UK culture sec hints at replacing TV licence fee, defends encryption ban proposals and her boss in Hacker House inquiry

Nuggets from Nicky Morgan's grilling by select committee

Culture secretary Nicky Morgan has hinted that the TV licence fee could be replaced with a Netflix-style subscription, defended Boris Johnson's involvement with Hacker House, and toed the government line on halting end-to-end encryption.

Morgan answered a wide range of questions about the work of the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) from its select committee yesterday.

On the licence fee issue she said she was "open-minded" about scrapping the mandatory £154.50-a-year licence fee and replacing it with a subscription service similar to Netflix.

"What I haven't seen is any evidence, either way, [of] what a subscription-based system would do in terms of the revenue. The licence fee last year raised £3.7bn for the BBC. They obviously have other sources of income as well. So I would need to understand what, if you were going to change, that would do to their income."

Morgan also said she would not intervene in the BBC's decision to abolish free TV licences for over-75s.

 peter capaldi as the Doctor and jenna coleman as the assistant in front of the Tardis - from bbc kids fantasy series Doctor Who

BBC detector vans are back to spy on your home Wi-Fi – if you can believe it


DCMS is currently conducting a review of how it awarded money to infosec training biz Hacker House, amid questions over the company's tenuous links to the UK. It has been reported that its co-founder, Jennifer Arcuri, secured UK government funding because of her personal relationship with now-Prime Minister Boris Johnson.

In February 2019, following an "open and fair" competition, Hacker House was awarded up to £100,000 of grant funding under the Cyber Skills Impact Fund, Morgan said in a letter to the committee.

"I am keen to emphasise that any notion of the Prime Minister influencing – whether directly or indirectly – any aspect of the due diligence, assessment and award of any grant funding made through the CSIIF is simply not true," she said.

During the hearing, Morgan was urged to refer the company to the police if it found that the money had been obtained fraudulently.

She said: "I can't make that assumption at the moment. But the whole point of having a government internal audit service looking at this is to make sure that we take it seriously."

Morgan was also quizzed about whether visitors to had given informed consent for data to be gathered about their browsing history, following a Buzzfeed story last month.

She said she hadn't logged onto to see what people are specifically being asked to consent to. "Perhaps there is always more to be done to explain how data is being used. But I do think it is right that we should understand what pages are most popular, where people are going after they look at those pages and [whether] they are accessing information or not."

The Information Commissioner is currently looking into the collection of data.

On broadband, she said that while the government's proposals of gigabit speeds for all by 2025 were "ambitious", it was still achievable. "I still use the phrase 2025 and so does the Prime Minister. I am very clear in the department, it is 2025 that we are aiming for."

Morgan was also asked if her department was consulted about the arrangement of data sharing between Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust and Experian to check whether patients could receive free treatment. "I am not aware of the issue, I would have to ask internally," she said. DCMS is the department in charge of government data policy.

She was also asked her opinion about Home Secretary Priti Patel's calls for Facebook to cease its end-to-end encryption plans. "I think the Home Secretary made an extremely good point it is a concern," she said, adding it was a particular issue when it hinders law enforcement investigations.

However, as the the European Internet Service Providers Association has pointed out, weakening encryption "will always be exploited by ill-intentioned hackers, undermining cybersecurity and privacy for all users and businesses online".

Morgan was appointed Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport in July 2019 after Jeremy Wright was sacked by Boris Johnson. Previously she was chair of the Treasury Select Committee following the 2017 General Election until July 2019. ®

Similar topics

Broader topics

Other stories you might like

  • Bank for International Settlements calls for reform of data governance
    Wants Big Tech to butt out, and return control to individuals

    The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) – a meta bank for the world's central banks and facilitator of cross-border payments – has advocated new governance systems that promote owner control of data and transparency over its use.

    In a report released on Thursday, the BIS argued that market failures mean that restoring de facto control of data to those who generate it has become necessary – along with requiring permission before service providers collect, share, and process it.

    Those market failures stem from consumers and businesses not understanding the benefits and costs of the sudden deluge of data they generate, as well as finding it difficult to assert any rights over it even if they do.

    Continue reading
  • Ex-Google, Uber AI heads launch ML error-detection platform
    'Soul-sucking' data problems were impetus for the founding of Galileo

    Machine learning alumni from Google, Uber, and Apple have started a new company to address errors in unstructured data.

    CEO Vikram Chatterji was previously product management lead for Google Cloud AI. CTO Atindriyo Sanyal was engineering leader for Uber AI's Michelangelo platform and was a founding engineer for SiriKit at Apple. VP of Engineering Yash Sheth led Google's speech recognition team.

    Galileo, their new venture, was founded in November 2021, operating under stealth until today's announcement.

    Continue reading
  • Don’t expect to get your data back from the Onyx ransomware group
    The cybercriminals trash files larger than 2MB, forever losing them to the void

    Ransomware groups in recent years have ramped up the threats against victims to incentivize them to pay the ransom in return for their stolen and encrypted data. But a new crew is essentially destroying files larger than 2MB, so data in those files is lost even if the ransom is paid.

    The group behind the Onyx operation is overwriting the data in those files with trash data rather than encrypting it, so the data cannot be recovered via a decryption key. Given that, victims of Onyx ransomware attacks are being urged not to pay the ransom.

    "There's a big problem: as the ransomware they are using is a trash skidware, it's destroying a part of the victims' files," analysts at the Malware Hunter Team wrote in a tweet. "Would say, no company should pay to these idiots as smaller files decryptable, big they can't decrypt, but they are stealing files too."

    Continue reading
  • Fake it until you make it: Can synthetic data help train your AI model?
    Yes and no. It's complicated.

    The saying "data is the new oil," was reportedly coined by British mathematician and marketing whiz Clive Humby in 2006. Humby's remark rings true more now than ever with the rise of deep learning.

    Data is the fuel powering modern AI models; without enough of it the performance of these systems will sputter and fail. And like oil, the resource is scarce and controlled by big businesses. What do you do if you're a small computer vision company? You can turn to fake data to train your models, and if you're lucky it might just work.

    The market for synthetic data generation grew to over $110 million in 2021 and is expected to increase to $1.15 billion by the end of 2027, according to a report published by research firm Cognilytica.

    Continue reading

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022