India's IT minister angry that Twitter broke local law by following US law

Brief account shutdown due to DMCA request interpreted as sign of avian network’s lawless intentions

The Indian government’s dispute with Twitter took a new turn over the weekend with Information Technology minister Ravi Shankar Prasad accusing the micro-blogging service of breaking Indian law by following US law.

Shankar, whose portfolio includes Law & Justice, Communications, Electronics & IT, made the argument that Twitter was again flouting Indian law after his account was briefly locked when the avian network acted on a complaint about copyrighted material appearing in the minister’s feed.

Shankar pointed out that India’s new Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code requires operators like Twitter to advise users before their accounts are shut down. The minister also claimed he has never received a complaint about his inclusion of TV news clips in his feed and interpreted Twitter’s actions as follows:

Shankar offered no evidence for his assertions about Twitter’s motives and did not note that the micro-blogging service is headquartered in the USA and therefore bound to observe American law as well as the laws of other nations in which it operates.

The minister’s account was restored in under an hour, and there is no indication that Twitter responded to Prasad’s ire.

India’s government and Twitter have been beefing over the Code, which among other things requires social networks to appoint local officers who handle content takedown requests and act as a point of contact for other grievances.

Twitter missed the deadline to name those officers, then named its US office and a local law firm as its appointed contacts rather than naming local employees into the roles.

India’s government considered that response to be disingenuous and cranked up the pressure on Twitter to comply, but Twitter has declined to do so. The service currently faces legal action brought by Indian States and private individuals over its recent decision to either allow circulation of some material or block it. Defending those actions may be hard, as Twitter’s non-compliance with the Code means it may have lost a legal shield that absolves it from liability for illegal content posted by its users. Minister Prasad has alluded to Twitter losing that protection, but the paperwork making it official is yet to emerge.

Now it appears that Twitter is headed for more trouble as Indian media report that Twitter’s temporary grievance officer has quit the role.

If correct, that leaves Twitter on the wrong side of both the spirit and letter of the Code. And probably ripe for further ministerial kicking. ®

Similar topics

Broader topics

Other stories you might like

  • We can unify HPC and AI software environments, just not at the source code level

    Compute graphs are the way forward

    Register Debate Welcome to the latest Register Debate in which writers discuss technology topics, and you the reader choose the winning argument. The format is simple: we propose a motion, the arguments for the motion will run this Monday and Wednesday, and the arguments against on Tuesday and Thursday. During the week you can cast your vote on which side you support using the poll embedded below, choosing whether you're in favour or against the motion. The final score will be announced on Friday, revealing whether the for or against argument was most popular.

    This week's motion is: A unified, agnostic software environment can be achieved. We debate the question: can the industry ever have a truly open, unified, agnostic software environment in HPC and AI that can span multiple kinds of compute engines?

    Arguing today FOR the motion is Rob Farber, a global technology consultant and author with an extensive background in HPC and in developing machine-learning technology that he applies at national laboratories and commercial organizations. Rob can be reached at

    Continue reading
  • But why that VPN? How WireGuard made it into Linux

    Even the best of ideas can take their own sweet time making it into the kernel

    Maybe someday – maybe – Zero Trust will solve many of our network security problems. But for now, if you want to make sure you don't have an eavesdropper on your network, you need a Virtual Private Network (VPN).

    There's only one little problem with commercial VPNs: many of them are untrustworthy. So, what can you do? Well, run your own of course is the open-source answer. And, today, your VPN of choice is Linux's built-in VPN: WireGuard.

    Why WireGuard rather than OpenVPN or IKEv2? Because it's simpler to implement while maintaining security and delivering faster speeds. And, when it comes to VPNs, it's all about balancing speed and security.

    Continue reading
  • Boffins demonstrate a different kind of floppy disk: A legless robot that hops along a surface

    This is fine

    Those of us who fear future enslavement by robot overlords may have one more reason not to sleep at night: engineers have demonstrated a few of the legless, floppy variety making some serious leaps.

    Animated pancake-like droids have demonstrated their ability to execute a series of flops in a fashion their creators – soft robotics engineers based in China – describe as "rapid, continuous, and steered jumping."

    "Jumping is an important locomotion function to extend navigation range, overcome obstacles, and adapt to unstructured environments," Rui Chen of Chongqing University and Huayan Pu of Shanghai University said.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021