Cooler heads needed in heated E2EE debate, says think tank

RUSI argues for collaboration, while others note all 'scans' compromise secure encryption


End-to-end encryption (E2EE) has become a global flashpoint in the ongoing debate between the security of private communications versus the need of law enforcement agencies to protect the public from criminals.

The Register has written at length about this increasingly strident back-and-forth that is seeing proponents of both sides more entrenched in their beliefs.

London-based think tank the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) released a report [PDF] this week laying out the contours of the privacy-vs-safety debate, weighing the needs and exploring possible solutions.

The researchers have tried to find middle ground in a highly polarized environment, calling for "a more nuanced conversation about possible solutions to the criminal use of E2EE services. It is vital that a range of views are considered in order to identify the key issues and inform a more productive debate."

E2EE essentially encrypts messages at every step of the journey in cross-communications. Proponents note the technology's ability to keep the communications private and secure, away from the prying eyes of not only hackers but also governments that may want to spy on and suppress their citizens.

Others argue that lawful exceptions need to be carved out, allowing law enforcement access to encrypted messages to protect citizens and hinder criminal behavior – a position that logically precludes secure encryption.

Meta wants to expand E2EE to all of its messaging services and this week said that an assessment by Business for Social Responsibility, funded by Meta, found that expanding full encryption protects fundamental human rights.

Britain's proposed Online Safety Bill and its No Place to Hide campaign look to ban or limit E2EE, a move that has been criticized by the likes of the Internet Society and BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT, which have argued that restricting E2EE would do more harm than good.

In a BCS survey last month, 78 percent of IT professionals said restricting E2EE would not protect users and 66 percent said it would have a negative impact on society.

In addition, 70 percent didn't believe it is possible to have both secure encryption and the capability of law enforcement to check encrypted messages for criminal material, worrying about surveillance from governments and tech companies as well as threat actors.

However, that is the path that RUSI is trying to lay.

"The extent to which a consensus can be reached depends on whether solutions can be developed which can combat criminal activity on E2EE platforms while also ensuring that the cyber security and privacy of civilians is fully protected," the researchers wrote in their report, based on writings on the subject and almost two dozen interviews with experts in the UK and US.

"Currently, proposed solutions have focused on methods for allowing law enforcement exceptional access to E2EE communications and ensuring E2EE service providers can access data to effectively monitor criminal and harmful activities on their platforms."

Those proposals have generated significant controversy that has only been stoked by UK policymakers' efforts to sway public opinion otherwise. Proposed solutions include lawful exceptional access, which is supported by UK officials. Two possibilities in this area are key escrow – with telcos and social media companies keeping a copy of keys for decrypting information with a third party that would turn the keys over to authorized law enforcement – and quietly adding a law enforcement person to an E2EE group chat or call, which would not break encryption. Both have been criticized as threats to security and privacy.

Other ideas include on-device scanning of data-at-rest – such as plaintext or images – on a user's phone to detect harmful material, such as that related to child sexual abuse or terrorism. However, Apple developed a scanning tool called NeuraHash and received blowback from opponents who said the technology could be exploited by bad actors or nation states and used for surveillance.

Analyzing the metadata at the network and application levels and legal hacking – allowing law enforcement to hack a device using their own means – are other options with pros and cons.

E2EE is a gnarly issue pitting security and privacy concerns against law enforcement issues. RUSI noted that the European Union's Internet Forum and the Safer Internet Forum are good collaboration avenues for discussing the problems.

However, there needs to be a consensus among "policymakers, proponents of technical measures and those who argue that access to E2EE communications is not possible without severe implications for privacy," the researchers wrote.

That said, the path forward will rely heavily on cooperation between those on both sides of the debate.

"One way of doing this is to ensure the technical community is involved in the development and assessment of capabilities and tools that are being considered," RUSI wrote. "Encouraging a stronger relationship through collaborative research with experts is key for building trust and ensuring tools are properly tested and critiqued before any technical measures are implemented." ®


Other stories you might like

  • Quantum internet within grasp as scientists show off entanglement demo
    Teleportation of quantum information key to future secure data transfer

    Researchers in the Netherlands have shown they can transmit quantum information via an intermediary node, a feature necessary to make the so-called quantum internet possible.

    In recent years, scientists have argued that the quantum internet presents a more desirable network for transferring secure data, in addition to being necessary when connecting multiple quantum systems. All of this has been attracting investment from the US government, among others.

    Despite the promise, there are still vital elements missing for the creation of a functional quantum internet.

    Continue reading
  • Drone ship carrying yet more drones launches in China
    Zhuhai Cloud will carry 50 flying and diving machines it can control with minimal human assistance

    Chinese academics have christened an ocean research vessel that has a twist: it will sail the seas with a complement of aerial and ocean-going drones and no human crew.

    The Zhu Hai Yun, or Zhuhai Cloud, launched in Guangzhou after a year of construction. The 290-foot-long mothership can hit a top speed of 18 knots (about 20 miles per hour) and will carry 50 flying, surface, and submersible drones that launch and self-recover autonomously. 

