Cisco to face trial over trade secrets theft, NDA breach claims after losing attempt to swat Leadfactors lawsuit

Startup alleges IP wound up in Switchzilla's Quad product


Cisco will face trial in a long-running case over claims that it stole trade secrets from an enterprise collaboration startup, a US judge has ruled.

As per the October 18 order by Judge Sunil Kulkarni at the Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara, Switchzilla lost its attempt to have the lawsuit dismissed, meaning the case will – barring some unforseen circumstances, proceed to trial.

Leadfactors LLC sued Cisco claiming Cisco's collaboration Quad platform was built using trade secrets that Leadfactors owned. It bought the intellectual property from a bank after company founder Puneet Gupta's previous venture, ConnectBeam, failed – allegedly because of Cisco's actions.

Cisco had allegedly signed an NDA with ConnectBeam in "late 2007 or early 2008," having contacted the startup to "learn more about its products." The product was described by the court papers as an "integrated social software platform" that combined "social bookmarking, tagging, social networking, expertise location and live profiles, along with social search."

After obtaining a proof-of-concept build from ConnectBeam, Cisco stopped talking to the startup in 2009, according to particulars of claim summarised by Judge Kulkarni in his judgment [PDF]. Deprived of its biggest customer, ConnectBeam promptly collapsed.

"Leadfactors alleges on information and belief that this was because Cisco built its own competing product using ConnectBeam's trade secrets, confidential information, and/or derivative technology," said the judgment.

Gupta used another firm he owned called Leadfactors to buy back ConnectBeam's IP from the failed business's bank. The bank had effectively mortgaged them to ConnectBeam, retaining ownership when that firm defaulted on its loans.

In June 2010, Gupta attended a Cisco conference and watched a demonstration of its Quad collaboration tool, noticing that it "had several features that embodied or were derived from ConnectBeam's trade secrets and confidential information." He sued in 2013, alleging misappropriation of trade secrets and breach of NDA.

Judge Kulkarni threw out Cisco's attempt at summary judgment, meaning a full trial will decide whether Leadfactors truly owned ConnectBeam's former IP and if it has the legal right to claim trade secret misappropriation. Cisco argued that between ConnectBeam's demise and Leadfactors' incorporation, Gupta unlawfully possessed the source code because at that time it belonged to the bank and not to him, arguing this prevented Leadfactors from suing.

The judge ruled that "possession of the source code that allegedly embodies the trade secrets is sufficient to establish standing to bring a trade secret misappropriation claim." ®

Similar topics


Other stories you might like

  • NASA installs a new and improved algorithm to better track near-Earth asteroids

    Nearly 20 year-old software used to protect humanity gets an upgrade

    NASA has upgraded its near-Earth asteroid monitoring algorithm to model hazardous space rocks more accurately after nearly two decades, it announced on Tuesday.

    The new system, dubbed Sentry-II, is more powerful than its predecessor, Sentry. Astronomers working at the space agency's Center for Near Earth Object Studies can now automatically calculate thermal influences that nudge an asteroid’s orbit, potentially sending it hurtling towards our home planet.

    The so-called Yarkovsky effect describes the subtle and gradual change of motion when asteroids are heated by the Sun’s light. When asteroids spin, one side of its surface exposed to the star gets heated. As it continues to rotate, the hot region enters shade and cools down. Infrared energy is radiated outwards; the photons carry momentum and impart a tiny thrust on the asteroid. Over long periods of time, these small kicks can change their paths and knock them out of their original orbit.

    Continue reading
  • Facebook slapped with an eyepopping $150B lawsuit for spreading hate speech against Rohingya refugees

    Lawsuit claims social media giant's algos helped Myanmar military crackdown on the Rohingya

    Meta was sued on Tuesday for a whopping $150 billion in a class-action lawsuit for allegedly amplifying hate speech and aiding the Myanmar military in the genocide of the Rohingya people.

    The case, led by an anonymous Rohingya refugee living in the US, accuses the entity formerly known as Facebook of inciting hatred and inflicting real harm on the predominantly Muslim group for years. Not only did the social media platform ignore hate speech posts, it's alleged that the service's algorithms actively promoted anti-Rohingya propaganda as hundreds of thousands of people fled from Myanmar to escape persecution.

    Facebook has already acknowledged its role in the campaign, which saw an estimated 25,000 people perish and 700,000 forced from the country. The lawsuit also comes after ex-employee and whistleblower Frances Haugen leaked internal documents demonstrating how its algorithms prioritized engagement over safety.

    Continue reading
  • Power management IC shortage holding cars, laptops, hostage

    Couple of cents-worth of kit causing big problems for the year to come

    The shortage of power management chips is worsening and holding back companies from building cars, PCs and items with batteries or an on-off switch, Trendforce said in a study this week.

    Power management ICs cost just a few cents, and are among cheap chips that include display driver and USB-C components that are in short supply. These chips are as important to PCs and other electronics as CPUs or memory.

    The demand for PMICs has gone through the roof with the emergence of electric cars and growing demand for PCs and consumer electronics during the past 20 plus months. Trendforce expects the prices will go up by 10 per cent to a six-year high of $0.23.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2021