Arm sues Qualcomm over custom Nuvia CPU cores, wants designs destroyed
British chip designer unhappy key customer is using lucrative blueprints
Updated Arm is suing Qualcomm, one of its key customers, in a row over the latter's Nuvia custom CPU cores.
The Softbank-owned British chip designer filed suit [PDF] against Qualcomm today in a US federal district court in Delaware.
Arm has accused Qualcomm of being in breach of its licenses, and wants the American giant to fulfill its obligations under those agreements, such as destroying its Nuvia CPU designs, plus cough up compensation.
How did we get here?
Back in 2019, Nuvia emerged as a startup formed by semiconductor veterans, including the former chief architect of Apple's iPhone chips, to design server microprocessors. To achieve this, Nuvia obtained from Arm a special architectural license, which allowed it to create its own custom high-end Arm-compatible CPU cores. Nuvia also licensed Arm's standard off-the-shelf designs to drop into its chips.
Then in 2021, Qualcomm bought Nuvia for $1.4 billion. This was seen as a move by Qualcomm to bring in designs and expertise to create or customize Arm CPU cores to better compete against its rivals. It was speculated that Qualcomm could use Nuvia's blueprints in server chips or adapt them for mobile devices.
According to Arm, though, the licenses it granted Nuvia could not be transferred to and used by its new parent Qualcomm without Arm's permission. Arm says Qualcomm did not, even after months of negotiations, obtain this consent, and that Qualcomm appeared to be focused on putting Nuvia's custom CPU designs into its own line of chips without permission.
TrendForce: AWS to give Arm a leg up to 22% of datacenter servers by 2025READ MORE
That led to Arm terminating its licenses with Nuvia in early 2022, requiring Qualcomm to destroy and stop using Nuvia's designs derived from those agreements. It's claimed that Qualcomm's top lawyer wrote to Arm confirming it would abide by the termination.
However, says Arm, it appeared from subsequent press reports that Qualcomm may not have destroyed the core designs and still intended to use the blueprints and technology it acquired with Nuvia for its personal device and server chips, allegedly in a breach of contract with Arm.
What's interesting is that Qualcomm has an Armv9 architectural license with Arm, which it can use to design custom cores. Qualcomm also licenses off-the-shelf standard Arm cores, and puts these to use in its widely used Snapdragon family of mobile processors. And at the same time, Arm is unhappy that Qualcomm intends to use Nuvia's custom CPU designs in PCs, phones, cars, servers, and so on, which one might think Qualcomm has permission to do, given all the licenses it holds.
Check the fine print
But Arm says individual licenses are specific to individual licensees and their use cases and situations, and can't be automatically transferred without Arm's consent.
According to people familiar with the matter, Nuvia was on a higher royalty rate to Arm than Qualcomm, and that Qualcomm hoped to use Nuvia's technology on its lower rate rather than pay the higher rate. It's said that Arm wasn't happy about that, and wanted Qualcomm to pay more to use those blueprints it helped Nuvia develop.
Qualcomm should have negotiated a royalty rate with Arm for the Nuvia tech, and obtained permission to use Nuvia's CPU core designs in its range of chips, and failed to do so, it is alleged, and is now being sued.
"Qualcomm effectively seeks to circumvent Arm’s licensing model," Arm's lawsuit states.
"Qualcomm’s improper acquisition of the relevant Nuvia technology in violation of Arm’s standard provisions threatens to harm Arm’s position in the ecosystem of Arm-based devices, harm Arm’s reputation as an intellectual property owner and technology developer whose licenses must be respected, and embolden other companies to likewise harm Arm’s reasonable business expectations in issuing its licenses."
In a statement, Arm said:
Because Qualcomm attempted to transfer Nuvia licenses without Arm’s consent, which is a standard restriction under Arm’s license agreements, Nuvia’s licenses terminated in March 2022. Before and after that date, Arm made multiple good faith efforts to seek a resolution.
In contrast, Qualcomm has breached the terms of the Arm license agreement by continuing development under the terminated licenses. Arm was left with no choice other than to bring this claim against Qualcomm and Nuvia to protect our IP, our business, and to ensure customers are able to access valid Arm-based products.
Qualcomm, which months ago was rumored to be interested in buying a stake in Arm after Nvidia failed to acquire the Brit biz, was not ready to comment at time of publishing. ®
Updated to add
Qualcomm has responded to Arm's lawsuit with a statement by Ann Chaplin, its general counsel:
Arm's lawsuit marks an unfortunate departure from its longstanding, successful relationship with Qualcomm.
Arm has no right, contractual or otherwise, to attempt to interfere with Qualcomm's or Nuvia's innovations. Arm's complaint ignores the fact that Qualcomm has broad, well-established license rights covering its custom-designed CPUs, and we are confident those rights will be affirmed.