Following Supreme Court ruling, Uber UK recognizes drivers as workers, offers min wage, holiday pay, pension

Nice but still not good enough, says union

After years of aggressively fighting any efforts to force it to recognize its drivers as employees, on Tuesday Uber performed a U-turn on the streets of Britain and recognized all of its drivers as working for the company rather than serving as freelancers.

The change is the result of a court ruling last month that entitled workers to seek more pay and benefits but resisted classifying them as employees. That decision by the UK’s Supreme Court, making it definitive, was unanimous, and actively rejected Uber’s argument that it was just a technology platform that connected suppliers with customers. The court was having none of that, and decided that since Uber set the prices, connected drivers and passengers, and decided which route the drivers should follow, it was more employer than platform.

The ride-hailing app maker initially downplayed the legal loss, and argued the decision only directly benefited the handful of drivers in that specific case. However, experts pointed out that every other Uber driver in the UK could cite the ruling at a tribunal to demand what was owed to them, and reality has since dawned on Uber.

As such, Uber has complied with the court's wishes, and said that its 70,000 UK drivers will henceforth be “workers” entitled to a minimum wage – £8.72 ($12.11) an hour – plus vacation pay, and a pension plan. The details are laid out in this filing [PDF] to America's financial watchdog.

The app biz has thus acknowledged that the people who make its British business a business at all are not just casual workers but people for whom driving for the company is their main job and source of income. That's more a point of a principle than anything else since we imagine most of Uber UK's drivers are earning more than minimum wage anyway.

It’s not clear whether this change will be expanded to Uber drivers in other countries, in large part because the UK is unusual in that it has a category of worker that is neither employee nor freelance; something that most countries don’t. Broadly, in the UK, a “worker” gets several key employee benefits, such as the minimum wage, but is not entitled to things like maternity/paternity leave or severance pay.


In the US, where Uber is headquartered and represents its largest market, the battle over drivers' status is ongoing: California’s legislature passed a law (AB5) that came into effect in January last year that forced gig-economy companies like Uber to recognize their drivers as employees, but that measure was then overridden in November by a ballot measure (developed and supported by Uber) in which California voters exempted app-based drivers from AB5 and allowed Uber et al to continue to treat their drivers as independent contractors rather than employees.

Meanwhile, in Europe, which is Uber's second-largest market, lawmakers are considering new labor laws to cover the same gig-economy companies that would force them to give their workers greater rights.


UK Supreme Court declares Uber drivers are workers, not self-employed: Ride biz's legal battle ends in a crash


The corporation has good reason to be worried. Just like food-delivery app companies, its entire existence depends on acting as a man-in-the-middle when the internet has proven incredibly effective at removing middlemen across all industries. To make it work without forcing a massive surcharge on customers, Uber is dependent on keeping labor costs as low as possible.

To that end, keeping drivers as independent contractors and so opting-out of employee protections saves the company a huge amount of money. It’s not clear how Uber’s business model could shift to accommodate larger costs without it losing a massive amount of market share to traditional taxi companies.

And then there’s the fact that despite its massive reach and huge market valuation, Uber has never made a profit – not even close. Last year in fact it made a $6.8bn loss – that’s bn for billion.

Bloody cabbies

You’d think the drivers would be elated, but you know cab drivers… “While we welcome Uber’s decision to finally commit to paying minimum wage, holiday pay and pensions,” reads a statement by the App Drivers and Couriers Union, “we observe that they have arrived to the table with this offer a day late and a dollar short, literally.”

The missive – written by James Farrar and Yaseen Aslam, the lead claimants in the case that sparked all of this – argued that Uber, when calculating drivers' benefits, ignores the time in between fares, and it should instead take into account whole shifts:

The Supreme Court ruled that drivers are to be recognized as workers with entitlements to the minimum wage and holiday pay to accrue on working time from log on to log off whereas Uber is committing only to these entitlements to accrue from time of trip acceptance to drop off. This means that Uber drivers will be still short-changed to the tune of 40-50 per cent.

It went on: "Also, it is not acceptable for Uber to unilaterally decide the driver expense base in calculating minimum wage. This must be subject to collective agreement. While Uber undoubtedly has made progress here, we cannot accept anything less than full compliance with legal minimums.

"We would also expect to see Uber make progress towards trade union recognition, a fair dismissals appeals process and a data access agreement.”

Yeah, great, oh look: we’re at our destination; time to hop out. ®

Broader topics

Other stories you might like

  • Enemies Waymo, Uber now friends making self-driving-ish trucks for US highways
    When you think about it, it makes cents

    Waymo and Uber announced on Tuesday a "long-term strategic partnership" promising to work together to deploy autonomous freight trucks on US roads, years after both companies fought bitterly over self-driving technology. 

    The collaboration will see Waymo retrofitting trucks with its AI-powered driving software operating on Uber's logistics and network infrastructure. Shippers can tap into the Uber Freight service to connect with truckers willing to deliver their goods across the country. Vehicles running the Waymo Driver software will be able to complete part of the journey autonomously, although human drivers will still need to be present.

    "With trucking, we plan to first tackle highway driving," a spokesperson from Waymo told The Register. "It's a natural environment to start this deployment due to the large number of highway miles, which are often the most tiring stretches for humans to drive, and which are a large opportunity to improve efficiency in the industry."

    Continue reading
  • Cookie consent crumbles under fresh UK data law proposals
    Campaigners fear erosion of rights as narrowing of law proposed as well as political control over independent watchdog

    The UK government has published its plans for reforming local data protection law which includes removing the requirement for consent for all website cookies – akin to the situation across much of the US.

    Also notable is the removal of the requirement for a Data Protection Impact Assessment, as well as a new political direction over the Information Commissioner's Office.

    However, Nadine Dorries, the minister for the Department of Digital, Media, Culture and Sport, rejected controversial proposals to remove the right to challenge automated decision-making. Privacy campaigners had said the proposals were "irresponsible" and would make it harder for people to "challenge the government or corporations."

    Continue reading
  • UK government still trying to get Arm to IPO in London
    Would give its right, er, leg, to keep HQ – and jobs – in Britain

    The UK government is continuing efforts to have chip designer and licensor Arm listed on the London Stock Exchange after its public offering rather than New York, as is the current plan.

    At stake is whether Arm moves its headquarters to the US, potentially leading to the further loss of UK jobs.

    Speaking to the Financial Times, UK minister for Technology and the Digital Economy Chris Philp said the government was still "working closely with" Arm management on the IPO process, despite its parent SoftBank having previously indicated that it was planning to list Arm on the Nasdaq stock exchange in New York.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022