This article is more than 1 year old

Malware attack that crippled Mumbai's power system came from China, claims infosec intel outfit Recorded Future

The fun started at the same time as border skirmishes

Updated Security intelligence firm Recorded Future's Insikt Group has written a paper alleging China was behind attacks on India's electricity grid.

In a blog post and white paper (which requires registration to access), the firm said it had seen a notable increase in targeted attacks on India from China state-sponsored groups.

The cybersecurity firm has named the offenders "RedEcho."

The incident it referred to took place last year, during the India/China border standoff in May. Malware was injected into 10 Indian power sector organisations and a pair of Indian seaport operators. The attack is considered the probable source of Mumbai's power outage in October of the same year.

"Using a combination of proactive adversary infrastructure detections, domain analysis, and Recorded Future Network Traffic Analysis, we have determined that a subset of these AXIOMATICASYMPTOTE servers share some common infrastructure tactics, techniques, and procedures (TTPs) with several previously reported Chinese state-sponsored groups, including APT41 and Tonto Team," the Recorded Future report said. "AXIOMATICASYMPTOTE" is the name given to the malware infrastructure.

The firm said most of the malware was not activated and the associated power outage was the result of a subset of the payload. Recorded Future did not have access to India's power system code to analyse in further detail. The cybersecurity company said it had contacted Indian authorities, which to date have largely kept quiet on the issue.

Tech-related tensions between the two nations saw India ban over 100 Chinese apps while also creating new investment funds that explicitly aim to lure major electronics manufacturers from the Middle Kingdom to India.

Recorded Future hypothesised that last year's power outages in Mumbai, which caused mass chaos in the city's infrastructure – ranging from trains to hospitals to financial centre operations – were a "show of force" designed to warn India of China's capabilities.

"While diplomacy and economic factors have been effective in preventing a full-blown war, notable most recently with the bilateral disengagement at the border, cyber operations continue to provide countries with a potent asymmetric capability to conduct espionage or pre-position within networks for potentially disruptive reasons," the report said. ®

Updated to add

After this story was published, India's government denied the outage was caused by a malware infection: the supply breakdown was blamed on "human error."

Union power minister RK Singh did, however, concede that a software nasty got into India's northern and southern region load dispatch centers, though the impact was limited, we're told.

More about


Send us news

Other stories you might like