Ex-asylum seeker with infosec degree loses discrimination claim against UK cyber range provider after storming out

'It had nothing whatsoever to do with the claimant's country of birth', rules Employment Tribunal


A former asylum seeker with a postgraduate degree in cybersecurity who alleged his bosses were spying on him for MI5 has lost his attempt to claim he was racially discriminated against.

The anonymous man, who worked for an unnamed company that set up a UK cyber range in mid-2019, told the Employment Tribunal that he had quit after being subjected to racial harassment at work – but judges overruled all of his legal claims.

Although he gained a "postgraduate degree in computer security systems", his three months working for the 1,000-strong "technology services" business ended with petty squabbles over the use of a laptop instead of a workstation – and serious accusations of racial discrimination.

Described by his former colleagues as "extremely technically competent", the man entered the UK in 2004 unable to speak English and with no computer skills either, though he considerably bettered himself over the next 15 years. Yet when he joined the company, the man's working relationship with his bosses soon broke down to the point where he stormed off home after getting into a shouting match with a manager.

The man, who was not named by the Employment Tribunal, alleged that two of his managers had told him they were "employed by MI5 and MI6", were "watching him closely" and that he should be "very careful what he was doing".

Employment Judge Laura Howden-Evans, sitting on on a three-person panel, ruled: "Neither man had ever worked for MI5 or MI6. We do not accept that this remark was made to the Claimant."

Conceived as a new line of business, the cyber range was set up in March 2019 by the company's European cybersecurity personnel. Local talent was hired to run it during April with its first customer demo scheduled for mid-June. Its format was described in some detail by the tribunal:

The Cyber Range was set up in a separate room. It comprised of a large video wall of 9 individual screens and 6 computers each with its own workstation. 3 of these computers/workstations (the "blue machines") were facing the video wall; 2 of these computers/workstations (the "red machines") were not facing the video wall and there was a separate administration computer/workstation (the "purple machine") located in the room.

Deployment of the range infrastructure was shaky, with workstations encountering faults after apparently being deployed with incompatible software builds. These needed updates before they could be used for their intended purpose.

"Managers did not realise that there were still problems with some of the range's computers," said the tribunal, adding: "As the Claimant hit a problem with a computer, he would revert to working on the range laptop."

This annoyed his managers, who expected their personnel to use the dedicated range hardware for demonstrating the £500,000 project. It came to a head with a shouting match, with the man storming off home after telling Mr A "No, you leave the room!" Shortly afterwards he resigned, before filing an employment tribunal claim alleging a dozen different forms of mistreatment by his bosses, including that he would have to give up his annual leave to attend CISSP training. Not one of his claims were upheld.

The tribunal ruled that the company, which was also anonymised in its judgment, had not racially discriminated against the man, nor harassed him because of his race – and neither had it constructively dismissed him.

"We are satisfied that Mr A would have taken exactly the same approach with an employee that did not share the Claimant's race – the reason Mr A was asking the Claimant to do this was because the Respondent had demonstrations coming up; it had nothing whatsoever to do with the Claimant's country of birth," concluded the tribunal. ®

Similar topics

Broader topics


Other stories you might like

  • Lenovo halves its ThinkPad workstation range
    Two becomes one as ThinkPad P16 stands alone and HX replaces mobile Xeon

    Lenovo has halved its range of portable workstations.

    The Chinese PC giant this week announced the ThinkPad P16. The loved-by-some ThinkPad P15 and P17 are to be retired, The Register has confirmed.

    The P16 machine runs Intel 12th Gen HX CPUs, but only up to the i7 models – so maxes out at 14 cores and 4.8GHz clock speed. The laptop is certified to run Red Hat Enterprise Linux, and can ship with that, Ubuntu, and Windows 11 or 10. The latter is pre-installed as a downgrade right under Windows 11.

    Continue reading
  • US won’t prosecute ‘good faith’ security researchers under CFAA
    Well, that clears things up? Maybe not.

    The US Justice Department has directed prosecutors not to charge "good-faith security researchers" with violating the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) if their reasons for hacking are ethical — things like bug hunting, responsible vulnerability disclosure, or above-board penetration testing.

    Good-faith, according to the policy [PDF], means using a computer "solely for purposes of good-faith testing, investigation, and/or correction of a security flaw or vulnerability."

    Additionally, this activity must be "carried out in a manner designed to avoid any harm to individuals or the public, and where the information derived from the activity is used primarily to promote the security or safety of the class of devices, machines, or online services to which the accessed computer belongs, or those who use such devices, machines, or online services."

    Continue reading
  • Intel plans immersion lab to chill its power-hungry chips
    AI chips are sucking down 600W+ and the solution could be to drown them.

    Intel this week unveiled a $700 million sustainability initiative to try innovative liquid and immersion cooling technologies to the datacenter.

    The project will see Intel construct a 200,000-square-foot "mega lab" approximately 20 miles west of Portland at its Hillsboro campus, where the chipmaker will qualify, test, and demo its expansive — and power hungry — datacenter portfolio using a variety of cooling tech.

    Alongside the lab, the x86 giant unveiled an open reference design for immersion cooling systems for its chips that is being developed by Intel Taiwan. The chip giant is hoping to bring other Taiwanese manufacturers into the fold and it'll then be rolled out globally.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022