phishing.

    Continue reading
  • How embarrassing: Xiaomi and Motorola show up to high school prom both wearing remote-charging tech
    Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether they could, they didn't stop to think if they should

    Motorola and Lenovo are experimenting with wireless charging tech that works remotely, casting power to phones and wearables from across the room.

    Xiaomi's tech – called Mi Air Charge – purportedly offers charging speeds of 5W, and works within a radius of "several meters", which is as vague a metric as any. It consists of two parts: a base station that looks a bit like a shrunken air conditioning unit, and a receiver embedded within a smartphone.

    The base station tracks the device with five phase-interference antennas, which energy is shot out via a phase-control array, which consists of 144 antennas. On the mobile front, you've got a beacon antenna which helps the base station pinpoint the device, as well as a receiving array, which consists of 14 antennas that convert the millimetre wave signal into electrical energy through a rectifier circuit.

    Continue reading
  • Motorola Moto G 5G Plus: It won't blow your mind, but at £300 we're struggling to find much to grumble about
    Conservative, competent entry-level blower for the next-gen networks

    Review The Motorola Moto G 5G Plus sits among the inaugural sub-£300 5G handsets. While the Lenovo-owned phonemaker is happy to tread that unfamiliar ground, the handset doggedly sticks to the tried-and-tested Motorola playbook, with decent performance and photography alongside a pristine stock Android experience.

    Motorola seeded The Register with the entry-level model. Under the hood, you'll find Qualcomm's mid-range Snapdragon 765 octa-core silicon, which uses a 7nm process and includes the Adreno 620 GPU. The cheapest variant of the Moto G 5G Plus comes with 4GB RAM and 64GB of UFS 2.1 storage. Pay a bit extra, and you can double your storage and increase the RAM to 6GB.

    Performance was reasonably fluid, with media-rich sites opening swiftly. And though it may not be most relevant for the grizzled IT veterans that comprise our readership, the Moto G 5G Plus proved capable of keeping pace with several taxing games, including Call of Duty: Mobile.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022