    According to this blurb from the shipbuilder behind its construction, the Cloud will also be equipped with a variety of additional observational instruments "which can be deployed in batches in the target sea area, and carry out task-oriented adaptive networking to achieve three-dimensional view of specific targets." Most of the ship is an open deck where flying drones can land and be stored. The ship is also equipped with launch and recovery equipment for its aquatic craft. 

    Continue reading
  • Experts: AI should be recognized as inventors in patent law
    Plus: Police release deepfake of murdered teen in cold case, and more

    In-brief Governments around the world should pass intellectual property laws that grant rights to AI systems, two academics at the University of New South Wales in Australia argued.

    Alexandra George, and Toby Walsh, professors of law and AI, respectively, believe failing to recognize machines as inventors could have long-lasting impacts on economies and societies. 

    "If courts and governments decide that AI-made inventions cannot be patented, the implications could be huge," they wrote in a comment article published in Nature. "Funders and businesses would be less incentivized to pursue useful research using AI inventors when a return on their investment could be limited. Society could miss out on the development of worthwhile and life-saving inventions."

    Continue reading
  • SEC probes Musk for not properly disclosing Twitter stake
    Meanwhile, social network's board rejects resignation of one its directors

    America's financial watchdog is investigating whether Elon Musk adequately disclosed his purchase of Twitter shares last month, just as his bid to take over the social media company hangs in the balance. 

    A letter [PDF] from the SEC addressed to the tech billionaire said he "[did] not appear" to have filed the proper form detailing his 9.2 percent stake in Twitter "required 10 days from the date of acquisition," and asked him to provide more information. Musk's shares made him one of Twitter's largest shareholders. The letter is dated April 4, and was shared this week by the regulator.

    Musk quickly moved to try and buy the whole company outright in a deal initially worth over $44 billion. Musk sold a chunk of his shares in Tesla worth $8.4 billion and bagged another $7.14 billion from investors to help finance the $21 billion he promised to put forward for the deal. The remaining $25.5 billion bill was secured via debt financing by Morgan Stanley, Bank of America, Barclays, and others. But the takeover is not going smoothly.

    Continue reading
  • Cloud security unicorn cuts 20% of staff after raising $1.3b
    Time to play blame bingo: Markets? Profits? Too much growth? Russia? Space aliens?

    Cloud security company Lacework has laid off 20 percent of its employees, just months after two record-breaking funding rounds pushed its valuation to $8.3 billion.

    A spokesperson wouldn't confirm the total number of employees affected, though told The Register that the "widely speculated number on Twitter is a significant overestimate."

    The company, as of March, counted more than 1,000 employees, which would push the jobs lost above 200. And the widely reported number on Twitter is about 300 employees. The biz, based in Silicon Valley, was founded in 2015.

    Continue reading
  • Talos names eight deadly sins in widely used industrial software
    Entire swaths of gear relies on vulnerability-laden Open Automation Software (OAS)

    A researcher at Cisco's Talos threat intelligence team found eight vulnerabilities in the Open Automation Software (OAS) platform that, if exploited, could enable a bad actor to access a device and run code on a targeted system.

    The OAS platform is widely used by a range of industrial enterprises, essentially facilitating the transfer of data within an IT environment between hardware and software and playing a central role in organizations' industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) efforts. It touches a range of devices, including PLCs and OPCs and IoT devices, as well as custom applications and APIs, databases and edge systems.

    Companies like Volvo, General Dynamics, JBT Aerotech and wind-turbine maker AES are among the users of the OAS platform.

    Continue reading
  • Despite global uncertainty, $500m hit doesn't rattle Nvidia execs
    CEO acknowledges impact of war, pandemic but says fundamentals ‘are really good’

    Nvidia is expecting a $500 million hit to its global datacenter and consumer business in the second quarter due to COVID lockdowns in China and Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Despite those and other macroeconomic concerns, executives are still optimistic about future prospects.

    "The full impact and duration of the war in Ukraine and COVID lockdowns in China is difficult to predict. However, the impact of our technology and our market opportunities remain unchanged," said Jensen Huang, Nvidia's CEO and co-founder, during the company's first-quarter earnings call.

    Those two statements might sound a little contradictory, including to some investors, particularly following the stock selloff yesterday after concerns over Russia and China prompted Nvidia to issue lower-than-expected guidance for second-quarter revenue.

    Continue reading
  • Another AI supercomputer from HPE: Champollion lands in France
    That's the second in a week following similar system in Munich also aimed at researchers

    HPE is lifting the lid on a new AI supercomputer – the second this week – aimed at building and training larger machine learning models to underpin research.

    Based at HPE's Center of Excellence in Grenoble, France, the new supercomputer is to be named Champollion after the French scholar who made advances in deciphering Egyptian hieroglyphs in the 19th century. It was built in partnership with Nvidia using AMD-based Apollo computer nodes fitted with Nvidia's A100 GPUs.

    Champollion brings together HPC and purpose-built AI technologies to train machine learning models at scale and unlock results faster, HPE said. HPE already provides HPC and AI resources from its Grenoble facilities for customers, and the broader research community to access, and said it plans to provide access to Champollion for scientists and engineers globally to accelerate testing of their AI models and research.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022